J.M. Berrie's Peter Pan -- Thesis

Length: 8 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Literature Type: Thesis Paper: #62331305 Related Topics: Arthur Conan Doyle, Dh Lawrence, Bell Hooks, Time Warp 3
Excerpt from Thesis :

It is Dudgeon's hypothesis through this bizarre methodology that the author Barrie and Kicky actually met and somehow Kicky demonstrated his power of psychic perception to Berrie, which of course fascinates Berrie. After becoming very interested in Kicky's powers Berrie than attempts to emulate those powers and in doing so gives Dudgeon's book its own mysterious glow (Haslin).

Once Berrie has become acquainted with the boys he becomes, according to Dudgeon's book, "Uncle Jim" to them. Soon Berrie (AKA Uncle Jim) succeeds in alienating the lovely Sylvia from her husband, and takes "borderline-pornographic photographs of her sons," and proceeds with his own apparently diabolic methodology to "immortalize" the boys as "delightful fictitious characters" (Haslin). Worse yet, and this goes well beyond the assumptions in the movie starring Johnny Depp, Berrie "forges a draft of Sylvia's will" in order to take possession of the boys and raise them the way he wants to raise them.

The book was not available for this paper, but Haslin explains that author Dudgeon "Blends scholarship, name-dropping and scandal-seeking heavy breathing"; moreover, Haslin continues, Dudgeon is "eager to point out that this is something spookier than celebrity pedophilia."

The implications and insinuations that author Dudgeon brings to the table include the notion that Berrie "dooms at least two of the five to suicidal melancholy" (Haslin). Why did Berrie do what he did? Why would a successful author turn to warped, wrong-headed practices with young boys? By bringing Freud and Jung into the picture Dudgeon suggests that Barrie's "perverse nature" is due to the bad treatment he received from his mother. Dudgeon offers that "maternal rejection is a terrible thing" that can "destroy a child's self-esteem" (Haslin).

Notwithstanding those psychological problems and the root of those issues for Berrie, Dudgeon claims that Berrie realized he could be "a controlling force, at least in his own world of illusion" (Haslin). Dudgeon is not satisfied to lay the blame for Berrie's unorthodox behavior towards young boys on Berrie's mother; Dudgeon also hints that Berrie may have been disturbed by the death of his own brother David, going on to suggest that Berrie may have become guilty over his brother's passing simply because perhaps Berrie had a hand in it.

Regarding the issue of Berrie's less than perfect relationship with his mother it is possible (without going to deeply into Freudian psychotherapy) to place Peter's "estrangement from the mother imago" square in Berrie's mother's lap. The methodology that is employed by Berrie, according to Richard Rotert, is psychologically based. The "barred window excludes Peter as a participant" in the mother-child nursery scene, according to critic Rotert (Rotert, 1990). And in denying his own manhood, Peter also denies "the possibility of a mature, loving relationship with any of the female characters" in the story (Rotert). The idea of Peter denying his manhood was a result of his "prior displacement from the nursery," Rotert explains. Peter's "instinctual desire for the feminine, which would normally shift from the mother to a lover, was arrested at an infantile stage" (Rotert).

Moreover, Rotert goes on, Peter develops a neurotic compulsion against adults: grown-ups were "spoiling everything" and so when Peter went into his tree he breathed "intentionally quick short breaths of about five to a second" (Rotert). Peter breathed in this manner because in Neverland, "every time you breathe a grown-up dies"; hence he wanted to kill them off as quickly as possible (Rotert).

Was J.M. Berrie "still...

...

Barrie…is something even more rare" than a genius. He is "a child who, by some divine grace, can express through an artistic medium the childishness that is in him" (Beerbohm). Besides being a child Berrie has "a second passport… he too, even pre-eminently, adores children" and "never ceases to study them and their little ways, and to purr sentimental paeans over them," Beerbohm goes on. Certainly Beerbohm, who reviewed the play shortly after it opened at the Duke of York Theatre, could not have been privy to the dark matter in Berrie's background biography (and of course the novel was not published at that time). The way Beerbohm gushes at Berrie's child-like theme, he too seems to become a believer in dreams and magic. "Our dreams are nearer to us than our childhood," he explains, and it is "natural" that Peter Pan "should remind us more instantly of our dreams than of our childish fancies" (Beerbohm).

Among the scholarly research into methodologies in Berrie's novel, Holly Blackford seems to have hit on a thorny one: the "parallels" between Wuthering Heights and Peter Pan "are intensely revealing" (Blackford, 2005). She doesn't assert that Berrie plagiarized or copied the characters and plot from the 1847 novel by Emilie Bronte. But the implications jump out at readers like a jack-in-the-box; to wit, both novels feature "spectral children lurking at the windows because they are in perpetual exile from the tale-telling world of adults" and both feature "boys perpetually fixated on and unable to accept the women their childhood lovers become" (Blackford, p. 119). In the play Peter Pan Mrs. Darling "is startled to see a strange little face outside the window and a hand groping as if it wanted to come in (20)." Similarly, in the "Satanic childhood romance of Wuthering Heights, Mr. Lockwood dreams of 'a little, ice-cold hand' scratching at the window for entry, a 'child's face looking through the window'" (Blackford, p. 120).

