National Sales Tax Term Paper

Length: 4 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Economics Type: Term Paper Paper: #58179994 Related Topics: Flat Tax, Income Tax, Taxation, Retirement
Excerpt from Term Paper :

¶ … sales tax reform in America. Specifically it will discuss the idea of an alternate tax system, the National Sales Tax and compare it to the current tax code. A new way of collecting taxes seems much more fair and equitable than the current income tax method, which seems antiquated and unfair. Some large corporations and America's wealthiest people pay very little or no taxes through tax loopholes, which makes the system, rely on the people who can afford it the least. One expert notes, "Certain business entities such as partnerships, small business corporations and limited liability companies are treated for tax purposes as conduits and pay no federal tax at the entity level" (Boyd, 2005). There has been talk about developing a more equitable system that would be fair to everyone, not just a few. Developing a national sales tax system could help decrease the budget deficit, make the system fairer, and help pay for other government programs, and it would make income tax season much easier for most Americans.

Some kind of tax reform has been on many people's minds for year. President George W. Bush talked about it during his administration, prior presidents addressed the issue, and people have advocated for tax reform for decades. However, simply changing the system to a national sales tax type of system is not as easy as it might seem. Expert Boyd continues, "Tax reform is much more complex than lowering or raising taxes. It implies shifting the burden among taxpayers, or changing the financial activity being taxed" (Boyd, 2005). That of course, is controversial, which makes any attempt to change the tax structure controversial, as well. The alternative tax system under consideration that most people take seriously is a "Value-Added-Tax" or VAT, which is in use in 130 countries around the world. Rates range from a 5% tax to 25% and it has been so successful in some countries, like Ireland, that they have been able to attract more outside businesses because of reduced corporate tax rates because of the tax (Montgomery, 2009). The VAT tax is much simpler to administer and collect, because it is paid by consumers and reported and collected by businesses for the government, just as any other sales tax is, and it is fair, because every consumer pays the same rate, regardless of their income or taxable income.

The elimination of the current Adjusted Gross Income and Income Tax credits would impact everyone in the U.S., but most people think the impact would be positive. Reporter Montgomery continues, "Yale law professor Michael J. Graetz estimates that a VAT of 10 to 14% would raise enough money to exempt families earning less than $100,000 -- about 90% of households -- from the income tax and would lower rates for everyone else" (Montgomery, 2009). Thus, the working poor and middle class would actually pay less than they pay now in taxes, and it would be spread out over the year through their consumer purchases. The wealthy would probably see their tax rates go down, as well, while some wealthy would pay more, because they are using tax loopholes now that would be closed. Experts also believe that the VAT tax would raise enough money to pay for government health care (Montgomery, 2009), which would reduce the healthcare burden on the working poor and on state and local governments who pay to subsidize healthcare as part of their social services.

The tax system should be used to address social and economic polices and change, because it is a way to stabilize the budget, bring tax relief to the nation, and it could fund a national healthcare system, as well, which is a social...


An alternate tax system should not change the common desire to save money for retirement, donate to charities, or own a home, because these items are not consumables, they are investments. A VAT would not tax investments such as these, or if it did, it would tax them at a very low rate, to encourage, rather than discourage these activities. Now, there are incentives, such as income or interest that encourage people to save or invest, and that would not change under a VAT system. In fact, another expert notes that the VAT tax would remove income distortions such as these, and encourage more people to make these investment and charitable decisions. He notes, "These include distortions of labor supply, saving, corporate financing decisions, corporate retention decisions, investment decisions, foreign retention decisions, bequest and gift decisions, and charitable contribution decisions" (Kotlikoff, 2008). This includes estate taxes and trust taxation, which would encourage more people to set up trusts and bequeath items, without the worry of a financial burden on their loved ones and charities.

Another major incentive to the VAT tax system is that it would reduce paperwork and the size of government. There would no longer be a need for the Internal Revenue Service, or its size could dramatically reduce, because there would no longer be a Federal Income Tax, so it would be unnecessary. That would reduce the size and cost of government, because collecting a flat rate tax would be far simpler. Americans would no longer have to file their income taxes every April 15, and life would be much simpler. Administrative costs would be minimal, and more money could go into other areas of government, but there would be other incentives to at least some VAT proposals, because they would eliminate all payroll taxes along with income tax. That means people would keep more of their paychecks to help pay for the VAT tax, and employers would only have to pay VAT taxes they collected, rather than all the payroll and Social Security taxes they have to withhold now, so it would be a savings for employers, as well (Kotlikoff, 2008).

There has been talk in Congress of a "sin" tax on items like tobacco, alcohol, and even super sugary drinks (Montgomery, 2009) as an alternative to the VAT tax. However, that targets only certain individuals, and does not address the inadequacy and intricacies of the current tax code. Most members of Congress do not support this type of sin tax, and it probably would not be part of a national sales tax plan, because so few people support it. President Obama also proposes a greenhouse gas emissions tax, but that would be difficult to monitor and administer, so it might not generate as much revenue as other tax reforms. Consumer purchases make sense to make the tax equal for everyone, and the government should explore this option because of all the positive benefits and the fairness of the tax structure.

