Aluminum vs. Steel Horse Shoes for the Performance Horse
This paper examines the comparative advantages of aluminum horseshoes over traditional steel horseshoes for performance horses. Drawing on veterinary and animal science research, it traces the history of aluminum horseshoes from their early use in Quarter Horse shows in the 1970s through their established role in racing. The paper evaluates evidence related to animal welfare, including the treatment of navicular disease and hoof cracking, and reviews a kinematic study comparing carpal angles in horses shod with each material. The paper concludes that aluminum horseshoes are superior to steel in most performance contexts, offering reduced impact, greater speed, and improved orthopedic outcomes for horses suffering from degenerative conditions.
- Introduction: Overview of horseshoe material debate and aluminum's promise
- Material Selection and Animal Welfare: Principles guiding safe material choice for horses
- History and Early Use of Aluminum Horseshoes: Aluminum shoes traced to 1970s Quarter Horse shows
- Navicular Disease and Orthopedic Considerations: Aluminum shoes aid horses with navicular disease
- Additional Conditions Benefited by Proper Horseshoes: Horseshoes aid hoof cracking and gait management
- Kinematic Evidence Favoring Aluminum: Study shows larger carpal angle with aluminum shoes
- Conclusion: Aluminum superior to steel in most performance contexts
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds its claims in multiple cited sources across veterinary, farrier, and animal science literature, lending credibility to its comparative argument.
- It moves logically from general principles of material selection to specific clinical conditions (navicular disease, hoof cracking) before arriving at a kinematic study, building a layered case for aluminum's advantages.
- It acknowledges unresolved debates — such as the true cause of navicular disease — which demonstrates intellectual honesty and strengthens rather than weakens the overall argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a comparative analysis structure, systematically evaluating aluminum against steel across multiple criteria: weight, impact transmission, orthopedic outcomes, and speed. By applying this framework consistently, the author builds a cumulative argument rather than relying on a single piece of evidence, which is a hallmark of evidence-based academic writing in the applied sciences.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad framing of the debate around horseshoe materials, then narrows to animal welfare principles, historical context, disease-specific applications, and finally a direct kinematic experiment. Each section adds a new dimension — historical, clinical, or empirical — before the conclusion synthesizes all threads. This funnel structure, moving from general context to specific evidence, is well-suited to persuasive academic essays in veterinary and animal science fields.
Introduction
There is a longstanding debate among animal welfare experts over the correct way to treat and handle animals. Some believe that the best approach is through entirely natural means — that is, without the use of shoes of any material. Such debates are inherently subjective and therefore very difficult to resolve objectively. Among the questions subject to discussion is whether the material used to create a horseshoe has any meaningful effect on the welfare of the horse wearing it.
It has been established that the first horseshoes were designed to improve the longevity of a horse's ability to work and to increase the individual animal's performance across various disciplines. Horseshoes have been made of strong metals since their inception; primarily they are made of iron, though other materials have also been used. Racehorses have been shod with aluminum horseshoes for some time, as this metal is extremely lightweight, malleable, and durable — properties that allow for speedier movement by the animals.
The question then becomes whether aluminum horseshoes would prove a viable replacement for traditional steel horseshoes in disciplines beyond horse racing. It is also important to consider that not all horses are physiologically similar, and this may have a significant impact on how certain materials affect a particular breed. Above all, researchers have concluded that under most circumstances, horseshoes made of aluminum are superior to those made from steel.
Works Cited
Balch, O., Butler, D., & Collier, M. (1997). Balancing the normal foot. Equine Veterinary Education, 9(3): 143–54.
Crisan, M., Lopez, J., Cjope, K., Muste, A., & Damian, A. (2009). Studies regarding treatment in navicular disease. Veterinary Medicine, 66(1).
Gore, R. (2012). Horse shoes: Pros and cons. Equestrian Life.
Huguet, E., & Duberstein, K. (2012). Effects of steel and aluminum shoes on forelimb kinematics in stock-type horses as measured at the trot. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science, 10 February.
Koepsich, W. (1996). Using aluminum shoes on Quarter Horses. Anvil Magazine. Retrieved 22 March 2012, from http://www.anvilmag.com/farrier/usalsonq.htm
Rooney, J. (1998). Navicular disease. Retrieved from
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.