Performance Measurement Of Bond Strategies And Management Case Study

Length: 8 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Economics Type: Case Study Paper: #35698625 Related Topics: Academic Performance, Performance Evaluation, Portuguese, Project Portfolio Management
Excerpt from Case Study :

¶ … structure' theories by making use of a new method. To achieve this, the case study shapes strategies of bond investment centered on diverse term-structure models to decide the best performing strategy. When making use of a "Manipulation-Proof Performance Measure," the case study attains the finding that in agreement with preceding literature, a pro-active method that is grounded on time-changing term premiums may create the foundation of an effective bond strategy, which outdoes an impartial anticipation inspired passive bond "buy and hold" tactic. Nonetheless, this turns out to be accurate for a previous spell when the literature primarily made this assertion. Later on, the study discovers that the passive "buy and hold" method is considerably superior in comparison to all active bond strategies. Generally, it seems that the impartial expectation model has been the most probable justification of the behavior of the term structure for the duration of more current periods. This is as, financially and statistically, substantial higher performance might not be realized if one utilizes data from the "forward-curve" or the "term-structure" to guide him or her in regulating bond portfolios in reaction to term premium variations (Gonzalez, Skinner, & Agyei-Ampomah, 2013).


In the contemporary times, findings have suggested that actively managing portfolios of bond by making use of 'forward curve" data or using the interest rates' "term structure" can bring about a greater and better level of performance. Research studies undertaken by Kessler and Scherer (2009) and Cochrane and Piazzesi (2005) discover that the forward curve is able to give a prediction on the returns attained by the bonds in the future. On the other hand, Ang et al. (2005) as well as Estrella and Mishkin (1997, 1998) discover in their research studies that the gradient of the yield curve is able to offer a forecast of the interest rates in the future.

Results from different research studies have all indicated that active strategies that are centered on, or put together with time varying information in the term structure can create feasible strategies for those who want to invest in bonds (Ilmanen 1995, 1997; Ilmanen & Sayood, 2002; Papageorgiou & Skinner, 2002). However, none of the aforementioned research work has taken into account correctly and precisely, whether active strategies that are centered on information in the term structure as well as the forward curve can in fact perform much better in comparison to a passive "buy and hold" strategy. This is because the research studies did not have accessibility to current advanced "Manipulation-Proof Performance Measure" or MPPM which was put forth by Ingersoll and colleagues in 2007. Rather, the only methods of performance measurement that were accessible to these researchers were all static in their nature and therefore not able to offer any adjustment for the intrinsic forceful nature of strategies centered on time varying term premiums integrated in both the forward and term structure.

Taking into consideration this void in the research, this particular paper will aim to determine as to whether dynamic strategies centered on time varying term premiums can in fact have a better performance compared to a standard buy and hold strategy. A significant aspect in the study or examination of this subject is performance measurement. Active strategies purposely endeavor to change the spread of returns by curtailing shortcomings and enhancing positive potential, and in so doing generate positive skewness in their efforts to improve and increase returns. For the time being, a number of strategies might prosper or be unsuccessful in a dramatic way, bringing about unevenness in the distribution. Any performance measure ought to take into consideration for these additional moments in the distribution of proceeds if at all either skewness and kurtosis or both of them are of concern to the investors. Furthermore, active strategies are dynamic as a result of their nature and therefore static performance measures are incapable of capturing their primary nature.

According to Ingersoll et al. (2007) making use of static performance measures for the assessment and


In particular, the MPPM overrides and overcomes the limitations of all preceding static performance measures on numerous different factors. It can be separated with time (can be expressed as a function of time, time being the variable) and for that reason not cause to experience any sort of dynamic manipulation. In addition, it is curved in, which implies that an individual or manager cannot manipulate his or her score through leveraging. More so, it is constant with evenness while all at once identifying greater performance that is centered on the manipulation of candid arbitrage prospects. Taking these measurement matters into consideration, the study makes an attempt to measure the performance of a selection of bond strategies that are stirred by data that is meant to be confined in the term structure and in the forward curve through five particularly dissimilar performance measures. First off, there is the traditional mean variance Sharpe ratio and secondly there is the one that alters for utility purposes that represent an inclination for positive skewness in addition to mean variance. The third one makes an adjustment for tail risk and the fourth one makes an adjustment for tail risk, skewness, and kurtosis, in addition to mean variance. The last one makes an adjustment for the forceful nature of active strategies. In particular, this last measure is the MPPM, which inhibits the manipulation of performance scores by regulating the return distribution by means of active trading (O Gonzalez, Skinner, & Agyei-Ampomah, 2013).


The main objective of this case study is the subject matter of how to measure performance

Literature Review

The theoretical validations for each strategy are centered on a central theory of interest rates. For instance, the expectation hypothesis emphasizes that forward rates are associated to the anticipations of the investor regarding future rates of interest and therefore create evenhanded estimates of future interest rates. This theory makes the implication that, considering the fact that term premiums are continuous, there is no predominantly proper or special time to invest at a certain maturity. This means that an investor ought to buy and hold bonds with a maturity that is equivalent to his or her investment horizon. Plenty of the published literature, for instance Cochrane and Piazzesi (2005), Ilmanen (1996), and Fama and Bliss (1987), outright discard the pure expectations theory of interest rates as it is apparent that term premiums do in practice, differ.

