Promissory estoppel and contract validity in a train sale dispute
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
Trains
For a legally valid contract to exist, there must be consideration (i.e., a good or service of value must be exchanged for money or something else of value), there must be a meeting of the minds (otherwise known as agreement) between competent parties, and the terms of contract must be legal (i.e., selling illegal drugs is not a contract.) in this case, the trains are clearly valuable and are at least worthy of consideration from a financial standpoint, both parties are competent adults, and the exchange is legal. What is under question is the nature of the agreed-upon consideration, as there was no articulated agreement of exchanging the trains for a specific dollar amount. ("Contract Basics," 2006, Electric Law Library)
Contracts need not be in writing to be legal, but the promise of exchange was not made for a specific dollar amount, thus consideration is in doubt. It seems that this is not a breach of contract, even though it was cruel of Tom not to inform the Harry that he had changed his mind.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.