¶ … defective regime under Aristotle? Aristotle was perhaps the first political philosopher to allow that all regimes are not the same to all people. Indeed, political regimes are more subjective in their quality, often, then objective. But, after permitting these deviations, Aristotle was quite adamant about the better regimes and the type of people who populate them.

Good men are the same everywhere, Aristotle argues, but all good men may not be considered good citizens in all regimes. Strauss, in his "What is Political Philosophy?" gives the example: "a good citizen in Hitler's Germany would not be a good citizen elsewhere."

Aristotle writes, quite clearly, "If, then, there are many forms of government, it is evident that there is not a single virtue of the good citizen which is perfect virtue. But we say that the good man is he who has one single virtue which is perfect virtue. Hence it is evident that the good citizen need not of necessity possess the virtue which makes a good man."

Only in a perfect, or at least best, regime will the qualities of a good citizen and a good man converge: "But will there be no case in which the virtue of the good citizen and the virtue of the good man coincide? To this we answer that the good ruler is a good and wise man, and that he who would be a statesman must be a wise man. And some persons say that even the education of the ruler should be of a special kind; for are not the children of kings instructed in riding and military exercises?" This special education of the ruler -- which Samuel Johnson also recognizes in his "Rasselas"...

Each has its benefits and detractions, but the common thread is the same: keeping the common interests of the subjects at heart. Aristotle discusses the judicial branch and its selection and its function, and many more nuances of government, but all these wax futile without the ruling power's education to take into consideration the common interests.
So that is the key to a correct regime: common interests of the people. Where these interests are not involved in the decision-making process, the regime is decidedly defective.

Aristotle extrapolates…