This paper examines the American crime film genre as a vehicle for exploring the heroic paradigm — the tension between good and evil — across literary, cinematic, and cultural traditions. Tracing influences from Dostoevsky and Conrad through German Expressionism, hard-boiled detective fiction, and Hong Kong cinema, the paper argues that the crime genre uniquely reflects the American moral consciousness. Through close readings of films by the Coen Brothers, Clint Eastwood, Oliver Stone, and Stephen Chow, and through analysis of literary precursors from Hammett to Flannery O'Connor, the paper demonstrates how the genre consistently interrogates nobility, moral ambiguity, and the nature of heroism in a corrupt world.
The paper demonstrates effective use of thematic threading: a central concept (the heroic paradigm and the battle between good and evil) is introduced in the opening section and then traced systematically through successive examples drawn from different national cinemas, literary traditions, and historical periods. This technique allows a broad survey to feel purposeful and cumulative rather than encyclopedic.
The paper opens with a wide-angle survey of the crime genre's thematic range before narrowing to its central argument about the heroic paradigm. It then proceeds through three analytical movements — literary and cinematic influences, American Gothic introspection, and the Western's moral code — before expanding outward to Hong Kong cinema as a global test case. The conclusion returns to historical grounding, connecting the genre's origins to real-world social alienation and affirming the genre's enduring relevance to American identity.
The American crime film genre has been used throughout the twentieth century as a vehicle for a variety of themes: from explorations of social degradation (White Heat) to social injustice and Christian allegory (On the Waterfront) to moral ambiguity (The Maltese Falcon, Touch of Evil) to action spectacle and car chases (The French Connection, Bullitt) to analyses of lost innocence and media corruption (Badlands, Natural Born Killers) to the film noir homage (Miller's Crossing). But primarily, the crime film genre has been used to represent a dual mentality in the American social fabric: "The first gangster cycle condemned and glorified the brutality of the underworld" (Mast 270). Raymond Chandler's tough-talking Marlowe would throw the scales of justice back in the face of a hypocritical system, thus establishing the defining paradigm of the crime genre: a hero whose legitimacy was denied by the very public whose order he attempted to serve — often following the spirit of the law over the letter.
The crime genre has also always dealt with varying levels of corruption, both in public offices and in private lives. At its best, it has shown both sides of the story, humanizing the villainous and the noble alike. At its worst, it has been a preachy, smug homage to American self-satisfaction. This paper analyzes the crime film and the variety of perspectives from which it has engaged American audiences since its inception, showing how — through its various influences and inspirations, from Germany's Fritz Lang (M) to Hong Kong cinema and British, Russian, and American literature — it has revealed the American consciousness as one in which the battle between good and evil is fought, as Dostoevsky said, in every human heart.
The crime film and film noir genres, though dating in American cinema back to the very beginning of the twentieth century with the one-reel shorts that depicted cops against robbers and other notorious or fringe characters (Dirks), really found their inspiration in the classic novels of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Chief among these was Dostoevsky's Notes from Underground, with the Underground Man figuring as the prototype for all modern anti-heroes (White). There were also Joseph Conrad's several psychological novels — many of them later adapted to film — such as Lord Jim, The Secret Agent, Heart of Darkness, Under Western Eyes, and Victory. The nihilist or criminal element was ever present in the British author's works, attempting to subvert polite society in some manner or another, often drawing the balance between good and evil with expansive shades of gray. Conrad thus acted as the precursor of Orson Welles' classic corrupt chief in Touch of Evil ("He was some kind of a man").
And then there were the hard-boiled detective novels and crime stories penned by American authors like Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler. Hammett's Sam Spade became iconic, portrayed by Bogart in 1941 before the actor went on to portray Chandler's Marlowe on screen. Bogart, in fact, could not have been Bogart without Hammett or Chandler, and Hammett and Chandler each in turn owed a debt to the criminal psychology and gray-scale characterization of Conrad, and to the inverted, regime-changing, heroic/anti-heroic paradigm of Dostoevsky.
The heroic paradigm, stood on its head by the Russian novelist, had descended from the classic stage through the classic novels into the modern age — where black could be white and white could be black, a notion perfectly phrased in the Coen brothers' 1990 film noir gangster classic Miller's Crossing. Dostoevsky gave it new life by characterizing the dregs of society and upholding such figures as in some ways better than much of the upper crust, yet in another way worse than genuine goodness. The Underground Man was the first anti-hero, followed by Raskolnikov of Crime and Punishment — who moves out of the Underground Man's shadow and into the light of redemption, not an uncommon theme in the more moralistic crime films — followed by Alyosha in The Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky's first and only truly good character. Dostoevsky essentially developed a new heroic paradigm, one in which the balance of good and evil was greatly tilted in favor of the latter, and the former was hardly judged by polite society as belonging to the good — but was, in fact, usually the only one to really represent it. Conrad's Lord Jim fits such a paradigm, as does Chandler's Marlowe and Hammett's Continental Op. Each follows a romantic code of chivalry, sorely out of place in the modern world yet sorely needed all the same.
