Enemy Of Great, Jim Collins Term Paper

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Business - Management Type: Term Paper Paper: #74982912 Related Topics: Discipline, Pharmacy
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Using catchy phrases like "rigorous, not ruthless," Collins repeatedly emphasizes the importance of the "right people." Being rigorous and attracting the right people means hiring self-motivated and creative individuals committed to the organization and who can be guided without being tightly managed. With the current emphasis on human resources, Collins' advice will ring true for many managers reading Good to Great. Hiring and keeping the right staff may be one of the keys to success for organizations. Moreover, Collins claims that good-to-great organizations resist restructuring and layoffs, instead placing an emphasis on keeping the "right people" on the team for good.

Collins advises managers to "Confront the Brutal Facts (Yet Never Lose Faith)" in Chapter 4. In keeping with his theme on pragmatism, Collins compares a&P to Kroger to show the difference between mediocre success and greatness. The two grocery giants started off in nearly the same manner but only Kroger and its executive leaders were able to accept the death of the old model of grocery store. Kroger became willing to change their business model to welcome the model that persists today: the superstore chain with branded items and strategic locations. a&P did not confront the brutal facts and as a result, their business languished.

Similarly, Collins shows how the "hedgehog" model has ensured success for good-to-great companies like Walgreens. Unlike its pharmacy competitor Eckerd, Walgreens implemented simple ideas with remarkable efficiency, merely offering customers more convenient clustered locations that increased profits on per-customer visits. Hedgehogs patiently pursue a goal of greatness, are constantly on the lookout for dangers and acknowledge the need for change. The Hedgehog model company focuses on its strengths and determinately pursues its passions. By understanding what the company is capable of and by knowing its limitations, it strives to become the best in its field. Collins outlines the Hedgehog model in Chapter 5.

To become the best in its field the good-to-great organization also pursues a


Creative discipline is not authoritarian but supportive; members of the organization have freedom but work within a meaningful framework. As a result, the organization does not pursue unrealistic goals and is not seduced by flashy opportunities. Collins suggests that organizations develop a "stop doing list" to encourage disciplined action.

Discipline comes into play in the ways good-to-great companies integrate technology into their operations. Rather than implement technology for technology's sake, good-to-great organizations use technology as a tool specific to their needs. Technology never prevents a great company from losing its footing or discipline. Technology, according to Collins in Chapter 7, "Technology Accelerators," accelerates change and can help an organization remain competitive and on-target with goals. Rarely does technology actually catalyze the shift from goodness to greatness. In the following chapter Collins claims that great companies use acquisitions as accelerators, rather than as instigators, of change.

In Chapter 8, Collins describes the difference between "The Flywheel and the Doom Loop." The flywheel image encapsulates the method by which good companies make the leap to greatness. Pushing a flywheel requires an enormous about of hard work, which pays off with "sustained and spectacular results," and the perpetuation of positive momentum (p. 165). According to Collins, great companies do not perceive their transformation as being a singular, miraculous event. Instead, the transformation from goodness to greatness involves steady growth, patience, and disciplined action.

Finally, good-to-great companies are built to last. In the final chapter of Good to Great, Collins addresses the reasons great organizations do last: including their ability to stick to their core values and their continued ascription to the principles of greatness outlined in the book: disciplined people, disciplined culture, and disciplined actions. In Chapter 9, Collins also describes the difference between good long-term goals and bad. Good BHAGs (big hairy audacious goals) stem from passions, abilities, and what drives the company's economic engine. Long-term goals should reflect the interface between core values and core dreams. The pursuit of greatness can, according to Collins, transform individual lives and communities as well as organizations.

Because Collins' book is well-researched, based on documented case studies, Good to Great is a valuable resource for management professionals. A series of appendixes offers the technical data to accompany Collins' claims that greatness can…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Collins, Jim. Good to Great. New York: Harper, 2001.

Cite this Document:

"Enemy Of Great Jim Collins" (2007, February 12) Retrieved September 17, 2021, from

"Enemy Of Great Jim Collins" 12 February 2007. Web.17 September. 2021. <

"Enemy Of Great Jim Collins", 12 February 2007, Accessed.17 September. 2021,

Purpose of Paperdue.com

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Jim Collins Is an American
Words: 2158 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 97497202

Collins further suggests that "you can't manufacture passion or 'motivate' people to feel passionate. You can only discover what ignites your passion and the passions of those around you" (Farias, 41). Jim Collins also suggests that before searching for strategy and vision to make a great enterprise, one first look for the people who will make it a great enterprise, he claims "The ultimate throttle on growth for any great

Adage, Good Is the Enemy
Words: 2220 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 68350479

Their contributions might be as worthy if not worthier than the contributions of a stalwart organization that has survived decades of market vicissitudes but which has no concrete contributions or merit. Not all is lost in the mire of Collins' masturbatory research, though. One of the most compelling sections of the book is the Hedgehog Concept, which can be applied to both personal and professional greatness. The Hedgehog Concept suggests

Flat 2005 I Was Intrigued
Words: 667 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 22444358

Jim Collins;' insights into what makes companies great is fascinating. What I liked most about this book was the thoroughness of the analysis of factors that specifically lift companies from being merely "good" at their respective performance both financially and from a market standpoint to being outstanding or great. While Collins does not quantify greatness, it is implied that the staying power of a company over many decades of

HRM Outline Human Resource Management
Words: 9449 Length: 30 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 89370006

, 2010). The model includes several mediator (e.g., knowledge exchange) and moderator variables (e.g., self-leadership competencies of actors) that explain why and when this approach is effective and looks at leadership in more of a comprehensive way than focusing on one individual. Such perspectives have suggested that when employees become involved in the decision making processes then this can strengthen leadership. Transactional Leadership Transactional leadership is the leadership model that represents what

Employee Motivation Motivating Employees Motivating Employees Requires...
Words: 840 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 16382912

Employee Motivation Motivating Employees Motivating employees requires exceptional leadership. There are many competing theories of available today. This essay examines two theories that have gained some popularity. The first leadership model is referred to as servant leadership. The concept of servant leadership was first introduced by Robert Greenleafe in the 1970's and subsequently the idea was picked up by many mainstream leadership theorists such as Stephen Covey (Dierendonck, et al., 2010). This

Personal Success Plan Ultimate Success Plan Jeremy
Words: 2756 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 29973680

Personal Success Plan Ultimate Success Plan Jeremy Steele Dr. Kate Spector MBA6210-Building Relationships DO I LOVE MY JOB? MITZBERG'S CATAGORIES PERSONAL Management PREFERENCE SUCCESS PLAN DISCUSSION SKILL SET OVERVIEW FUTURE DEVELOPMENT A personal success plan can serve as the foundation for a successful career. In fact, there are so many qualified professionals in the workforce today that a personal success plan is more of a requirement than a luxury. With this in mind, coupled with the training I recently received, my