Criminal Law Case Study
Summarize the following cases:
Edwards v. South Carolina, 372 U.S. 229 (1963)
This case involved a protest where 187 blacks filed a petition. They divided themselves into groups of fifteen people. They would protest in public areas. They wanted to air out grievances that their state had policy segregation. All of these had been organized to take place in South Carolina state house grounds. The strike was peaceful because they did not interfere with smooth running of activities in the City. The police came in to stop the protest: they asked the protesters to disperse and threatened to arrest them. This group of police comprised 30 officers. The protesters instead of cooperating with the police they started chanting patriotic and religious songs. A warrant of arrest was issued where they were convicted of breaching peace (Alldridge, 2001).
When they were arrested, they were denied some rights such as right to speech, freedom of petition and free assembly. The Supreme Court made it clear that in the process of arrest, punishing, and convicting the petitioners: the petitioners were infringed by South Carolina of their rights to speech, and freedom to petition. The court made a statement that the rights are guaranteed and protected by the first and fourth amendment from invasion by the state respectively. The Supreme Court termed this act as expressing peace of unpopular views being made criminal by the South Carolina (Paul, 2008).
2. Adderley v. Florida, 385 U.S. 39 (1966)
This occurred in the U.S. regarding whether it was constitutional to arrest people who protest in front of a jail. The majority opinion raised an issue arguing that the county jails are not public places: the right to assembly was not infringed. There was a contradiction between author Douglas and chief justice warren. Douglas was on the protesters side and said that they never violated or threatened or blocked the entrance to the jail. From the first amendment,...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now