Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Letters to Authors Smehra
Letters to Authors
Dear Plato,
In "The Republic" you state: "We know that, when the bodily constitution is gone, life is no longer endurable, though pampered with all kinds of meats and drinks, and having all wealth and all power....the very essence of the vital principle is undermined and corrupted, life is still worth having to a man" (Republic, 18).
A implore you, dear Plato reconsider your statement here because it is full of errors in logic and thinking.
Personally, I think society is full of examples that counteract your argument regarding 'bodily constitution' and an 'endurable life'.
You are a logical and noble thinker, yet you have taken things at face value by associating the pleasures of life with bodily health. Do you not think that the physically, or mentally challenged are able to enjoy an endurable life?
It is after all in your argument that an astute bodily constitution - in mind and physique - is correlated to virtues and justice.
Perhaps you have only been surrounded by two kinds of men - those that honor justice and virtue, and those that do not.
It's possible, as a philosopher, of your particular stature that you have been unprivileged to witness the virtues of someone with a poor bodily constitution - least you...
Was he least able to understand moral virtues and justice because he was blind?
Was he only able to understand vices and injustices because his bodily constitution was below your Utopian ideal of human nature?
A say, he was above that vision. Beyond being a teacher, philosopher and honorable being, Cheron had honed his senses to make up for the lack of one. Does that not make him a far better being than you or I?
Perhaps Plato, you should clarify what it is you mean in regards to body and mind when it comes to the subject of virtues and justice. You should elaborate on what is the foundation of a 'bodily constitution' and maybe then, there will be little room for misinterpretation, as I feel, this is the only justification of your argument in The Republic. I find it hard to believe, in other words, that you would be biased towards those that are different to you.
As always, your philosophical ideas and essays entice thought and discussion, and I imagine that was your initial intention. I look forward to your thoughts on my thoughts on "The Republic," and say hello to Socrates and Aristotle - no doubt they share the same corner of the stars as you do.
Deepest Respect and…
Scarlett Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne Scarlet letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a sensuous and touching account of a woman named Hester Prynne. It also has a prologue by the title "The Custom house" that briefly prepares the reader for what is to follow. The significance and detail of The Custom house shall be dealt with later in the paper. The underlying subtle criticism of the puritan mindset, profound symbolism and
"In no sense do I advocate evading or defying the law, as would the rabid segregationist. That would lead to anarchy. One who breaks an unjust law must do so openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty." In that argument, the author also draws a comparison with those most committed to maintaining segregation; presumably, he was referring to those who physically attacked and sometimes killed both African-Americans and
Letter from the Birmingham Jail" by Martin Luther King, Jr., and "A Letter from the Clergy" by some leading spiritual clergy in Birmingham, Alabama. Specifically, it will summarize the two letters. Both of these letters provide compelling reasons for what the authors believe in, and they are both very persuasive and convincing in their own way. The clergymen believe that King's actions, in creating a march that led to many
He clarifies his status i.e. A spiritual leader and a learned person by using well chosen ethos of St. Aquinas, Jesus and Paul therefore puts him forth as a trustworthy person. Also being an African-American makes him the right person to participate in this event because he understands the situation properly. By use of logos he explains the reason behind the actions of the black persons of which the
Furthermore the rhetoric here is rich in symbolism. Dr. King draws parallels between the response of violence to his peaceful protests and other great personalities whose commitment to justice, truth, and love also had unintended and unfortunate consequences. Personalities like Socrates and Jesus, for example, could not be expected to deny their truth for fear of public reaction. Dr. King makes this argument even stronger by also drawing the parallel
" (Hawthorne, 71) This statement of intent strikes as a core romantic value, contending with no small degree of irony that there is a sense of moral authority in the air which bears a dominant effect on the lives of New Englanders. Indeed, this is consistent with our understanding of Hawthorne's critical response to the forces of Puritanism. That the author is from the infamous settlement of Salem, Massachusetts, commonly referenced