This paper examines two common classroom management challenges at the high school level and applies behavioral frameworks to address them. The first scenario involves a history teacher whose 5th period class has developed a growing tardiness problem. The second involves a 9th grade social studies teacher dealing with a student who repeatedly arrives without required materials. Drawing on behavioral classroom management theory and assertive discipline principles, the paper proposes concrete strategies β including token economies, short daily quizzes, and structured rule systems β to reinforce positive behavior, establish clear expectations, and hold students accountable in age-appropriate ways.
Effective classroom management is one of the most persistent challenges facing teachers at every level. This paper examines two specific scenarios involving high school teachers who are struggling with student behavior problems β one involving chronic tardiness in an 11th grade history class, and another involving a 9th grade student who consistently arrives without required materials. In each case, a behavioral framework is applied to analyze the problem and propose practical, age-appropriate solutions.
A high school history teacher is experiencing a growing tardiness problem in his 5th period class. At the start of the semester, only a few students were arriving late; by mid-semester, nearly half the class is tardy on a regular basis. A separate 9th grade social studies teacher faces a different but equally disruptive challenge: one student arrives every day without any of the required reading materials, creating a recurring dilemma about whether to send him to his locker β wasting class time β or allow him to remain unprepared and unable to participate.
The behavioral approach to classroom management focuses on establishing clear expectations, monitoring behavior, reinforcing positive behavior, and redirecting negative behavior. In most classroom situations, it is essential to create expectations during the initial part of the semester, since it is far more difficult to introduce or enforce new rules after patterns of misbehavior have already formed. The core principles of this approach include the following:
Applying a behavioral approach in an 11th grade classroom is somewhat more complex than with younger students. At this age, peer pressure and social dynamics often take precedence over teacher-imposed rules. One effective way to reward students who arrive on time is through a token system β using chits such as poker chips or similar items β that allows punctual students to "purchase" tangible rewards such as extra credit questions, extended time on assignments, movie tickets, or subject-related paperback books.
For example, if the instructor awarded a chit to every student who arrived on time, a student with perfect punctuality over a month might accumulate 20 chits. Those chits could then be exchanged for a bonus question worth additional points on an upcoming test, or for an extra two days to complete a research paper. In this way, the rewards for punctuality are closely tied β or proximal β to the behavior itself. Students who continue to arrive late simply do not have access to these benefits, creating a natural and non-punitive incentive structure.
In addition, it is logical to praise good behavior rather than drawing excessive attention to tardiness. One practical strategy is to begin the first five minutes of each class with a short quiz based on the previous day's lecture or the assigned readings. These quizzes might be worth only five points each, but given daily, they could account for 20β25% of the final grade. There would be no make-ups for missed quizzes, and students who arrive late would simply forfeit the opportunity. The quizzes should be straightforward β five questions requiring only one- or two-word answers or a single sentence β so that prepared, on-time students can complete them with ease.
Ultimately, one of the root causes of widespread tardiness is likely the absence of meaningful consequences. If the teacher has not clearly communicated expectations or followed up consistently on the issue, students have little incentive to change. By making the opening minutes of class genuinely valuable β through short assessments or key lecture previews β those who arrive on time are rewarded, and those who do not face natural academic consequences without the need for overt punishment.
"Assertive discipline theory and classroom rules"
"Strategies for student arriving without materials"
Canter, L. (1990). Assertive discipline: More than names on the board and marbles in a jar. Dyc.edu. Retrieved April 2013 from
Huitt, W. (1996). Classroom management: A behavioral approach. Educational Psychology Interactive. Retrieved April 2013 from http://www.edpsycinteractive.org/topics/manage/behmgt.html
McIntyre, T. (2008). Assertive discipline. Behavioradvisor.com. Retrieved April 2013 from http://www.behavioradvisor.com/AssertiveDiscipline.html
You’re 51% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.