Montefiore Medical Center Strategy & Balanced Scorecard
This case study examines the strategic transformation of Montefiore Medical Center (MMC) in the mid-1990s, drawing on a Harvard Business School case. It explores the underlying reasons for MMC's new strategy — including financial deficits, management dysfunction, and demographic pressures — and describes the GRIP framework and dual strategic directions adopted. The paper compares the old and new organizational structures, explains the concept of causal ambiguity in the resource-based view of the firm, and analyzes the Heart Center Value Map. It concludes by contrasting Porter's activity-system view with the resource-based view, arguing that an activity-based management approach aligned with the Balanced Scorecard and the principle of shared value is most appropriate for MMC's performance management process.
- Underlying Reasons for a New Strategy at MMC: Financial deficits and management dysfunction drive new strategy
- Strategic Direction Chosen by MMC: GRIP framework and dual population-based strategies explained
- Comparison of Old and New Organizational Structures: Decentralized care centers replace functional silos
- Causal Ambiguity and Problematic Relationships: Causal ambiguity defined and Heart Center value map analyzed
- Activity-System View vs. Resource-Based View: Porter's shared value compared to resource-based management
- Summary and Conclusion: Balanced Scorecard recommended for patient-centered strategy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper systematically addresses a multi-part case study prompt, structuring each response as a clearly labeled section, which makes the argument easy to follow and evaluate.
- It draws meaningfully on a range of theoretical frameworks — the Balanced Scorecard, the resource-based view, Porter's activity-system and shared value concepts — and applies each directly to the Montefiore case rather than treating them abstractly.
- The conclusion synthesizes the case analysis with a concrete recommendation, tying the shared value principle back to the patient-centered mission of a nonprofit medical center.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective compare-and-contrast analysis: it places the resource-based view alongside Porter's activity-system view, identifies their differing assumptions about competitive advantage, and then evaluates which framework better fits MMC's context as a mission-driven nonprofit. This technique shows how theoretical frameworks must be tested against organizational realities rather than applied generically.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an objective section that previews all major questions before addressing each in numbered sections: (I) strategic drivers, (II) strategic direction, (III) organizational structure comparison, (IV) causal ambiguity and value map analysis, (V) activity-system vs. resource-based view, and a concluding synthesis. This numbered structure mirrors the format common in professional case analyses and graduate-level business coursework.
The objective of this study is to answer the question of what were the underlying reasons for the development of a new strategy at Montefiore Medical Center (MMC). It will also address how the strategic direction chosen by MMC can be described and what factors likely influenced that direction. This study compares and contrasts the old and new organizational structures, and — with reference to the notions of synergy and responsiveness — analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of each. It explains the meaning of the term causal ambiguity, examines the Heart Center Value Map in Exhibit 4 to identify which relationships appear more or less problematic, and compares the activity-system view recently proposed by Michael Porter with the resource-based view (RBV), considering which appears more appropriate to the performance management process at MMC.
Demographics
In 1996, the newly appointed vice president of operations for the Acute Care Division of Montefiore Medical Center faced many challenges. The Center had resulted from the merger of a large urban teaching hospital and a small university hospital, and carried a large budget deficit. This facility provided care to 1.2 million residents in the Bronx. Approximately 65% of recipients of medical care at the Center were either Hispanic or African-American, comprising the largest group of Medicare patients at any institution in the United States. The area served by the Center was characterized by poor housing conditions, low rates of employment, high rates of addiction, widespread disease, and deep poverty.
Patient Population
Montefiore also operated a Home for Chronic Invalids that provided care for patients other facilities could not help, including those with tuberculosis, syphilis, opium addiction, chronic kidney disease, and arthritis. Separate from this institution, the Albert Einstein College of Medicine — sponsored by Yeshiva University — came under Montefiore's operation in 1963. While both institutions remained legally separate, they were functionally joined. The two were separated by a large stretch of urban streets, yet together they formed one of the country's largest and most respected medical centers.
Bases for New Strategic Direction
Management and financial problems plagued Montefiore through the mid- to late-1980s. The newly board-appointed president, Spencer Foreman, envisioned Montefiore's mission as "patient care, teaching, community service, and research," while the majority of faculty held that the institution's priorities were in a different order, with teaching and research coming before patient care. Foreman brought in Robert Conaty as executive vice president of operations, charged with establishing effective physician relationships and aligning the physician community with the new vision and strategy of Montefiore. Conaty was also responsible for managing clinical operations across the continuum of care in a financially sustainable manner.
Conaty worked with Montefiore's 24 academic chairpersons, who oversaw 800 full-time medical center faculty and 750 residents. Conaty reported that the chairpersons were making decisions that benefited their individual clinical departments while simultaneously producing negative effects on operations as a whole. Financial problems resurfaced in the mid-1990s, and a new executive was promoted to lead the hospital's operations and finance functions with a mandate to find lasting solutions.
Division into Two Sectors
The hospital was reorganized into two sectors: (1) operations and (2) corporate services (Harvard Business School, 2001). Functions including purchasing and information services were standardized, and 150 management positions were eliminated through the merging of administrative departments and the removal of layers of management, resulting in annual savings of $15 million. However, fewer people remained to accomplish the same amount of work, stress increased, and personnel turnover grew. It was at this point that a strategic management team comprising all levels of management was formed, with the task of developing a new business strategy. The reason for formulating a new strategy was therefore one of necessity — a need to focus on high-quality, cost-effective patient care, rather than on cost reduction alone.
The strategic management team at MMC chose two strategies that were both high-level and easy to understand:
(1) Be "all things to some people": develop a population-based approach focused on providing a full spectrum of healthcare services to specific populations, including children, women, and seniors.
(2) Be "some things to all people": develop specialty centers — such as cancer and cardiology — to attract patients from outside the Bronx, and maternal/child services to attract patients from lower Westchester County (Harvard Business School, 2001).
GRIP
These two strategic choices became known as GRIP, representing: (1) Grow volume and market share; (2) Rebalance academic and clinical staff; (3) Infrastructure — upgrade facilities, information systems, and technology; and (4) Performance — set targets and achieve them (Harvard Business School, 2001).
Objective of the New Strategy
The objective of this new strategy was to find a balance between providing population-based healthcare and developing centers of excellence in five areas: (1) cardiovascular, (2) cancer, (3) children's health, (4) women's health, and (5) HIV (Harvard Business School, 2001).
According to the case report, a full-service delivery system across the continuum of care — one that was cost-effective and competent in managed care — was required for population-based healthcare. To be designated as a center of excellence, MMC required "high-reputation, high-quality, specialty services for targeted patient segments that could attract a large customer base for Montefiore's hospital and its medical school faculty" (Harvard Business School, 2001).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.