Is Organ Harvesting Ethical

The concept of organs as commodities is one that sets a dangerous precedent for humankind. It turns people into potential banks that can be robbed at a moment’s notice—and indeed some are. With organs being viewed as so much in demand, it makes organ harvesting into a lucrative career for some who do not have the ethical restraints needed to keep one from viewing humans as mere means to wealth. Organs should not be allowed to be sold, because it cheapens the value of one’s existence. As no price can be put on one’s life or one’s existence, no price should be allowed to be put on one’s organs. Doing so only opens the door to abuses and sets a precedent that will eventually lead to everyone’s life being in danger of being stolen so that another might profit from the organs that one has.
Indeed, as Caplan and Parent (n.d.) note, “the pressure is getting worse because waiting lists are growing faster than the supply of organs.” This means that organs are in high demand—and when something is in high demand, its value goes up—especially in terms of dollar signs. This inherently makes organ transplantation an issue that is bound to have ethical challenges. From a social ethics points of view, cost should not be a factor in obtaining quality health care (Fowler, 2010)—yet in organ transplantation, it is, precisely because of the nature of the care being provided and the scarcity of organs available for the number of people waiting. Moreover, as Jonsen et al. (2010) note, a clinical ethical problem can emerge when goals are poorly defined for all involved: “Sometimes the ethical problem merely reflects a failure to clarify for all participants the feasible goals” (Jonsen et al., 2010, p. 18). For the case of organ transplantation, the goals are so stretched that it makes outcomes almost miraculous—like finding a diamond in the rough. This immediately raises ethical issues regarding how one should approach the subject if at all. If it cannot be approach ethically—i.e., clearly and systematically, it should not be approached.
Yet, it must be approached and that is the crux of the situation. The implications for nurses nationally and internationally are that everywhere people are waiting for organ transplants, many do not know if they will ever get them, some may be attainable on the black market (Organ Trafficking Prices and Kidney Transplant Sales, n.d.)—but where these came from and the ethical manner in which they were obtained are questionable at best. Nurses must be willing to accept these questions and resolve them in their minds and with their own organizations so that they are not caught unprepared for these situations.
Nurses can address the problem of the underground sale of organs by always pressing for clear information on where organs are coming from and refusing to uses organs that have no clear medical lineage (National Geographic, 2015). Nurses are obliged to address this issue because they are medical personnel and have an ethical responsibility to always operate within the scope of transparency and legality. They have a duty to only use organs that they can account for and that they know were not obtained through illegal means, murder, or the exploitation of unsuspecting or vulnerable persons somewhere else in the world.
If a patient asks healthcare personnel to provide information on the availability of organs for purchase in other countries—such as in Asia (Al Jazeera English, 2016), personnel should refuse this request because it violates their ethical standards. They may tell the patient that they will have to seek the information from other sources.
References
Al Jazeera English. (2016). Asia’s kidney black market—101 East. Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V6yRKosE2MI&feature=youtu.be
Caplan, A., Parent, B. (n.d.). Organ transplantation. Retrieved from
https://www.thehastingscenter.org/briefingbook/organ-transplantation/
Fowler, M. (2010). Guide to the Code of Ethics for Nurses with Interpretive Statements.
Silver Spring, MD: ANA.
Jonsen, A. et al. (2010). Clinical Ethics. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
National Geographic. (2015). Black market kidney transplant. Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6mM_Yt7Iy7Q&feature=youtu.be
Organ Trafficking Prices and Kidney Transplant Sales. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.havocscope.com/black-market-prices/organs-kidneys/