Both novels "harbor issues of female desire for youths who cannot follow them into the windowed worlds they grow into," Blackford explains (119). And Neverland and Wuthering Heights "have tremendous significance in both novels" because both feature "rival male and female storytellers"; there are similar "tensions between the narrator of Peter and Wendy and Mrs. Darling" and the tensions between "Lockwood and Nelly Dean" in Wuthering Heights. And in both novels, "Abandoned children lie at the root of favored tales of human development," Blackford advises. Ironic? Coincidence? Did Berrie use another author's methods to portray his characters and entice his readers? The jury is out, but literature has a long shelf life so others may offer new insights on an old story, and no reader should ever be surprised by what is revealed.

Works Cited

Barrie, James Matthew, and Unwin, Nora Spicer (editor). Peter Pan. New York: Scribner, 1950.

Beerbohm, Max. "The Child Barrie." The Saturday Review, London. 99.2567 (1905): 13-14.

(Source: Children's Literature Review, Ed. Gerald J. Snick, Vol. 16 [1989]).

Blackford, Holly. "Mrs. Darling's Scream: The Rites of Persephone in Peter and Wendy and Wuthering Heights." Studies in the Humanities 32.2 (2005): 116-142.

Maslin, Janet. "For Starters, A Satanic Svengali." The New York Times, 159.54840 (2009)

Rotert, Richard. "The Kiss in a Box." Children's Literature Vol. 18 (1990): 114-123.

(Source: Twentieth-Century Literary Criticism, Eds.…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Barrie, James Matthew, and Unwin, Nora Spicer (editor). Peter Pan. New York: Scribner, 1950.

Beerbohm, Max. "The Child Barrie." The Saturday Review, London. 99.2567 (1905): 13-14.

(Source: Children's Literature Review, Ed. Gerald J. Snick, Vol. 16 [1989]).

Blackford, Holly. "Mrs. Darling's Scream: The Rites of Persephone in Peter and Wendy and Wuthering Heights." Studies in the Humanities 32.2 (2005): 116-142.


Cite this Document:

"J M Berrie's Peter Pan --" (2009, November 30) Retrieved November 27, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jm-berrie-peter-pan-16923

"J M Berrie's Peter Pan --" 30 November 2009. Web.27 November. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jm-berrie-peter-pan-16923>

"J M Berrie's Peter Pan --", 30 November 2009, Accessed.27 November. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jm-berrie-peter-pan-16923

Related Documents
Peter Pan Is Peter Pan
Words: 3135 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Mythology Paper #: 89020729

132). Hence the Faerie Folk came to symbolize the De Danann's "earlier sensual and spiritual connection to life and nature that influenced the beliefs of the Druids" until Christianity showed up, Yeoman continues. This analogy dovetails with the confusion and game playing in Neverland, according to Yeoman's point-of-view. The author dips into the sexuality issues on page 133, asserting that the blending together of masculine and feminine attributes within Berrie's

Peter Pan
Words: 2725 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Literature Paper #: 75967757

Identifying Archetypes in Peter Pan Introduction J. M. Barrie’s Peter Pan is full of a wide range of characters who embody or represent various literary types. For instance, there are archetypes of Innocent Youth, the Hero, the Doppleganger, the Villain, the Mother, and so on. This paper will identify these archetypes and show how they are used in Barrie’s Peter Pan. Archetype  The archetype is an example or representation of a specific type of

James Kincaid, Peter Pan & Grimm's Tales
Words: 2030 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 80617021

James Kincaid, Peter Pan & Grimm's Tales "By insisting so loudly on the innocence, purity and asexuality of the child, we have created a subversive echo: experience, corruption, exoticism." This statement from James Kincaid's work on Victorian children's literature would be later expanded and ramified to provide the central thesis for Kincaid's study Erotic Innocence: The Culture of Child Molesting, a work which inquires into the cultural investment that contemporary mainstream

Fantasy Peter Pan: Resurrected From
Words: 945 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Mythology Paper #: 25086847

The lines between good and bad are blurred, and the ability to identify who is "right" is lost in a vaguely politically correct equal opportunity defiance of gravity. Additionally, a modern adaptation made by Hogan is one that is a true mistake when made by any artist. Assumably working under the impression that audiences are not intelligent enough to decipher literary techniques, Hogan removes most of the tragic elements

Explication of Peter and Wendy by JM Barrie
Words: 2732 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Mythology Paper #: 26539562

Peter, Wendy & the Victorian British Family In J.M. Barrie's epic fantasy, Peter and Wendy, three children from Victorian England set off for a distant paradise of endless boy-centered adventures called 'Neverland'. This land that can be reached by Peter Pan's nonsensical directions, "second to the right, and then straight on till morning" (Barrie 24), represents an upside-down world where the codes of Victorian England can be deeply analyzed and challenged.

Peter Behrens
Words: 792 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Architecture Paper #: 47247526

Peter Behrens Born in Hamburg, Germany in 1869, Peter Behrens studied painting from 1886 to 1889 at the Karlsruhe School of Art, and in 1889 in Dusseldorf under Ferdinand Brutt (Peter pp). He visited the Netherlands in 1890 before finally settling down in Munich (Peter pp). Behrens was a member of the Munich Secession and associated with the contemporary artistic radicals of the day, and in 1897, after visiting Italy the