And as to reportedly lax laws that make it reasonably easy to purchase a weapon at a gun show, Kleck asserts "...determined killers who plan their murders over a long period of time are the people least likely to be blocked from getting a gun by background checks." The perpetrators who are "most strongly motivated" and have long-range plans are also likely the "most motivated and able to evade the controls," he explains.
The bottom line for Kleck is that quick-fixes based on the emotion and passion stirred up by wall-to-wall coverage of a massacre are rarely, if ever, legitimate solutions. This is why he chose the title. In making his case as cogently and calmly as possible, he writes, "assessments of preventative measures based on a narrow focus on violent events that did occur" are "inherently misleading." The reason they are misleading is that they focus "only" on the "failures of preventive efforts." The success rate of preventative measures cannot be measured as easily as the failure of preventative measures, he continues. Moreover, the diagnosis of the causes of violence "is similarly distorted by a narrow focus on the attributes of a few violent actors." more realistic focus for Kleck should be on how "honest advocates" present their proposals as relevant to a more general form of youthful violence, and not necessarily to "extraordinarily violent events." In other words, are there measures that can be put in place in a more general way to stem the violence youths are capable of, prior to that violence turning into a holocaust of hatefulness and killings in a cafeteria?
The fuel is in plentiful supply for the passionate, emotional (and yet ill-conceived) answers and solutions to an extraordinary event like Columbine, thanks to television's heavy coverage. And while Kleck isn't blaming television, he is saying that it is phony to come up with radical solutions to mass killings just because one recently happened. He does admit, towards the end of his essay, that "drawing lessons from high-profile tragedies" might be justified (didn't he say at the outset there were no...
What he means is, it is reasonable for a person or a culture to "make use of the temporarily elevated level of concern about violence to advance worthy suggestions..."
Those "worthy suggestions" (and it seems like any and all suggestions should be given consideration, since no one predicted this mass murder and certainly no one prevented it), according to Kleck's essay, might not prevent "unusual events" like the Columbine killings. But such suggestions might help "in the long run" with "more mundane crimes." He doesn't explain how this might be possible.
Still, having said that, Kleck turns around and said that believing that a worthwhile suggestion can be made would "seem to depend on the dubious premise" that people make "wise choices in times of fear and hysteria." People who are frightened tend to favor actions that "make them feel better over those that would actually make them safer," he explains in the last portion of his essay. And Kleck seems to be restating the obvious, and weakening his arguments, when he writes that people are "less logical" in the "aftermath" of "ghastly crimes." In the end, Kleck, a professor of criminology at Florida State University, finally offers several suggestions that any teacher or parent (and many students) could agree with. Schools should more closely monitor and try to stop bullying and taunting on their campuses; and, they should education students about "male-on-female teen dating violence." As to his additional concern, the issue of "violence-saturated entertainment disseminated by profit-hungry corporations" (X-Boxes, Nintendo, etc.), these electronic games (that both boys who perpetrated the Columbine killings were heavily involved with) are completely out of control. Parents who do limit their children's (mainly boys) access to these violent games are few and far between.
Conclusion: this is a good essay, and it stirs the mind to thinking about possible solutions. But one can't help but wonder what Kleck has to say about the most recent school mass murder at the University of Virginia.
Kleck, Gary. "There Are No Lessons to Be Learned from Littleton." Criminal Justice Ethics
Overall, what Kleck is saying is that knee-jerk reactions that happen after the fact can, and in this case do, get falsely validated. Second, Kleck uses solid data in the form of documented statistics to show that despite indications to the contrary on the part of the popular culture, it is a fact that gun violence has been decreasing steadily in recent years, those events of gun related violence that
Violence in American Schools Violence (a & b) Columbine High School is in Jefferson County in Littleton, Colorado. In the spring of 1999, two male senior students executed a plan to commit a brutal series of violent acts against their fellow students, teachers, and staff. In essence, they took the school by siege and they took every person within the school hostage. There were several aspects to the plan. These domestic
#MeToo in the Workplace With the downfall of movie mogul Harvey Weinstein and the fall from grace of several other prominent persons in media and entertainment, business and government— from Charlie Rose to to Matt Lauer to Rep. Patrick Meehan to Les Moonves to Kevin Spacey—a veritable slew of names and stories has appeared, propelling the #MeToo Movement into existence (Glamour). However, some have questioned whether the #MeToo Movement has run
Laptop Implementation Program - Action Plan Ideal Classroom The ideal school in the modern era of global education evokes dynamic and progressive thought to what exactly enables a student population to excel and succeed in life's endeavors. Truly, this is central to any discussion regarding educational reformation via school and classroom development. The critical component to these decisions is inherent to the leadership at the school to understand that, according to Cause
Internet: Privacy for High School Students An Analysis of Privacy Issues and High School Students in the United States Today In the Age of Information, the issue of invasion of privacy continues to dominate the headlines. More and more people, it seems, are becoming victims of identity theft, one of the major forms of privacy invasion, and personal information on just about everyone in the world is available at the click of
Similar to the suggestions offered by Gahala (2001), Brody (1995) identified several traits to be considered when developing a comprehensive professional development program. Among those traits include the reputation of the trainer, the rewards available to the participants, both tangible and intangible, and the support of the administration. Traditional staff development models have required everyone to participate at the same time and in the same location creating problems such