UCC Scenario Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Business - Law Type: Essay Paper: #1586565 Related Topics: Acceptance, Commercial Law, Cloud Computing, Jurisprudence
Excerpt from Essay :

Legal Memo

Acme Box and Container Company v. Long Haul Moving Company

In this paper, I will elaborate on the various elements of the commercial transaction between two companies, Acme and Long Haul and offer an opinion as to the evidences of Acme's suit for breach of contract against the other company, Long Haul. Additionally, I will consider Long Haul's possible defenses to the suit. This is meant to show the ways both parties can offer a proper case to the courts. The essay will provide further insight into current laws concerning UCC. Whether private parties have to adhere to the same regulations and standards.

Development of enforceable potentials between the two parties calls for an offer and acceptance, or what business law labels "mutual agreement" and consideration, removing potential defenses. "During the service negotiation or renegotiation, a consumer exchanges a number of contract messages with a provider in order to reach a mutual agreement" (Johnston, 2012, p. 292). In the scenario the UCC applies and since both parties are companies that buy and sell goods. They are what is termed, "merchants" and the transaction between them involves the sale of merchandise, "boxes" making the transaction a goods contract. A service contract would entail the purchase of services.

The supply catalogue from Box Co. can be considered an offer, which Moving Co. acknowledged, placing an order of 5000 boxes on Feb. 16. Nevertheless, businesses frequently view supply catalogues as "invitations to bid," much like advertisements are. Businesses do not consider these actions, offers. In the UCC or "Uniform Commercial...


This seller can then reject or accept this offer. Acme Box did accept and made it known their conditions: "because of variation in pigments, seller cannot guarantee the color of imprint of any product." Acme or Box Co. was careful to include all significant terms in a clear quote letting the buyer know the printing could be different from expected.

When buying the boxes, Long Haul also added a conditions term stating: "Strict adherence to terms and samples is required." The problem with this is, it is too vague. Acme sent one sample in and when Long Haul placed the order, they placed a formal offer. Any counteroffers or conditions was taken as acceptance under UCC law.

The rigidity of the common law rule ignored the modern realities of commerce. Where preprinted forms are used to structure deals, they rarely mirror each other, yet the parties usually assume they have a binding contract and act accordingly. Section 2-207 rejects the common law mirror image rule and converts many common law counteroffers into acceptances under 2-207(1) (Helewitz, 2007, p. 47).

Long Haul's phone call to Acme on Feb. 1 can be seen by the courts as an offer. Acme's subsequent shipment of boxes may be considered an acceptance. When Long Haul placed the order after seeing the sample and then added the condition that shipment must be the same as sample, they also enforced what the courts could see as a potential non-negotiable condition that could then remove liability from Long Haul to pay for the boxes shipped. However, UCC states any counteroffers; including conditions, can be seen as acceptance, regardless of conditions.

Acceptance then becomes a grey area of interpretation. Under the UCC, an acceptance may be done by any rational means under the conditions. This signifies that the shipment of boxes from Acme established an acceptance making the contract Long Haul and Acme have, a unilateral contract. Since mirror image rule does not apply in UCC Acme's disclaimer of guarantee of color was most likely not considered as part of the offer Long Haul accepted if the courts decide Acme made the offer. As Long Haul's acceptance contained a disclaimer of their own, under the UCC, a contract would still have been formed and disclaimers like Long Haul made would be part of the contract as Acme accepted the…

Sources Used in Documents:


Helewitz, J. (2007). Basic contract law for paralegals. Austin: Wolters Kluwer Law & Business Aspen Publishers.

Johnston, L. (2012). Grid and cloud computing. Hershey, Pa: Information Science Reference.

Lanciano, J., Farrell, M., & DeBole, P. (2007). Regulation: Usiness Law and Professional Responsibiltiy / Federal Income Taxes. Lambers CPA Review.

Wilken, S., Villiers, T., & Wilken, S. (2002). Wilken and Villiers the law of waiver, variation, and estoppel. London: Oxford University Press.

Cite this Document:

"UCC Scenario" (2015, April 26) Retrieved January 20, 2022, from

"UCC Scenario" 26 April 2015. Web.20 January. 2022. <

"UCC Scenario", 26 April 2015, Accessed.20 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Business in the Scenario Presented
Words: 606 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 56206966

The chairs would not normally be expected to be received in a damaged state, so the argument could be made that these chairs were not received in the condition that one would expect from chairs that cost $1,000 each. Security Interest On the financial end of this transaction, the bank that lent the funds to Megalo for the purchase of the chairs did not perfect security interest in the chairs from

Legal Problems Case Scenario One
Words: 1406 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Miscellaneous Paper #: 89084684

Under the provisions, a whistle blower is any employee or exterior auditor. Under the law, the whistle blower must first report the information to a superior officer. Here, the information was initially reported to the head of department, but was ignored. The law then enables whistle blowers to release unclassified information to the press to draw attention to the issue. This step was followed. When proper protocol is followed, the DoD

Case Scenario Grocery, Inc.
Words: 919 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 95033918

Universal Commercial Code does apply because the vendors are supplying goods and products to the stores. "Many of the Code's provisions apply only to merchants or to transactions between merchants" (Mallor, 2003). It is possible that common law contracts might also apply. However, for any issue that arose to be governed by common law rather than the Uniform Commercial Code, it would have to concern a service to be

Procurement the Law Is Both Imaginary and
Words: 1833 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 89002479

Procurement The law is both imaginary and complex, yet affects each and every one of us on a daily basis on a number of different levels. In the business world, the law takes on new meanings and new forms as commercial exchange is guided by their principles. The purpose of this essay is to examine the legal aspects of procurement and how this idea can shape the different aspects of trade

Big Time Toymaker and Chou Over an
Words: 1330 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 96793952

Big Time Toymaker and Chou over an agreement to distribute a new strategy game. Some of the areas covered are whether or not a contract existed between the two parties, objective intent, and how e-mail comes in to play with enforceability. Also we see if the statute of frauds applies to this scenario and the defenses that either party has in the case. Lastly, we look at the different

Business Law Contract Analysis U-Haul:
Words: 4590 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 46964143

Independent dealers must sign a contract that sets forth the manner in which they will operate their rental centers. Often a small business owner will supplement their income be adding U-Hauls to their market mix. Independent contractors earn a commission on their sales. Each division of AMERCO has it own president. All of them must report to a Board of Directors. The Chairman of the Board and overall President is