Catholic Priests and Sexual Abuse: Scope, Research, and Response
This paper examines the ongoing sexual abuse scandal involving Roman Catholic priests and other Church officials. Drawing on peer-reviewed research and investigative journalism, it traces the origins of public awareness in the United States to 2002 reporting by the Boston Globe, outlines key statistics on the number of abusive priests and victims, and analyzes how Church leadership initially responded—often by deflecting blame. The paper also considers scholarly explanations for why abuse occurred, including arguments connecting it to the Church's mandatory celibacy policy and patriarchal structure. The analysis concludes that thousands of priests have been implicated as child predators, and that the scandal has caused lasting reputational damage to the Catholic Church worldwide.
- Introduction: Framing the global Catholic clergy abuse scandal
- Overview of the Abuse of Young Boys by Priests: Boston Globe reporting and international spread of scandal
- Available Research on Sexual Abuse by Priests: Clinical statistics on offending priests and victims
- How the Church Has Addressed the Problem: Church leadership deflection, papal statements, and blame-shifting
- Conclusion: Celibacy, patriarchy, and lasting institutional damage
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Efficiently synthesizes multiple peer-reviewed sources alongside investigative journalism to build a factual foundation for a sensitive topic.
- Presents quantitative statistics (percentages of offending priests, number of victims) in a concise, readable way that grounds the argument in evidence rather than rhetoric.
- Balances institutional response with scholarly explanation, quoting Church officials directly and then contrasting those statements with academic research findings.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of direct quotation paired with in-text citation to attribute controversial claims to authoritative sources. By quoting Vatican spokespeople and popes verbatim alongside scholarly statistics, the writer allows the primary sources to carry rhetorical weight while maintaining academic distance and credibility.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing introduction, then moves through three substantive sections: a historical account of how the scandal became public, a synthesis of clinical and research data on the scale of abuse, and an analysis of the Church's institutional response. A short concluding paragraph ties the scholarly explanation—mandatory celibacy and patriarchal structure—back to the opening thesis. The structure is linear and logical, moving from discovery to data to institutional reaction to cause.
Introduction
The ongoing sexual abuse scandal involving Roman Catholic priests and other Church officials continues to shock the Christian world. It has led to prosecutions, prison sentences, international embarrassment for a major world religion, and the paying out of millions of dollars in reparations by the Church. This paper reviews the sexual abuses perpetrated by clergy, the number of cases involved, the impact of this abuse, and the responses of the Church, the media, and the public.
Overview of the Abuse of Young Boys by Priests
The first public reports of sexual abuse by Catholic priests in the United States were published in 2002, according to a peer-reviewed article by Karen J. Terry. At first it appeared that the perpetrators were American priests, but within a few years the scandal took on international implications. The investigative journalism conducted in the United States gave impetus to uncovering the larger scope of the problem.
It was the Boston Globe that initially revealed the abuse of boys within the Church. The allegations against "serial predator John Geoghan in the Boston Archdiocese" were widely disseminated, and the Globe published "more than 1,000 articles" from 2002 to 2004 (Terry, 2015). The scandal subsequently spread to Europe—including Austria, Belgium, England and Wales—as well as to Canada, Australia, Ireland, the Netherlands, "and even the Vatican" (Terry, 140).
Available Research on Sexual Abuse by Priests
The abuses reported by the Boston Globe and hundreds of other newspapers in the 2000s were not the first instances by any means, but the recent revelations gave rise to the widespread image of the "pedophile priest" (Terry, 141). A clinical study conducted in 2003 found that potentially 3,000 priests had abused minors—predominantly boys—over a 50-year period (Terry, 141). Another clinical study found that 4% of priests "are sexually preoccupied with adolescent boys or girls, and 20–40% of priests engage in sexual misconduct with adults" (Terry, 142). A study by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate reported that "5% of priests in ministry since 1950 have allegations of abuse against approximately 15,000 minors" (Terry, 142).
Are these abusive priests actually pedophiles? Are some of them gay men who, because they are not permitted to marry, seek out illegal sexual contact with boys? There are far more questions than answers to these perplexing problems. A telling statistic, however, is that the vast majority—81%—of victims of priests' misconduct are male (Terry, 143).
Conclusion
Why do priests abuse children? According to Dale, scholarly research into the psychology of the problem attributes the abuse to "the misogynistic and patriarchal infrastructure of the Catholic Church, including the mandatory celibacy policy" (Dale, 69). The research reviewed in this paper clearly demonstrates that thousands of priests have acted as child predators, and the Catholic Church will be forever tarnished by this shocking scandal.
Works Cited
Barrett, D., and Squires, N. (2014). Pope Francis says about 8,000 pedophiles are members of Catholic clergy, including bishops and cardinals. The Telegraph. Retrieved April 14, 2015, from http://www.news.nationalpost.com.
Dale, K.A., and Alpert, J.L. (2007). Hiding behind the cloth: Child sexual abuse and the Catholic Church. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 16(3), 59–72.
Terry, K.J. (2015). Child sexual abuse within the Catholic Church: A review of global perspectives. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 39(2), 139–154.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.