This paper examines whether The Amazing Race qualifies as a reality TV series, a game show, or a hybrid of both. By analyzing the episode "Not a Well Rounded Athlete," the paper identifies how the show blends voyeuristic, unscripted elements characteristic of reality TV with the structured competition and prize-based format of traditional game shows. Drawing on definitions from media scholars and industry sources, the paper concludes that The Amazing Race is best classified as a "reality game show" — a hybrid genre that has grown increasingly common in contemporary television. The paper also briefly considers opposing viewpoints and reflects on the broader implications for how television genres are defined and categorized.
Over the last several years, reality TV has become a popular genre. This is because it mirrors events occurring in real life while also incorporating elements of drama and competition. As a result, the line between reality programs and game shows has become increasingly blurry.
To fully understand these differences requires comparing each type with the other. This will be accomplished by examining an episode of The Amazing Race and using it to determine whether the series is best classified as a game show or a reality TV series. The findings will also illustrate the show's influence on society and the way such programs are produced.
The biggest difference between reality TV and game shows is the voyeur element. Voyeurism, in this context, refers to the viewer feeling as though they are part of the unfolding events — watching from a neutral perspective. This means the show develops naturally with little to no influence from writers. The basic idea is to capture the way people interact with each other in a natural setting.
However, another format has evolved in recent years: the reality game show. This is a hybrid of both genres, combining select amounts of voyeurism with an otherwise pre-scripted format. As a result, the line between the two has become ambiguous.
The Amazing Race is considered a reality game show because it uses elements of reality TV augmented with a scripted format at select points. These elements are designed to provide viewers with a sense of excitement and realism, mirroring many of the experiences one might expect from a traditional game show.
According to Boelcke (2012), "One of the main types of reality television shows are competition-based shows. According to the Writer's Guild of America, talent competition programs are classified as reality television and game shows." This observation illustrates how The Amazing Race functions as a combination of both formats — two elements that together add excitement and drama to the program.
Evidence of this hybrid classification can be seen in the episode titled "Not a Well Rounded Athlete." In this episode, four teams are traveling to Mallorca, Spain — the hometown of Rafael Nadal. During the episode, contestants Natalie and Nadiya experience car trouble, slowing their progress and leaving them distressed about falling behind the other teams.
Their objective is to locate a traditional Moroccan show featuring devils and demons, where they will receive their next clue and advance toward winning the cash prize. Meanwhile, the twins, the Chippendales, and Trey and Lexi all find the Moroccan devils and demons simultaneously. The three teams begin chasing them around before ultimately deciding to work together to reach their shared objectives. They then locate their next clue, directing everyone to head to the Centro de Alto Rendimiento.
These events demonstrate how The Amazing Race incorporates key elements from both reality TV and game shows. The reality TV dimension is evident in the tension and drama the contestants experience — particularly with Natalie and Nadiya's car trouble, a situation relatable to everyday life. The fact that viewers can ride along with them in real time adds a sense of authenticity to the program.
At the same time, game show elements are clearly present through the rivalries between competing teams, which heighten the sense of competition and excitement. The elimination of one team each week further reinforces the structured, high-stakes format typical of a game show.
"Some classify show as pure game show"
These contrasting views tend to rely on a narrower definition of each genre. What makes the broader classification used in this analysis more persuasive is that it accounts for the specific elements the two genres share. When both voyeuristic realism and structured competition are present, the hybrid "reality game show" label more accurately describes what The Amazing Race delivers to its audience.
The Amazing Race is best classified as a reality game show. It achieves this through the simultaneous use of voyeurism and structured competition between teams, which together deliver both realism and excitement. This combination is what makes the show popular across a wide demographic of viewers.
The broader implication of this classification is that television genres are continually evolving. As hybrid formats become more common, media scholars, industry professionals, and classification bodies will need more nuanced definitions to accurately describe and categorize the programs being produced.
Boelcke, Allison. "Definition of Reality TV." eHow, 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2013.
Gunkee, Alice. "Reality Game Shows." Yahoo Voices, 2009. Web. 15 Feb. 2013.
Murray, Susan. Reality TV. New York: NYU Press, 2009. Print.
"Not a Well Rounded Athlete." TV.com, 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2013.
"The Difference between Reality." SF Gate, 2008. Web. 15 Feb. 2013.
You’re 89% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.