This paper examines how Roman Polanski's Chinatown (1974) both adheres to and redefines the conventions of classic film noir. Drawing on foundational scholarship by Andrew Spicer and Raymond Borde and Etienne Chaumeton, the paper traces film noir's origins, its defining character archetypes, visual style, and social themes, then analyzes how Chinatown updates these elements for a 1970s audience. Topics covered include the hard-boiled detective, the femme fatale, moral ambiguity, the California Water Wars conspiracy, the abandonment of the Production Code, and the film's status as a neo-noir work that critiques systemic corruption and the cyclical nature of societal failure.
The paper demonstrates genre analysis: it establishes the defining features of a genre through scholarly sources, then evaluates how a specific text both conforms to and departs from those features. This technique is effective because it requires the writer to move between broad theoretical claims and close textual evidence, showing mastery of both levels of argument.
The paper opens by defining film noir and establishing Chinatown's place within the genre. It then covers noir's origins and character types, applies those types to the film's cast, introduces the neo-noir label, analyzes the conspiracy plot in detail, discusses the Production Code's removal and its impact on the film's content, and closes with a reflection on the film's social and metaphorical relevance. The conclusion ties the argument back to a broader claim about corruption and societal repetition.
Rising to prominence in the late 1940s and initially described as "murder with a psychological twist," film noir introduced audiences to a genre distinguished by its subject matter, themes, and stylistic trademarks (Spicer 1). Chinatown, directed by Roman Polanski and starring Jack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway, and John Huston, helped to redefine the genre while maintaining several aspects of classic film noir. Although Chinatown was released in 1974, it remains a definitive film of the genre and adheres to the "murder with a psychological twist" trope.
The classification "film noir" was first used by French film critic Nino Frank to describe a series of four recently released crime thrillers: The Maltese Falcon (1941), Murder My Sweet (1944), Double Indemnity (1944), and Laura (1944) (Spicer 2). Crime films, including the gangster film and subsequently film noir, shared a similar "iconography, visual style, narrative strategy, subject matter and characterization" (4). An estimated 20% of films noir produced between 1941 and 1948 were direct adaptations of novels written by "hard-boiled" detective writers such as Dashiell Hammett, Raymond Chandler, and James M. Cain. Within film noir, the realms of good and evil become intrinsically intertwined and are often merged into one another (Borde & Chaumeton 12).
Film noir also exploited the cynicism of the American people by reflecting sentiments such as anxiety, pessimism, and paranoia to depict the unsettling reality of post-war America (Spicer 20). It was usually set in urban cities such as Los Angeles, San Francisco, New York, and Chicago, presenting a world that had been corrupted and had become morally ambiguous. Chinatown, set in Los Angeles, embodies these qualities and is reflective not of post-World War II America but rather of the conflict in Vietnam in which the United States was embroiled until 1975.
Traditionally, film noir uses a criminal investigation to introduce characters such as the hard-boiled detective, the femme fatale, and the corrupt policeman (Borde & Chaumeton 7). J.J. Gittes plays the part of the hard-boiled detective, hired to perform marital surveillance on Hollis Mulwray, and in the process uncovers a much larger underlying conspiracy. Gittes formerly worked as an officer with the Los Angeles Police Department, serving mainly in Chinatown alongside Lt. Lou Escobar (Polanski).
Evelyn Mulwray — both the imposter and the real Evelyn Mulwray, played by Faye Dunaway — prove to be the femmes fatale in the film, with both women ultimately dying in order to cover up the ongoing conspiracy. The contradicting natures of the hard-boiled detective and the femme fatale influence how these characters behave. The detective's contradicting nature extends to the point where he becomes "an inglorious victim who undergoes…some appalling beatings" (9). The femme fatale's contradicting nature likewise means that she will not survive her involvement in the scheme she is part of and will prove to be "fatal unto herself" (9).
The police in Chinatown are also of dubious character. Lt. Lou Escobar allows Gittes insight into the ongoing investigation of Mulwray's murder and aids Gittes in his work, yet at the film's end attempts to console him by saying there is nothing to be done to avenge or rectify the murder of Evelyn Mulwray or to apprehend Noah Cross for his many crimes. Noah Cross, the film's ultimate villain, is presented as a sociopath willing to do anything to hold onto his water empire: he fraudulently purchases property, contributes to the murder of his business partner, commits incest, contributes to his daughter's death, and approaches his daughter/granddaughter as a loving figure who will care for her (Polanski). Complicated and intertwining character relationships add to the story's complexity and explicate character behaviors and motives through narrative development. These relationships include that between Hollis Mulwray and Evelyn Mulwray, and the incestuous and devastating relationship that Noah Cross had with his daughter Evelyn.
Chinatown may be considered an updated version of film noir within the cinematic genre, cementing itself as a neo-noir film. Neo-noir has been described by Todd Erickson as "a new type of noir film, one which effectively incorporates and projects the narrative and stylistic conventions of its progenitor onto a contemporary canvas" (Spicer 130). Unlike many of the popular and successful films noir of the 1940s that were based on "hard-boiled" novels, Chinatown is an original imagining of life, controversy, and conspiracy in 1930s Los Angeles. Roman Polanski commented, "I saw Chinatown not as a 'retro' piece or conscious imitation of classic movies shot in black and white, but as a film about the thirties through the camera eye of the seventies" (Spicer 139).
Because Chinatown was shot in color, the use of chiaroscuro to emphasize the interplay between good and evil, light and darkness, becomes nearly impossible to rely upon as a stylistic element. The audience must instead rely on the characters' moral fiber, and its development, to gauge their intent. Nevertheless, many of the complex narrative structures found in classic film noir are also present in Chinatown.
You’re 45% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.