In spite of this research study, the expectations hypothesis still has not seen its demise. Froot (1989) discovers that despite the fact that the expectations hypothesis is overruled at the short end of the yield curve, there is some support for the hypothesis at the long end. As per Longstaff (1990), for technical explanations at best, time varying term premiums can at the same time be constant with the expectations hypothesis. De Bondt and Bange (1992) recommend that time varying term premiums might be the outcome of doubtful under-reaction to inflation predictions. Longstaff (2000) demonstrates that the feasibility of the expectations hypothesis is virtuously an empirical matter for the reason that in an imperfect market the presence of the expectations hypothesis does not point toward arbitrage prospects. In recent periods, Galvani and Landon (2012) discover that investors who are fascinated in short time horizons are at an advantage capitalizing in short-term bonds instead of making an attempt to seize term premiums by holding long-term bonds for short spells. Taking all this into consideration, it can be seen that a simple buy and hold strategy is still feasible in its own right and not simply a "straw man" approach to be employed to standardize the attainment of other bond trading approaches.

In the meantime, there is significant empirical backing for a time varying term premium, which suggests that investors ought to abide by a more active approach and alter their allocations in reaction to varying term premiums. Results from a research study by Estrella and Mishkin (1997) show that growths in the gradient of the term structure are linked with rises in inflation, whereas Estrella and Mishkin (1998) and Ang et al. (2006) discover that reductions in the gradient or angle of the term structure can point toward an increased probability of future slumps. It is discovered by Cochrane and Piazzesi (2005) that the forward curve can be employed to forecast imminent Treasury bond yields. Kessler and Scherer (2009) spread out this discovery to six other bond markets. Fascinatingly, Kalev and Inder (2006) discover untapped data in the term structure that is not integrated into anticipations. Taking these findings into consideration, investors ought to regulate their bond holdings in reaction to fluctuations in term premiums. For example, in relation to Estrella and Mishkin (1997), when the term structure and…

Sources Used in Documents:


Ang, A., Piazzesi, M., Wei, M. (2006). What does the yield curve tell us about GDP growth? J. Econ, 131:359 -- 403.

Cochrane, J., Piazzesi, M. (2005). Bond risk premia. Am Econ Rev, 95:138 -160.

De Bondt, W., Bange, M. (1992). Inflation forecast errors and time variation in term premia. J Financial Quant Anal 27:479 -- 496

Diaz, A., Navarro, E., Gonzales, M., Skinner, F. (2009). An evaluation of contingent immunization. J Bank Finance, 33:1874 -- 1883.

Cite this Document:

"Performance Measurement Of Bond Strategies And Management" (2015, August 22) Retrieved August 10, 2022, from

"Performance Measurement Of Bond Strategies And Management" 22 August 2015. Web.10 August. 2022. <>

"Performance Measurement Of Bond Strategies And Management", 22 August 2015, Accessed.10 August. 2022,

Related Documents
Managing Across Cultures Business Management
Words: 3178 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 78902565

Need theories discover the kinds of needs that motivate people but it lacks to explain how people decide to behave in a certain manner for the satisfaction of their needs (Campbell, 1983). b) Process Theories: These theories explain the thought processes. These thought processes guide certain behaviors through decisions and action to be applied in response to satisfy certain need. Two significant approaches are Vroom's expectancy theory and Adam's equity

Performance of Credit Rating Agencies
Words: 5610 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 31974604

Credit Ratings The company which is responsible for assigning the issuers of particular kind of debt obligations and debt instruments the credit ratings is known as a credit rating agency (CRA). There are a few cases in which the ratings are given to the underlying debt servicers. It is the special purpose entities, non-profit organizations, companies, national governments and the state and local governments who, in majority of the cases get

Assessing an Integrated Management Framework
Words: 3510 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 22326085

Integrated Management Framework The notion of Operations Management (OM) resembles that of a tree with various branches attached to it; although each of the branches represents a separate icon, their roots are linked. Here, the various branches stand for Logistics, Purchasing, Supply Chain Management (SCM), Management Information Systems (MIS), Accounting, Engineering and Marketing. All have a different persona but play a significant role in the implementation of Operations Management and

Risk Management in British Hedge Funds
Words: 19188 Length: 60 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 89099157

Risk Management in Hedge Funds A research of how dissimilar hedge fund managers identify and achieve risk The most vital lesson in expressions of Hedge Fund Management comes from the inadequate name of this kind of alternative investment that is an alternative: The notion that all methodical risks are differentiated away is not really applicable here, with the Hedge Fund returns, in realism, representing a mixture of superior administration of market

Buyout Strategies a Researcher Works Within the
Words: 3436 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 45332737

Buyout Strategies A researcher works within the finance division of a large alcoholic and beverage company which is interested in expanding the company line of business. The company considers the buyout strategy to enhance the competitive market advantages as well as expanding the presence of its product range in the UK wines and spirits market. A Finance Director of the company identifies Blavod Wines and Spirits plc as a potential buyout

Value-Based Management
Words: 2770 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 60576947

Value-Based Management (VBM) is a management philosophy that aims to achieve superior results (Niedell, 1996). This process measures performance by the value that is returned to shareholders. Successful implementation of VBM requires a successful change in corporate culture, as well as the adoption of VBM concepts at all levels and functions within an organization. VBM includes an integration of performance measurement, compensation, strategic planning, training, and communication (Porter, 1986). The