APA Code of Ethics and Military Interrogation of Detainees
This paper examines the tensions between the American Psychological Association's (APA) code of ethics and the involvement of psychologists in military interrogation of detainees following the September 11 attacks. It analyzes the merits and shortcomings of the APA's Policy on Ethics and National Security (PENS) report, changes in APA public policy, and the boundaries psychologists face when operating within national security settings. The paper also explores how U.S. policies on detainees, the influence of Pentagon and CIA on the APA, and conflicts between domestic and international law — including the Geneva Convention — have created ethical dilemmas for psychologists working in or around interrogation environments.
- Introduction: APA ethics under scrutiny in interrogation contexts
- Merits, Demerits, and Biases of the PENS Task Force: PENS report strengths, gaps, and internal contradictions
- Changes in APA Public Policy: APA policy amendments banning psychologist interrogation roles
- APA Ethical Principles and Psychologists' Involvement in Military Interrogation: Pentagon influence undermines psychologist reporting ability
- APA Code of Conduct and Rights of Patients and Clients: APA principles align with UN human rights standards
- Impact of U.S. Policies on Detainees: Legal gaps leave detainees without institutional protection
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper draws directly on primary sources — the APA Ethics Code, the PENS report, General Principle D, and UN human rights declarations — giving its arguments documentary grounding.
- It maintains a balanced critical stance, acknowledging both the APA's stated commitments and the institutional failures that undermined them, particularly through Pentagon and CIA influence.
- The discussion of specific PENS report contradictions (Principle 2 vs. Principle 7) is a strong analytical move that demonstrates close reading of policy documents.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates policy analysis through internal contradiction identification. By juxtaposing specific numbered principles within the same APA document — one prohibiting participation in torture and another permitting national security roles — the author reveals structural ambiguity in official ethics guidance. This technique of using a document against itself is a hallmark of rigorous policy critique.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a framing introduction establishing the core controversy, then moves through a sequence of increasingly specific analytical sections: a critique of the PENS task force, a review of policy amendments, an evaluation of ethical boundaries, a discussion of patient/client rights under APA principles, and finally an examination of the real-world impact on detainees. Each section adds a new layer to the central argument that APA's ethical framework, despite revisions, has struggled to protect both psychologists and detainees from institutional pressure.
Introduction
United States interrogation policies and rules regarding detainees have been greatly criticized following the discovery of "black site" prisons outside the territory of the United States. While the American Psychological Association (APA) has extended its cooperation to law enforcement agencies with reference to the interrogation of war detainees, the APA's regulations and code of ethics have been receiving significant criticism from psychologists and human rights organizations alike. There is serious concern about the objectivity and effectiveness of psychologists when they are involved in interrogation sessions of international detainees conducted by agencies such as the Pentagon and CIA. These sessions have been found to be profoundly inhumane and brutal, violating the fundamental principles of both the APA code of ethics and international law.
Considering the nature of typical ethical conflicts faced by military and intelligence personnel, ethical consultation should be sought when professional ethics conflict with the objectives of activities undertaken by these personnel. This applies specifically with reference to the APA Ethical Principles and Code of Conduct related to the resolution of ethical issues. According to APA standards, "misuse of psychologists' work, conflicts between ethics and law, regulations, or other governing legal authority, conflicts between ethics and organizational demands, and reporting ethical violations" are all areas requiring professional consultation from the Ethics Committee (APA Ethics Committee, 2010, para. 1).
Compliance with ethical psychological standards in interrogation settings has been a growing concern for APA authorities. Considering the implications of interrogation methods on psychologists, it has been declared that psychologists shall not be present during interrogation sessions involving torture or physical and mental abuse. The American Psychological Association has issued various public statements condemning torture as unethical and unacceptable, yet it has chosen not to make these statements enforceable on its own membership through inclusion in the enforceable section of its ethics code (Pope, 2008).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.