The crime film genre's cinematic and stylistic influence was German — not French, who only gave us the noir name — and Fritz Lang gave us the first crime genre masterpiece, M: a gruesome tale starring Peter Lorre as a deranged pedophiliac murderer hunted by both the police and the criminal underworld. American director Stanley Kubrick would recall Lang's wildly angled shots and eerie set-ups in Dr. Strangelove, The Shining, and A Clockwork Orange, and every director who has attempted to shoot a film noir since Lang has had to tip his hat to the German for translating into film what the novelists had first depicted on the page: good vs. evil in the psychotic society. Hitchcock would carry on the tradition of the crime genre, adapting Conrad's The Secret Agent into the romanticized Sabotage, a lineage that would show up again in Tarantino's 2009 Inglourious Basterds. Hitchcock's Psycho would change the way films addressed the subjective, opening the door for further analytical ambiguity. Nonetheless, no thread or genre has had a greater life than the crime genre — because no better heroic paradigm has been constructed that so well fits the modern American world.
The crime genre, however, is as heterogeneous as any genre can be, ranging from themes of pure spectacle and machismo to character studies that scrutinize the spiritual nature of the good vs. evil conflict. Conrad's Lord Jim provides ample basis for such introspection, but American author Flannery O'Connor provides it as well, establishing it in a distinctly American Gothic tone — predated just barely by Shirley Jackson's New England Gothic and, of course, by Hawthorne before her. One of O'Connor's most iconic characters is The Misfit, an escaped convict who fails to bat an eye at the thought of murdering an entire family in broad daylight. "A Good Man is Hard to Find" dwells, however, not on The Misfit's wrongdoing, but on the fact that he makes more metaphysical sense than the "good people" he slaughters in the woods, expressing the truth of American malaise and spiritual mediocrity: "She would of been a good woman," The Misfit said, "if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life" (O'Connor).
The theme is picked up again by Terrence Malick in his 1973 debut Badlands, starring Martin Sheen and Sissy Spacek, as precursors to Oliver Stone's Mickey and Mallory in Natural Born Killers two decades later. Both films go beyond the normal scope of the crime film genre: the former by examining the desolate interior life of its characters through their journey across the desolate American landscape; the latter by examining the pernicious influence of modern media, the American obsession with crime, and the desensitization of youth. At one point in Natural Born Killers, a spiritual Native American elder observes the devil that haunts Mickey (played by Woody Harrelson) — its name is "Too Much TV."
Stone would also pen the updated version of Scarface for director Brian De Palma, which contains one of the themes that would define Stone's filmmaking career: Tony Montana's symbolic gaining of the entire world at the expense of his soul and his life — itself an echo of Cagney's cry in White Heat, just before he is damned to the flames: "Look Ma! I made it! Top o' the world!"
The most cinematically satisfying and faithful adherents to the style and themes of the film noir and crime genre are Joel and Ethan Coen, who have crafted a number of films that fit the mold: beginning with their first, Blood Simple — a Hitchcockian suspense-thriller complete with adultery, a jealous husband, a corrupt private detective, and money — and continuing through Raising Arizona (a comedic twist on the genre); Miller's Crossing (an ode to speakeasy gangster films, and an adaptation of Hammett's The Glass Key); Barton Fink (an existential twist on the genre); The Big Lebowski (an affectionate parody and homage); The Man Who Wasn't There (another existential twist, filmed in black and white); and No Country for Old Men (an adaptation of the Cormac McCarthy novel).
Miller's Crossing gives the best example of the "ethics" of the crime film genre, beginning as it does with the classic speech delivered by Giovanni Gasparo: "I'm talkin' about friendship — I'm talkin' about character — I'm talkin' about — hell, Leo, I ain't embarrassed to use the word: I'm talkin' about ethics…" The film is full of characters whose actions are shady and unethical, but the good — calm, loyal, not afraid of a fair fight — are clearly distinguishable from the bad — shifty, irrational, conniving, and always looking for the fix. Tom Reagan, the hero, is the man who appears to be playing both sides against the middle. Leo comes out on top at the end, and Tom is no worse for wear, even though he loses the girl and walks away from further employment in Leo's racket. His final look bears all one needs to know about the crime film genre: at its greatest it is a genre devoted to introspection. The Coen brothers prove it as the camera pans up and zooms in on Tom's eyes, fixed on the carriage disappearing into the distance — and on something even beyond the horizon. Dignity? Soul? Heaven? Hell? Death? Judgment? True to form, we are never told, and the credits roll.
The crime film genre was born out of the type of real-life characters of the nineteenth century: men who "blamed capitalism, religion, the army, and the state for the plight of the underclass, who struggled to get by as the rich lived it up… [who] felt dislocated, alienated, and angry" — men like Emile Henry, who threw a bomb into Paris' Hotel Terminus in 1894 (Merriman 4). From life, those characters went into books, and from there into movies, but the same heroic paradigm never changed. The best pictures have always been true to it; the worst have been little more than superficial attempts to redefine it.
The crime film genre is part of the American fabric in a profound way: it touches on both aspects of the human heart — the good and the bad — and depicts them both on screen. As Paul Sann observed in The Lawless Decade, "A jury in Hammond, Indiana, acquitted a man who had killed an alien for saying 'To hell with the United States.'" That was in 1920, and America's love of such a moral code has not changed yet.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.