Death of a Salesman: American Dream and Family Failure
This essay analyzes Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman through the lens of the 1966 television film directed by Alex Segal and starring Lee J. Cobb. It examines three interlocking themes: Willy Loman's mental and physical decline as portrayed by Cobb's imposing physicality, the destructive fallacy of the American Dream that ultimately drives Loman to suicide, and the dysfunction of the Loman family rooted in Willy's infidelity and its devastating effect on his son Biff. The essay argues that beneath the surface tragedy of one man's collapse lies a broader critique of American cultural mythology and the impossible standards it sets for success and family life.
- Introduction: A Salesman's Tragic Reality: Overview of the play's themes and film versions
- Willy Loman's Physical and Mental Decline: Cobb's casting highlights mental over physical decay
- The Fallacy of the American Dream: Dream's impossibility drives Willy to suicide
- Family Dysfunction and the Loman Household: Willy's infidelity destroys Biff's ambition and family bonds
- Conclusion: Play critiques American mythology through personal tragedy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses direct textual quotations from the play to ground each analytical claim, giving the argument concrete evidentiary support.
- Connects the casting choice of Lee J. Cobb — known for physically imposing roles — to a specific interpretive point about Willy's mental rather than physical deterioration.
- Moves logically from individual character analysis to broader thematic critique, linking personal failure to the cultural myth of the American Dream.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates thematic layering analysis: rather than treating the play's plot at face value, the writer identifies a surface narrative (one man's breakdown) and a deeper ideological critique (the American Dream as a destructive myth). This technique shows the reader how to read beneath the literal events of a text toward its social and cultural argument.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with an introduction that frames the play's multiple themes, then devotes one body paragraph each to Willy's physicality as portrayed by Cobb, the American Dream theme and Willy's suicide, and the Loman family's dysfunction centered on Biff. A brief Works Cited section closes the paper. Each body section follows a consistent pattern: introduce the theme, support it with a direct quotation, and draw an interpretive conclusion.
Introduction: A Salesman's Tragic Reality
Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman follows Willy Loman, a sad and aging salesman who has spent his entire adult life in sales with little success, yet always affirming his belief that a man who is well-liked is destined to succeed. There have been many film and television adaptations of Miller's play since its first performance in 1949. The 1966 television version directed by Alex Segal and starring Lee J. Cobb has proven particularly interesting in the way it treats the story's specific themes. Death of a Salesman has what would initially seem to be a spare plot: an aging man comes face-to-face with the reality of his existence and crumbles under the weight of his failures. The mental anguish of the main character is only one theme of the piece. When examined more deeply, it becomes apparent that beneath the surface lies a second layer dealing with the fallacy of the American Dream and the failure of the stereotypically happy American family.
Willy Loman's Physical and Mental Decline
Most performers who portray Willy Loman present him as a physically weak character, mirroring his failing mental state. Lee J. Cobb, who also originated the role of Loman on Broadway in 1949, was most famous for playing burly, angry, and physically intimidating men. When the audience is first introduced to Willy, he is mentally exhausted from his time on the road making sales calls. "Suddenly I'm goin' sixty miles per hour and I don't remember driving the last five minutes. I'm… I can't seem to… keep my mind to it" (I). From the outset, it is clear that this man has given everything he has and has little left to give. It is therefore significant that Cobb, though older than the young men around him, still projects a stronger physical presence than his sons. Willy's weakness is thus far more in mind than in body, making Loman's descent a mental rather than a physical tragedy.
The Fallacy of the American Dream
The American Dream is the idea that anyone willing to work hard can rise from nothing and build a fortune, simply by virtue of living in America. Willy Loman staunchly believed in this dream when he was a young man, and he holds to the conviction that a man who is well-liked will always have a better chance at achieving it than one who is not. Unable to keep pace with the younger men in his office — those who have not yet grown jaded enough to abandon their own dreams — Loman is fired at the relatively young age of 63. Incredulously, he cries, "You can't eat the orange and throw the peel away — a man is not a piece of fruit" (II). The fallacy of the Dream proves fatal for Loman, who cannot survive the death of his illusions. Feeling he has nothing left to offer the world, he kills himself in the hope that the insurance money will give his wife and sons another chance at life. "After all the highways, and the trains, and the appointments, and the years, you end up worth more dead than alive" (II). In the original play, Willy's death could be interpreted as either an accident or a suicide depending on individual analysis; the 1966 film makes it unambiguously clear that Loman's death was intentional.
Conclusion
Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman operates on multiple levels simultaneously, weaving personal tragedy, cultural critique, and family dysfunction into a single, devastating narrative. Through Lee J. Cobb's physically powerful yet mentally deteriorating portrayal of Willy Loman, the 1966 film foregrounds the psychological dimension of the story. Willy's fatal embrace of the American Dream and the broken family left in the wake of his infidelity together reveal Miller's deeper argument: that the myths American culture holds most dear can be as destructive as they are inspiring.
Works Cited
Death of a Salesman. Directed by Alex Segal, performed by Lee J. Cobb and George Segal. 2002. DVD.
Miller, Arthur. Death of a Salesman. 1980. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.