Bartleby's Ghost-Like Symbolism in Melville's Story
This essay examines how Herman Melville uses physical description, foreshadowing, and ghostly imagery in "Bartleby, the Scrivener" to portray the title character as figuratively dead long before his literal demise. From Bartleby's pallid appearance and mechanical behavior to his refusal to eat, speak, or leave the office, the paper traces how each descriptive detail accumulates into a portrait of a man haunting the living world. The essay also considers the narrator's paralyzed response to Bartleby and how the office environment — with its dead brick walls — reinforces the story's pervasive death symbolism. Ultimately, the essay argues that Bartleby's ghostly existence reflects a soul already extinguished.
- Introduction: Foreshadowing Bartleby's Strangeness: Narrator foreshadows Bartleby's mysterious, death-like nature
- Physical Description as Death Imagery: Pale, lean features prefigure Bartleby's self-starvation death
- The Narrator's Reaction and Bartleby's Emotional Flatness: Narrator's paralysis and sympathy for Bartleby's flat affect
- Bartleby as a Living Ghost: Bartleby haunts the office like a spectral presence
- The Office as a Space of Death: Dead brick walls mirror Bartleby's detached, tortured soul
- Haunting the Building: Bartleby's Refusal to Leave: Bartleby refuses to leave, embodying a true living ghost
- Conclusion: Exorcised from Wall Street: Bartleby removed and dies exactly as he lived
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It builds its central argument — that Bartleby is figuratively dead before he literally dies — through sustained close reading of specific textual details, including color imagery (pale, gray, white), physical posture (motionless, immovable), and the narrator's language (ghost, apparition, fixture).
- Each paragraph advances the ghost metaphor progressively, moving from first impressions to increasing ghostliness to Bartleby's eventual removal, giving the essay a clear developmental arc.
- Direct quotations from the text are woven smoothly into analytical sentences, demonstrating how to integrate evidence without letting quotes stand alone.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates cumulative close reading — rather than making one large claim and defending it with a single block of evidence, the writer layers multiple small textual details (diet, eyes, clothing, voice, posture) to build a progressively stronger interpretation. This technique is especially effective in literary analysis because it shows that meaning emerges from pattern, not from isolated moments.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by establishing narrative anticipation through foreshadowing, then moves into detailed physical description, the narrator's emotional response, the ghost metaphor, the symbolic setting, Bartleby's refusal to leave, and a brief conclusion linking his life and death. Each section adds a new dimension to the central thesis rather than repeating it, keeping the argument moving forward throughout.
Introduction: Foreshadowing Bartleby's Strangeness
Bartleby is described as "the strangest" scrivener the narrator has ever encountered in his long career, and with this remark the narrator foreshadows Bartleby's eventual demise long before the scrivener enters the office. The reader anticipates Bartleby's entry, especially after the narrator describes Turkey, Nippers, and Ginger Nut. After these three less-than-perfect employees, one might expect Bartleby to appear comparatively ordinary. Yet Bartleby remains a man of mystery. The first physical description offered is that he was "a motionless young man," which bears direct testimony to the title character's personality. Bartleby's physical characteristics make him well-suited for the profession of law scrivener, for the job is itself tedious, repetitive, and "motionless." The narrator also notes that his first impressions of Bartleby were that he was "pallidly neat, pitiably respectable, incurably forlorn."
Not simply foreshadowing but direct inferences about the story's outcome provide clues as to how Melville's narrative will end. Bartleby is not merely "motionless" — he is "singularly sedate." His "young" age is absolutely ironic given the catatonic state in which he conducts himself. It is as if the man is already dead when he reaches the office. Bartleby does not speak; he is eerily "quiet" and performs his job robotically. The narrator describes Bartleby as working "silently, palely, mechanically." The only words Bartleby utters are those he will repeat again and again throughout the brief course of his employment: "I would prefer not to."
Physical Description as Death Imagery
Bartleby's face is "leanly composed," which foreshadows his eventual death by self-starvation. The description of Bartleby's limited diet of ginger nuts also presages the manner by which his body deteriorates. His eyes are "gray" and "dimly calm," alluding to Bartleby's deathly visage. His face is also "pale," and the narrator describes his mouth as "white" and "attenuated." Interestingly, Bartleby does not exhibit any emotion whatsoever; he has a flat appearance and "not a wrinkle of agitation rippled him." His face is more expressionless than a statue.
Later, the narrator describes Bartleby as a "ghost" and an "apparition." His countenance is "immovable," and he dresses in a ghost-like manner with "a strangely tattered dishabille." Essentially, Bartleby was figuratively dead long before his body actually perishes. Herman Melville layers each physical detail — pallor, leanness, glazed eyes, expressionless mouth — into a cumulative portrait of a man already departed from the world of the living.
The Narrator's Reaction and Bartleby's Emotional Flatness
The narrator's reaction to Bartleby is as remarkable as Bartleby himself. It is the narrator's perplexed paralysis that drives the narrative forward and engenders sympathy for the title character. The narrator explains that he is touched by the scrivener's irregularly flat affect and dull temperament: "there was something about Bartleby that not only strangely disarmed me, but in a wonderful manner touched and disconcerted me." The narrator even describes Bartleby's voice in musical terms — he has a "flute-like tone" — lending an ethereal, almost otherworldly quality to a character who otherwise registers no feeling at all.
Bartleby as a Living Ghost
Bartleby's physical appearance — his pale visage, his lean form, his tattered clothing, and his "flute-like" voice — conveys a man who is like the living dead. The narrator discovers that Bartleby has been sleeping in the office, haunting the building much as a spirit haunts a house. He only speaks when summoned, exhibits no discernible emotional reactions, and floats around the office as if he is not even there. Bartleby is more of a "fixture" than a human being.
Death is alluded to not only in Bartleby's physical nature but also in the office environment itself, with its "dead brick wall" that matches the "dead-wall reveries" of his mind. Every element of Bartleby's world — the walls he stares at, the sparse food he barely consumes, the silence in which he labors — reinforces his status as a figure who belongs more to the realm of the dead than the living.
Conclusion: Exorcised from Wall Street
However, Bartleby is not a ghost; he is a living man. His depressed personality, his immovable body, and his unreachable soul have a strong impact on all those around him and especially on the narrator. Ultimately, Bartleby is treated as if he were dead. He is "removed to the Tombs as a vagrant." Bartleby has been exorcised from Wall Street, and he dies exactly as he lived — silent, motionless, and apart from the world.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.