Alienation in Faulkner's Emily and Eliot's Prufrock
This essay examines the theme of self-imposed alienation in William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily" and T.S. Eliot's "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock." Rather than treating alienation as something imposed from outside, the paper argues that both protagonists willingly withdraw from the communities and relationships around them. Through close reading of literary techniques — particularly imagery and the treatment of time — the essay traces how Emily Grierson's neurotic attachment to the past and Prufrock's paralyzing indecision lead each character into isolation. The paper concludes that both works function as cautionary portraits of individuals who choose detachment over engagement, ultimately mourning a life they never allowed themselves to live.
- Introduction: Alienation as a Choice: Both protagonists willingly alienate themselves from society
- Establishing Mood and the Alienated Protagonist: Authors use opening tone to signal self-imposed isolation
- Neurotic Behavior in Emily and Prufrock: Both characters exhibit neurosis rooted in fear and avoidance
- Imagery as a Vehicle for Alienation: Death and decay imagery reinforce themes of stagnation
- Time, Stasis, and the Inability to Move Forward: Obsession with time deepens each protagonist's alienation
- Conclusion: Warnings Against Self-Imposed Isolation: Both works warn against choosing detachment over engagement
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The thesis is clearly stated in the introduction and consistently supported throughout: alienation in both works is a voluntary choice, not an external imposition.
- The paper maintains a parallel structure, moving through each literary technique — mood, neurosis, imagery, and time — by examining both texts side by side, which makes comparison easy to follow.
- Textual evidence is woven into the argument at each stage, with direct quotations grounding every analytical claim in specific passages from the primary sources.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates comparative literary analysis: the writer identifies shared thematic and technical features across two distinct texts (a short story and a poem) and uses them to develop a unified argument. By treating imagery and time as parallel analytical lenses applied to both works, the essay shows how different genres can be examined together when they share a common thematic concern.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis paragraph establishing alienation as a deliberate choice. It then moves through mood and character introduction, neurotic behavior in each protagonist, imagery (death and decay in Faulkner; fog and stasis in Eliot), and the role of time in each work. A concluding paragraph synthesizes the argument and frames both works as cautionary tales. The structure is thematic rather than text-by-text, keeping both works in dialogue throughout.
Alienation is a curious thing. While we would like to think that it is something that happens to people against their will, that is often not the case. Two works of literature that demonstrate this point are "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner and "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock" by T.S. Eliot. Both works feature protagonists who are alienated from the world in which they live — and who are, to a significant degree, willing participants in that alienation. Emily Grierson has no intention of blending in with the community in Jefferson. She is simply too set in her ways to want to do such a thing. She chooses not to grow and change with those around her and, as a result, becomes an eccentric, neurotic old woman. Similarly, the protagonist in "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock" does not want to fit into his surroundings. He spends so much time obsessing over what he will do, his clothing, his words, the passing of time, and the importance of striking up conversation with others, that he does absolutely nothing — literally wasting his life away. To emphasize alienation, both authors utilize the literary techniques of imagery and the treatment of time.
Alienation might seem like an unnatural condition, but the protagonists in these works illustrate how it can be a matter of choice. In "A Rose for Emily," Emily is quite content living like a hermit. She stays in her home most of the time, and the community seems more troubled by this than she does. She rarely leaves, especially after her father dies. By establishing the story this way, Faulkner prepares the reader for her eccentric, neurotic behavior. Emily's personality is well suited to the kind of mystery Faulkner is constructing, because she herself is a mystery. The mood is set from the opening of the story, which begins with a funeral — a tone that signals a suspenseful, somber tale.
The protagonist in "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock" leads the reader down a path of complete avoidance. His journey illustrates the life he has left behind by choosing not to become involved with anyone. He experiences remorse for a life that could have been, and this remorse is riddled with indecision. That indecision becomes a primary aspect of the poem, which Eliot introduces with a quote from Dante's Inferno. The allusion to hell is deliberate and signals to the reader what lies in store for the protagonist. The poet proceeds to describe the protagonist's particular hell on earth — a hell that is largely self-induced, as the protagonist has alienated himself from all kinds of relationships. Eliot reinforces this mood with the poem's first arresting image: a "patient etherised upon a table" (Eliot 3). Both authors thus establish tone by carefully crafting mood from the very opening of their work.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.