Wells Fargo Fake Account Crisis
A crisis is defined as the perception of an unprecedented event/incident that threatens shareholders’ valuable expectations in relation to economic, health, environmental, and safety issues (Coombs, 2014). Since organizations operate in a challenging and highly competitive environment, they are likely to undergo crises. An example of an organization that has experienced a crisis in the recent past is Wells Fargo. The company recently experienced a scandal relating to fake accounts, which has plagued its operations for approximately a year. Given that the crisis is still ongoing, Wells Fargo needs to develop a suitable crisis management plan that will help resolve the issue. This paper focuses on examining the crisis using the three-stage approach articulated by W. Timothy Coombs.
Factual Summary
Wells Fargo fake account crisis is an ongoing scandal regarding the creation of millions of fake savings and checking accounts on behalf of its clients, but without their consent. Wells-Fargo, the third-largest bank in the United States, opened 3.5 million fraudulent accounts from 2009 to September 2016 (Dugan, 2017). Based on a summary by an auditor, the number of opened accounts during this period exceeded the previously estimated 2.1 million accounts by the bank, which represented 70% increase. The company also admitted to have opened fraudulent accounts from 2002 to 2009. As a result, Wells Fargo has been under investigations by several regulatory agencies including the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which fined the bank a combined $185 million due to its illegal activities. Since the company is still under investigation, it faces more criminal and civil lawsuits. For instance, Wells Fargo is facing a pending $32 million civil class-action settlement lawsuit for its engagement in illegal activities by opening fraudulent accounts (Dugan, 2017).
The bank responded to the crisis through admitting its wrongdoing, which has deepened its woes. However, an explosive report conducted on Wells Fargo by Pricewaterhouse Coopers did not include its fraudulent accounts that were opened between the years 2002 and 2009. This was primarily because of the difficulties in conducting a comprehensive analysis for this period of time. The bank has been accused of potentially lessening restitution for customers through...
Through omitting that time period, Wells Fargo prevented an actual size and reflection of fraudulent accounts from being known. This ongoing crisis was uncovered by Los Angeles Times in 2013 and has continued to have significant impacts on its operations.
Precrisis
According to Coombs (2014), the first step towards effective crisis management is examining the precrisis stage, which includes signal detection, prevention, and crisis preparation. This is an important stage because it can help in preventing a crisis or preparing for it if it’s deemed inevitable.
Signal Detection
Similar to many crises, Wells Fargo fraudulent accounts scandal had some early warning signs that could have been addressed to prevent the crises. The early warning sign of this crisis was the mounting pressure on Wells Fargo bank managers and individual bankers to generate sales despite the extremely aggressive and mathematically impossible quotas (Morrell, 2017). Throughout the years, Wells Fargo has been utilizing a sales culture and cross-selling strategy, which is a concept of trying to sell several products to customers. This company has played a critical role in the growth of this bank in the recent past to an extent that it’s regarded as the most successful cross-seller in the modern business environment. Despite contributing to its success, cross-selling became the underpinning practice for this scandal through creating a corporate culture where bank managers and individual bankers were under intense pressure to generate sales. While the impact of this culture on the firm’s managers, employees, and customers were brought to its attention in 2011, Wells Fargo ignored its potential negative impact and denied the existence of any overbearing sales culture.
Probing and Prevention
By ignoring the potential negative effects of its sales culture and cross-selling strategy, the firm did not adopt any measures to prevent the problem from developing into a scandal/crisis. The firm’s Chief Financial Officer, Timothy Sloan, denied the existence of an overbearing sales culture, which implied that issues management and risk management approaches were not undertaken to deal with the early warning signs. The…
Write a -4-page academic paper in which you describe a business situation, apply a critical thinking framework to the situation, and recommend evidence-based solutions to the situation. Explain how the concepts of VUCA (volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity) could affect both the situation and the solutionIntroductionThe banking business is currently undergoing fundamental change. Since the financial crisis, a litany of new rules, regulations, and procedures have been imposed on the
SWOT Analysis: Its Uses for Wells Fargo As noted by Giesen (et al., 2010), one of the most difficult things for any business to know is when and how to alter its core business model. Technology businesses such as IBM have been forced to do this, as the physical product lines on which they based their successes have become obsolete. The consequences of failing to innovate are dire, as seen when
Enterprise Risk Management in Wells Fargo during the Pandemic Introduction As Beasley (2020) points out, enterprise risk management (ERM) is especially needed during the COVID 19 pandemic because of the “number of different, but interrelated risks spread all across most organization” (p. 2). COVID 19 is not just a factor that has impacted one business or industry. It has impacted all businesses and all industries in different ways. Grocery chains like Kroger,
Business Ethics and Positive Social Change at Wells FargoIn early 2016, Wells Fargo was formally implicated in a corporate scandal which reflected the failure of its officers and directors to fulfill their duties and responsibilities. The purpose of this paper is to provide an analysis of a case study concerning this ethical scandal involving Wells Fargo to evaluate its business ethics within the context of positive social change. To this
Porter’s Five Forces model of analyzing any industry marketplace first assesses the overall level of competition of the industry actors, the threat of substitutes, the bargaining power of consumers, the bargaining power of suppliers, and the threat of new entrants into the marketplace (Maverick, 2020). Clearly, the banking industry at present is intensely competitive. Even the most casual observer of a typical city, suburban, or even rural area will see
Agency Theory Agency theory refers to the relationship with the principle and the agent, where the principle delegates its financial decision making to the agent. In most cases, the agent is the owner/executive of the company while the principle is the shareholder. Challenging scenario arises as there are two distinct sets of interest which cause decision making problems. Due to this complex and intricate relationship, conflicts of interest arises sometimes where