Women and Cosmetic Surgery

¶ … North American Women Continue to be the Primary Targets and Consumers of Cosmetic Surgery?

In a world in which we are judged by how we appear, the belief that we can change our appearance through cosmetic surgery is liberating to a lot of women. The growing popularity of cosmetic surgery is a testament to society's overrated fixation with appearance. For women living in North America, their appearance is in fact an obsession. For hundreds of years, cosmetic surgery has thrived on women's insecurities pertaining to their physical appearance, and today, million's continue placing themselves under the knives of unscrupulous businessmen while struggling to "improve" themselves. Women's fascination with beauty and their physical appeal to men has always been a famous trend. In the past the art of manipulating ones appearance was a practice celebrated by the wealthy and the famous, but is now so commonplace that it is feasible for women of all ages, races, and economic status to participate. Cosmetic surgery, a phenomenon so greatly overrated, has become a 'quick-fix' solution, to the tedious drudgery of slaving away at the gym or starving with diets. It is a means to eradicate wrinkles, and buy participants a little longer shelf life.

According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, over 7.4 million people in 2000 had some aesthetic defect whether real or imagined, surgically fixed. What many do not realize is that cosmetic surgery has become a cruel business venture, one often realized at the expense of the vulnerable women; Women who have been manipulated and deceived by the advertising media.

THESIS

Throughout history, women have been fed the notion that beauty is all that matters in life, and cosmetic surgery is the answer to many if not all of life's problems. Today, in the 21st century, women continue to be the primary targets and consumers of the media industry. Media manipulation of women's perspectives related to their appearance routinely occurs, as media moguls persist to work hand in hand with the cosmetic industry, feeding society with unattainable ideals, encouraging women to mutilate themselves for the psychological reasons, often with lethal consequences usually hidden in fine print.

HISTORY AND IDEALS OF BEAUTY

The ideals of beauty and what is and is not considered attractive have changed drastically over the past centuries. The history of cosmetic surgery goes back more than one hundred years ago, when a few men began to explore some minor surgical reconstructive and functional repairs that improved appearance. Very early on in history for example, it is commonly known that women would paint their skin and color their hair with natural plant dies to enhance their beauty and the appearance of youth. Berries would often be crushed, the juice from which was applied to the lips and cheeks, thereby rendering a fuller more attractive specimen to male attendants. This historical practice of altering one's physical appearance is commonly noted in Egyptian history, as painted pictures of hieroglyphs depict women with enlarged features and painted "tattoos."

Initially, "cosmetic surgery" was intended and typically reserved as a repair mechanism to assist wounded and deformed soldiers in war. Soldiers returning from WWI with missing limbs and shrapnel torn faces entrusted their appearance to the hands of skilled surgeons of the time. The development of cosmetic surgery received a push for movement from the need to repair gross deformities sustained in WWI to the need to change normal and typical physical appearances. Early surgeons intended cosmetic surgery for surgical repair of congenital or acquired deformities and the restoration of contour to improve the appearance and function of tissue defects (Kazanjian, 250). Today however, cosmetic surgery takes on a whole new meaning, and the players are participating in a totally different ball game. Though many plastic surgeons are still touted and well received for their remarkable abilities to restore dignity to the deformed, cosmetic surgery has also taken on a new meaning. Cosmetic surgery has become a mechanism women have turned to in hopes of changing not just their appearance, but also their life.

In modern day times, cosmetic surgery has unfortunately become a degrading and harmful procedure, especially for women. It is an invasion and exploitation of women's bodies, a harmful procedure that women often perceive as the solution to life's problems. A procedure the media encourages, directly and indirectly. The problem must be voiced to the public.

Modern Day Cosmetic Surgery as a "Panacea," the Cure All for Life's Problems

Cosmetic surgery has become the answer for many modern women, who hope that surgery will help them feel better about themselves, become a part of societal ideals or disguise and perhaps even eliminate the signs of aging. What happened to the idea that 'beauty is only skin-deep?' Is one's character and personality less important than one's looks? According to the media, perhaps the answer to these questions is yes. In a news report in Arlington Heights, Ill. The following was said of women and plastic surgery, "Women reign supreme when it comes to cosmetic plastic surgery." (plasticsurgery, org., 2002). According to the same article released in April of 2002, women performing elective cosmetic procedures comprised 87% of the entire plastic surgery population. That is a lot of people choosing "elective" procedures, and relatively few truly "needing" plastic surgery.