One hundred and thirty other countries use a VAT form of taxation, and for most of them, such as Ireland as noted, have found it is a positive experience. Author Kotlikoff continues, "Virtually every developed country with the exception of the U.S. has a VAT" (Kotlikoff, 2008). Certainly, it is still a tax, but it simplifies the tax structure in these countries, and it brings in revenue from all people equally, rather than favoring the few and the privileged.

Of course, there are always opponents of every innovation, including the national sales tax. Another expert notes, "While some taxes are worse than others, there is no good tax. All taxes distort production, depress economic growth, and punish producers and consumers. They all violate privacy and rob us of property" (Rockwell, 2008). These opponents say the national sales tax will collect just as much as people pay now and more, and that it will be difficult to administer.

In conclusion, this research shows that a VAT tax is a national sales tax alternative that might bring excellent results to the country.…

Sources Used in Documents:


Boyd, T. (2005). Tax reform in a global economy: Shifting the tax burden. Review of Business, 26(2), 48+.

This is a business journal that is greatly impartial in its judgement, so the article is more balanced and fair than one produced by a pro-VAT tax source. It is conservative, but it advocates the positive aspects of a VAT tax on businesses and individuals, and how it would simplify doing business in a global economy, as well.

Kotlikoff, L.J. (2008). Why the fair tax will work. Retrieved 12 June 2009 from the Americans for Fair Tax Web site:

This is a web site advocating a VAT tax called the "Fair Tax," and so, it exists to convince Americans that a national sales tax is desirable and will work. This particular article refutes an economist's claims the tax is a bad idea, so it is subjective at best, fairly liberal, and funded by like-minded individuals who may not want to hear the other side of the story.

Cite this Document:

"National Sales Tax" (2009, June 12) Retrieved September 27, 2021, from

"National Sales Tax" 12 June 2009. Web.27 September. 2021. <>

"National Sales Tax", 12 June 2009, Accessed.27 September. 2021,

Related Documents
Federal Sales Tax
Words: 1206 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 79564793

Federal Sales Tax The purpose of the proposed Fair Tax Act of 2003 is "to promote freedom, fairness and economic opportunity by repealing the income tax and other taxes, abolishing the Internal Revenue Service, and enacting a national sales tax to be administered primarily by the states." (Boortz, 2003). Unfortunately, there are a lot of beliefs about the proposed legislation that simply aren't true. Fears range from inflation, lower economic growth,

Tax Law the Nature of
Words: 3529 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 65889154

With regard to the salaried people the federal tax system has improvised a method to flush the surplus spending funds in advance by the mandatory provision of requiring employers to withhold tax from payments in advance which on remitting will be computed as part of the total tax liability of the employee. This method of advance collection is an important feature said to be the pillar of the tax

Internet Sales Tax
Words: 1352 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 79460784

Internet Tax The issue of an Internet sales tax has been at the topic of much debate over the past few years. The issue is a complicated one and the budget crises' facing many states has made it a crucial one. The purpose of this discussion is to examine Internet tax legislation. We will begin by exploring the current status of Texas legislation regarding internet Taxation. We will also investigate the

State Sales Tax and State Spending
Words: 802 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Finance Paper #: 97826896

Maryland 1 Look at the state general sales tax proportion. How important is the general sales tax to your state… more or less important as compared to the average of all states? More or less important as compared to the 6 states we’ve looked at?  General sales tax makes up 9.8% of Maryland’s income, which ranks it 3rd among the six states looked at but nearly 2 percentage points below the U.S.

Tax Revenue Analysis for the
Words: 3540 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 31188106

The general fund collects over 86% of the total tax revenues and is the primary funding source for most commonwealth agencies. General fund tax revenues The largest significant source of tax revenues net of refunds is personal income tax. Reported personal income tax accounts for 38% of all tax revenues reported. Sales tax, which represents a tax on various items purchased by consumers, is the second largest category. Reported sales tax

Tax Revenue Analysis Project Tax
Words: 3010 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 34294644

Thus, the per capita tax revenue is presented in Table 5. Table 5: Ratio: Per Capital Tax Revenue ($Million) New York Activities 2010 2009 Tax Revenue $58,039 $55,804 Total Population 19,378,102 19,378,102 Ratio: Per Capital Tax Revenue $2,995: 1 $2,880: 1 Pennsylvania Tax Revenue $28,300 $27,600 Total Population 12,702,379 12,702,379 Ratio: Per Capital Tax Revenue $2,228:1 $2,173:1 The findings from table 5 reveal that both states record increase in per capital tax revenue at the end of the fiscal years 2009 to 2010. In the New York, the government realizes ratio of $2,880 per