Verified Document

Ethics Aquinas Augustine Essay

Ethical Dilemma Group A: The situation with the journalist reflects on the ethical implications of a contract. A contract is an agreement, and is legally binding. Under law, there are provisions for how and when a contract may be broken -- a more lucrative offer from a competitor is unlikely to be among these. Morally, a contract is an obligation that should be upheld. But that is, ultimately a rather weak morality in that in the grand scope of right vs. wrong, breaking a contract is relatively irrelevant. Even the aggrieved party will recover just fine; nobody got hurt, nobody got killed; nobody's rights were trampled.

But ethically, this situation is more interesting. This is business, and there are not a lot of ethics in business. The legal wrangling about the contract is an accepted tactic in business -- you use the system to your advantage when you can, and that is what both parties are trying to do here. Only one will actually win, and it is possible that such a victory might be Pyrrhic.

Ultimately, the lack of genuine harm here calls into question whether this is a legitimate ethical dilemma. A contract does create obligation, but contracts are...

There are plenty of scenarios where the first newspaper would have to consider breaking contract with the columnist to fire her. It would be surprising if a threat to break contract was a negotiating ploy gone awry. Ultimately, the point of the legal system is to provide a venue for the resolution of such grievances. There is no major moral issue here because contracts are never really fixed, and employment is at will. Ethically, it is a suspect move on the part of the journalist, but someone putting their own interests ahead of those of their employer is not exactly a major ethical violation, given that the inverse happens all the time.
The question should be asked -- would Augustine even care about a contract dispute? God has more important things to worry about than contract grievances. This is not a scenario where evil is involved, so really is outside the realm of Augustinian ethical perspective. Aquinas was concerned with principles, and in that breaking a contract for self-gain is likely against his principles. Either man could interpret the action as one of greed, and thus a violation of natural law, but the newspaper is acting in its own…

Sources used in this document:
References

Matthews, G. (2002). Augustine (AD 354-430). Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved March 13, 2015 from http://caae.phil.cmu.edu/Cavalier/80130/part1/sect3/texts/R_Augustine.html

DeYoung, R., McCluskey, C. & Van Dyke, C. (2009). Aquinas' ethics. University of Notre Dame Press. Retrieved March 13, 2015 from http://www3.nd.edu/~undpress/excerpts/P01296-ex.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Augustine Is a Christian Father of the
Words: 3225 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Augustine is a Christian father of the late Roman Empire -- the traditional date of the "fall" of the Roman Empire is about a half-century after Augustine's death -- while Thomas Aquinas is a thinker of the medieval period. It is worth noting this substantially large time difference -- eight hundred years separates Augustine from Aquinas, just as another eight hundred years separate Aquinas from ourselves -- because we need

Ethical Dilemmas a Newspaper Columnist
Words: 738 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The pilot only has a month to go before he is eligible for retirement. The doctor know this and wonders whether, under these unusual circumstances, she is justified in withholding the information about the pilot's condition. Withholding the information would be dependent on the severity of the pilot's heart tumor. Considering the pilot will be flying an aircraft that carries over 200 human beings, the doctor would not be justified

Aquinas Thomas Aquinas and the
Words: 1406 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Therefore the Old Law should have been given to all nations, and not to one people only. (Aquinas: 811) Aquinas responds in these words: Although the salvation, which was to come through Christ, was prepared for all nations, yet it was necessary that Christ should be born of one people, which, for this reason, was privileged above other peoples, according to Rom. ix. 4: To whom, namely, the Jews, belongeth the

Perspectives of Augustine and Aquinas
Words: 1166 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Augustine and Aquinas Saint Augustine and Aquinas are both very well-known because of their theological and philosophical explorations, with Augustine writing in late fourth to the early fifth century while Aquinas in the thirteenth century. They are both well-known for their efforts of trying to reconcile ancient philosophy and Christianity however they did these using different ways. Augustine took Platonic route while Aquinas was more focused on the Arstotelian way.

Ethical Dilemmas Group an Office Worker Had
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethical Dilemmas Group An office worker had a record of frequent absence. He used all his vacation and sick leave days and frequently requested additional leave without pay. His supervisor and co-workers expressed great frustration because his absenteeism caused bottlenecks in paperwork, created low morale in the office, and required others to do his work in addition to their own. On the other hand, he felt he was entitled to take

Ethical to Raise Animals for
Words: 2104 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Fosterfacts.net). Arguments For: In response to those allegations, Bill Mattos, the president of the California Poultry Federation, said that he had invited California Senate representatives to visit poultry farms -- and to see for themselves that allegations of inhumane treatment are not true -- but his offer was declined (Fitzenberger). "To me, it's propaganda disguised as research," Mattos said in response to the report the California state Senate Office of Research

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now