Every year, millions of people hurt themselves and mutilate their bodies by trying to alter their natural characteristics and uniqueness in an effort to produce carbon copies of what society considers beautiful and sexy. Of course, this varies from country to country, however in North America statistically and historically the trend has moved to pencil thin women with skinny noses, pouty lips and enormous breasts. Modern day images in magazines that TV media hail women who have achieved this picture of perfection, causing the majority of women, who do not look like these media "ideals" to feel less than beautiful.

According to 2000 ASPS reports, the number of people having cosmetic plastic surgery has consistently increased, in fact tripled since 1992. "Certain levels of attractiveness can open doors. It can make a difference in a teen's social life and later on, in a career," (Bloch 60). However, the question remains, shouldn't people accept themselves for who they are? The reported rise in cosmetic procedures should raise eyebrows, and point out that more and more patients, primarily women, are falling victim to their insecurities and the need to match up to unrealistic media images of ideal. In a society filled with naturally beautiful women, it is shameful to think that many women live their lives feeling mediocre.

Why the proliferation of women flocking to plastic surgery? One of the reasons is beauty has become a business, a socially constructed scheme with a clear message that a pretty face will get you far in life. As George Brennen, M.D., in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery claims, "A big part of self-esteem is feeling that you look good. We can cure an insecurity in 30 minutes, that a psychiatrist can't cure in 30 years." With a message like this, who can resist an innocent tuck, lift or boost? What this statement does not point out is that insecurity is often deeply rooted, and the idea that altering ones physical appearance alone will cure such a deeply rooted problem is preposterous. Most individuals that have high self-esteem have confidence and security whether or not they fit into societies ideals of beauty. The question doctors should be truly asking is what makes these women feel so bad to begin with?

BEAUTY AND UNNATTAINABLE IDEALS

The value of natural beauty has been replaced by fake and artificial models of what is acceptable and ultimately considered beautiful. Politics have taken over the idea of beauty and transformed it into a vicious cycle by developing unattainable ideals and forcing women to strive to reach those goals. All of the pictures that women and men see each day of models in the media reflect not the true appearance of the women photographed, but a fantasy. People whether adults or teenagers, do not care that the models they see in magazines are airbrushed to eliminate any imperfections. The public also does not take into consideration the fact that these "models" often work out three times a day because they are getting paid for it. What they see are perfect people on their television sets, people that are hailed and honored, adored by their fans. They are people hat the public will go to any lengths to emulate. Hollywood is responsible for making people feel inadequate about their bodies. To often women fall into the trap of comparing their bodies to their favorite movie stars. "Stars have personal trainers, stylists, make-up artists and people to airbrush the wrinkles and cellulite out of their magazine covers - all of whom create an image that is meant to be frozen in a photograph or presented in a two-hour snippet" (Brew I). If every working mother or single parent had a personal trainer, a personal chef, a motivator and a make-up or stylist working with them every day, they would look great too.

Many people want to feel good about how they look," says Dr. Erhardt. "People spend a lot of time through exercise, diet and skin care to attain a certain look, and plastic surgery has taken its place in the continuum of care people use, to maintain or enhance their appearance." Many women are the victims of these superficial plots and one can only hope that more women would ask themselves the question, "Why am I going through with these procedures?" before the surgery, and not after the damage has been done. Trouble occurs when women are looking for a quick fix to a problem that did not occur overnight. For example, a woman that enters a plastic surgeons office for whole body liposuctions addresses temporarily the "problem" of carrying around what she thinks is too much fat. However, if her added weight is the result of a lifetime of diet abuse and malnutrition, a simple procedure will not solve the mental distortion within the woman's thinking patterns. It is likely that over time she will gain the weight back.

BEAUTY AS A Business INDUSTRY

Cosmetic surgery is propaganda, which promotes sex symbols to sell their practice while avoiding the risks that these practices often lead to. As Plastic Surgery Today reports, "7.4 million Americans choose to look as good as they feel!" On a daily basis, women fall prey to society's superficiality and the devious moneymaking business of cosmetic surgery. Whether at work, school, or other social environments, it is impossible to escape society's constant beauty reminders. Advertised products lead women to believe that if they use these items they will attain and improve their appearances thus conforming to society's ideals of beauty. For example, how often throughout the last decade has the use of diet pills been encouraged to assist in quick weight loss? How many people have damaged their bodies using dangerous drugs containing stimulants that can lead to cardiac arrest, in search of instant gratification? Nothing will replace the need to actually eat well and exercise, this is what the media should be touting.

