Descartes, Chisholm, and Moore on Skepticism and Knowledge
This paper examines the role of skepticism in Western philosophy, tracing its foundations in René Descartes' method of systemic doubt and the claim that objective knowledge of the external world is unattainable. It then considers Roderick Chisholm's challenge to Cartesian skepticism, particularly his adoption of particularism as an epistemological framework, and G. E. Moore's famous attempt to prove the existence of an external world by raising his hands. The paper argues that both Chisholm's and Moore's counterarguments are ultimately circular and question-begging, concluding that the skeptical position established by Descartes remains the most logically defensible account of human knowledge.
- Introduction to Skepticism in Western Philosophy: Skepticism's role and Descartes' centrality introduced
- Descartes and the Foundations of Epistemic Doubt: Descartes' method of doubt and cogito ergo sum
- Chisholm's Challenge: Particularism vs. Skepticism: Chisholm's criterion problem and particularist solution
- Moore's Proof of an External World: Moore's hand-raising argument examined and critiqued
- The Fatal Flaw in Chisholm's Argument: Chisholm's hidden assumption exposed as circular
- Conclusion: The Enduring Force of Skepticism: Skepticism vindicated; counterarguments rejected as circular
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear thesis early — that Chisholm's counterargument to Descartes is ultimately flawed — and maintains that through each section without deviation.
- It structures the argument dialectically: presenting the Cartesian position, then the objection, then the rebuttal, which models strong philosophical essay organization.
- The critique of Chisholm as a covert particularist before the inquiry even begins is a pointed and intellectually honest logical observation, demonstrating the ability to identify circular reasoning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates internal critique — rather than simply asserting that Chisholm is wrong, it enters his own framework (the problem of the criterion, the three available solutions) and shows that his choice of particularism is predetermined by an unstated prior commitment. This technique of exposing a hidden premise is a hallmark of rigorous philosophical argumentation.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad introduction to skepticism, narrows to Descartes' specific contributions, then introduces Chisholm as the primary antagonist. Moore's proof serves as a concrete case study of the anti-skeptical position before the final two sections deliver the paper's central argument and conclusion. The movement from historical context → case study → logical critique → verdict is clean and well-paced for an undergraduate philosophy essay.
Introduction to Skepticism in Western Philosophy
Skepticism is a foundational component of the Western philosophical tradition. At its simplest level, it posits that human beings can never arrive at certain knowledge about the world, nor can objective truth ever be ascertained (Hooker, par. 1). While skepticism has a long history in Western civilization, its development took a crucial turn when René Descartes turned his attention to the question of how we can know anything. Modern skepticism is a derivation of Descartes' examination of the nature of knowledge and humanity's relationship to it. However, Descartes has not been accepted without question. Many philosophers refuse to accept the basic tenets of skepticism, including the claim that no one can possess objective knowledge of the external world. The skeptics assert that we know significantly less about the world than we presume to know (Steup, par. 1).
Notable among Descartes' detractors is the twentieth-century philosopher Roderick Chisholm, who viewed this issue as fundamental to any philosophical discussion (Faber, par. 2). Chisholm developed his own counterargument to the Cartesian system. However, examined with a critical eye, it becomes evident that Chisholm's argument is ultimately flawed. René Descartes established the importance of skepticism to Western civilization; Chisholm's attempts to undermine that centrality have thus far proven ineffective.
Works Cited
Faber, David S. "Modernism, Postmodernism, and the Problem of Criterion." Direction 30.2 (Fall 2001): 162–176.
Hooker, Richard. "Skepticism." World Cultures. 14 July 1999.
Steup, Matthias. "Knowledge and Skepticism." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2005.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.