Skip to main content
Research Paper Undergraduate 2,536 words

Colgan Air Flight 3407: Human Factors in the Crash

~13 min read Technology · Aviation
Abstract

This paper investigates the February 12, 2009, crash of Colgan Air Flight 3407 near Buffalo, New York, which killed all 49 people aboard and one person on the ground. Drawing on NTSB findings, CVR transcripts, and expert commentary, the paper examines the human factors that contributed to the accident — including Captain Martin Renslow's improper stall response, the crew's failure to maintain sterile cockpit procedures, inadequate training, and the systemic problem of pilot fatigue. The paper also considers the role of alcohol impairment in aviation safety and concludes with recommendations for counter-practices pilots and airlines can implement to prevent similar tragedies.

Key Takeaways
  • The Accident: Overview of Flight 3407 crash and fatalities
  • Causes Contributing to the Accident: Pilot error, stall response, and crew failures
  • Discovery of Human Factors: Training deficiencies, fatigue, and CRM breakdown
  • Pilot Fatigue and Aviation Safety: FAA fatigue regulations and their shortcomings
  • Alcohol Impairment and Pilot Error: FAR 91.17 rules and blood alcohol effects on pilots
  • Conclusion: Recommendations for safer pilot practices
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper grounds its analysis in primary NTSB evidence — including verbatim CVR transcript excerpts — which lends credibility and specificity to its human-factors argument.
  • It moves logically from the specific accident details outward to systemic industry problems (inadequate training standards, fatigue regulations, and alcohol policies), giving the analysis both depth and broader relevance.
  • The use of a contrasting example — Captain Sullenberger's successful Hudson River landing in the same year — effectively frames the central argument about professional competence without editorializing excessively.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates effective use of multi-source triangulation: it combines regulatory documents (FAR 91.17), official investigation findings (NTSB reports), journalistic accounts, expert commentary, and a personal communication to build a converging case. This technique strengthens arguments by showing that multiple independent sources point to the same conclusions about pilot error and systemic failures.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with the accident narrative and a framing research question, then moves through immediate causes, legal discovery findings, systemic issues (fatigue, alcohol), and ends with a prescriptive conclusion. Each section layers additional causal depth onto the central human-factors thesis, creating a funnel structure that proceeds from specific incident details to broad safety recommendations.

Essay 2,536 words

"These people knew what they were supposed to do, and they did it."
— Kathryn O'Leary Higgins (as cited in Buffington, 2009, p. 351)

On the night of February 12, 2009, Colgan Air Flight 3407, a 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 121 scheduled passenger flight traveling from Newark, New Jersey to Buffalo-Niagara International Airport in Buffalo, New York, crashed into a house in Clarence Center, New York. Reports confirm that at the time of the accident, night visual meteorological conditions existed. According to Mike Mitchell (2010), writing in the web article "NTSB Colgan Air Flight 3407 Actions Led to Crash of Flight," the report states that "when the stick shaker activated to warn the flight crew of an impending aerodynamic stall, the captain should have responded correctly to the situation by pushing forward on the control column. …the captain inappropriately pulled …back on the control column" (Mitchell, 2010, "NTSB Colgan Air…," ¶ 3). This action placed the airplane into an accelerated aerodynamic stall.

This paper investigates the crash of Flight 3407, focusing on the human factors that contributed to the accident — with particular attention to the two pilots. One pertinent research question is addressed: In consideration of the human factors that reportedly contributed to the Colgan Air Flight 3407 accident, what counter-practices may pilots implement to help avoid this type of tragedy?

In addition to pilot Martin D. Renslow and co-pilot Rebecca L. Shaw, two flight attendants and 45 passengers aboard the plane were killed in the crash. One individual on the ground was also killed. The total number of individuals who lost their lives that day was 50. In another web article, "NTSB Report on Colgan Air Crash Highlights CAPA's Safety Concerns," Mitchell (2010) reports that impact forces and a post-crash fire obliterated the airplane:

…a Colgan Air, Inc., Bombardier DHC-8-400, N200WQ, operating as Continental Connection Flight 3407, was on an instrument approach to Buffalo-Niagara International Airport, Buffalo, New York, when it crashed into a residence in Clarence Center, New York, about 5 nautical miles northeast of the airport. (Mitchell, 2010, "NTSB Report…," ¶ 2)

The opening quote from Kathryn O'Leary Higgins refers to the actions of Captain Chesley B. "Sully" Sullenberger III, the pilot of Flight 1549, and his crew, who safely landed 155 individuals in the Hudson River, also in 2009. Comments regarding Renslow, the pilot of Flight 3407, indicate that he and his crew did not do what they were supposed to do.

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) released the following excerpts from Flight 3407's Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR). These passages represent the last communications between Renslow and flight control:

Excerpts from Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) transcript:

22:15:06.3 HOT-1 flaps five.
22:15:08.1 HOT-2 what?
22:15:08.8 HOT-1 flaps five please.
22:15:13.5 APP Colgan thirty four zero seven three miles from KLUMP turn left heading two six zero maintain two thousand three hundred until established localizer. cleared ILS approach runway two three.
22:15:22.2 RDO-2 left two sixty two thousand three hundred 'til established and cleared ILS two three approach Colgan thirty four zero seven.
22:15:31.7 HOT-1 alright approach is armed.
22:15:32.8 HOT-2 roger.
22:16:04.1 HOT-1 gear down…loc's alive.
22:16:06.4 APP Colgan thirty four zero seven contact tower one two zero point five. have a good night.
22:16:11.5 RDO-2 over to tower you do the same thirty four zero seven.
22:16:21.2 HOT-2 gear's down.
22:16:23.5 HOT-1 flaps fifteen before landing checklist.
22:16:26.6 HOT-2 uhhh.
22:16:37.1 HOT-2 I put the flaps up.
22:16:42.2 HOT-1 [grunt]
22:16:45.8 HOT-2 should the gear up?
22:16:46.8 HOT-1 gear up.
22:16:50.1 CAM [increase in ambient noise]
22:16:51.9 CAM [thump] (Flightpath, 2009, Excerpts from CVR transcript section)

In the book Squawk 7700: A Pilot's Adventure, Peter M. Buffington (2009) asserts that one primary cause contributing to the crash of Flight 3407 evolved from Renslow and Shaw permitting the aircraft to slow to a precariously low speed. Renslow's reaction proved to be the exact opposite of what he should have done once a stall warning sounded, meaning he could not regain control of the plane (Buffington, p. 351). Other contributing causes included Renslow and Shaw failing to recognize the low-speed cue's position on the airplane's flight displays when it indicated the stick shaker would soon activate.

Renslow and Shaw also failed as a team. Reports indicate that neither pilot adhered "to sterile cockpit procedures" (Mitchell, 2010, "NTSB Colgan Air…," ¶ 4). Renslow failed to perform his duties as captain, as he did not "effectively manage the flight and Colgan Air's inadequate procedures for airspeed selection and management during approaches in icing conditions" (Mitchell, 2010).

1,828 Words Hidden · 28% Shown
Key Concepts in This Paper
Pilot Error Stall Recovery Crew Resource Management Sterile Cockpit NTSB Investigation Pilot Fatigue Flight Training Alcohol Impairment Regional Airlines Aviation Safety
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Colgan Air Flight 3407: Human Factors in the Crash. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/colgan-air-flight-3407-human-factors-15065

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.