The cosmetic surgery industry continues to grow, feeding off of women's insecurities, as stated in the American Society of Plastic Surgeons report in 2001, "Cosmetic surgery procedures increased 198% between 1992 and 2000." Women must realize that the commercial goal of these advertisers and plastic surgeons is to make the viewers feel vulnerable and depressed, in order to earn more money, not because they care for them.

Ultimately, cosmetic surgery is a business. Like any other business, a practitioner wants to make money. In order to make money, the surgeon has to sell a product. What cosmetic surgeons are selling, is an unattainable ideal. They are selling appearance.

MEDIA AND MANIPULATION

Women are constantly abused by the media creators, who force an idealized image on passers by ever day. It should come as no surprise that women feel different about themselves and their attractiveness after being constantly presented with sexually explicit images of women's bodies in the media every day. Whether on TV or in magazines, in advertisements or newspapers, the media ideal is inescapable. What is most disturbing is that these messages start at an early age when children are brought up watching television or playing with perfect toys, such as extremely thin Barbie dolls with body measurements such as 39,18 and 38. Young girls grow up thinking that Barbie is a beautiful image, when realistically a woman with those measurements couldn't even walk correctly.

An article by Petra M. "Is that supposed to be sexy?" suggests how media manipulates women's decisions for choosing to undergo cosmetic surgery. After reading a magazine or watching commercials filled with subliminal massages of gorgeous women, feelings of ugliness and abnormalities often arose as women compared themselves to the models viewed, and such feelings were a trigger for most cosmetic decisions.

WRONG REASONS FOR UNDERGOING PLASTIC SURGERY

The motivation for cosmetic surgery most often cited by women in Petra's argument is that they want to feel good about themselves. Depression, low self-esteem, and self-hatred have become major reasons for women's decisions to undergo cosmetic surgery. Although these women have no deformities or imperfections, rather a subconscious idea of being someone better and beautiful, that is all that ruminates in their minds.

Self-identity is an important issue, which seems to have been totally ignored by women when considering cosmetic surgery. The way a woman looks physically sometimes may not fit the body image they have perceived as ideal, and their image may not feel suitable for the personality they exude in life. What patients must realize is they may not even be comfortable with the results of how they look after surgery. A person considering cosmetic surgery might want to consider this fact before taking the huge leap under the knife.

Although technological developments have a lot to offer, women should take their time and think about all the risks involved in the process of altering and satisfying society's desired images. Women must realize that through cosmetic enhancement they are not only inviting potentially more hazardous health problems to their bodies but possibly also losing their sense of true identity and self-worth. Women who feel that undergoing cosmetic surgery will change their life, make them rich or make someone love them more should be prevented from receiving surgery, until their internal insecurities are addressed by qualified physicians. Too often women turn to cosmetic surgery as a quick fix for deeply rooted problems and insecurities, problems that will exist with or without physical enhancements.

LETHAL CONSEQUENCES

The process of reshaping one's body is not only financially draining, but the procedure is also a costly experience, for ones physical and psychological well being. For example, after surgery, if you've had an incision, you'll get a scar. This is a fact. Many women don't consider the side effects of surgery such as a scar, and a scar may not help someone feel better about their self-image. A scar might even make someone think they look worse. Immediately after surgery, it is common not to be able to exercise. Surgery recipients will always have to wear sunblock on the part of the body that has been surgically altered. The skin affected in surgery will be drastically affected by exposure to hot, cold, or windy conditions.

Some people are going into the surgery thinking that it will solve their problems, so they go ahead with it. In the end, people are more depressed after the surgery because they do not like the way they look. Surgery isn't guaranteed. What if you aren't satisfied? It should be carefully thought out. There is pain. Recovery can be lengthy and uncomfortable. Moreover, there can be complications of anesthesia, infection, bleeding, and unfavorable scar," says Ross Rudolph, head of plastic surgery. There have also been several disaster stories, which are seldom talked about or mentioned on any advertising ads. In 1995, Physician Insurers Association of America, which collects data on malpractice claims, was asked to check its database of over 150,000 cases involving cosmetic procedures. There were 2,600 claims from Jan. '85- Dec. '95. Thirty of those cases involved deaths," (Podolsky 74). That is a high death rate. Are these death rates mentioned to the patients who are considering going through with cosmetic surgery? Occasionally in the media one hears a story about a woman who died on the table of a surgeon conducting liposuction. These stories should be more adequately covered in the media.