This paper explores the role of formal education in transforming police management and organizational culture. It traces the historical development of criminal justice education in the United States, from the 1960s President's Commission recommendation that all officers hold college degrees to the proliferation of over 1,000 academic programs by 1990. The paper argues that higher education contributes to meaningful change in police culture by reducing authoritarianism, improving community relations, refining codes of ethics, and developing analytical and organizational management skills. It also acknowledges ongoing debates about whether college-educated officers are truly necessary, weighing benefits against concerns such as reduced tenure and the gap between academic theory and street-level practice.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
The police force in any country has a vital role to play in achieving its intended mission of crime prevention, protection of life and property, and apprehending violators of the peace. The police are the upholders of justice, and to that extent they, more than anyone else, need to practice an underlying code of ethics true to the spirit of democracy: "…the mission 'to protect and serve' is not so simple…require[s] distinct and separate skills [and the] artistry of police work lies in the ability to handle explosive situations without resorting to force." (Delattre, 1989, pp. 25–26). The practice of justice in police work does not only involve overt criminal acts but also various types of community service, including assisting the sick and injured or defusing domestic tension and violence.
Even where police officers have ingrained humane values and ethics, such situations require specialist and varying skills. Beyond the necessary knowledge and skill base required to perform their duties, the police are increasingly under pressure to deliver a wide range of services using limited human and financial resources — a challenge that requires optimization through the application of management principles and techniques. It is for these reasons that the role of education in policing begins to assume great importance.
Historically, the emphasis on protecting and serving the public, combined with an initial training period focused on preparing officers for danger and violence, led to the development of an authoritarian attitude in police culture. The police have also tended to view themselves as the only ones qualified to do such a specialized job, producing an organizational culture that is closed, secretive, and insulated from the outside world (Johnson, May–June 2003). This problem is further compounded by media portrayals of policing, which create the belief that police work is primarily about crime fighting requiring physical strength and masculinity. Police recruitment propaganda has often projected the same image, resulting in a conflict between the type of applicant needed and the type that actually applies. In fact, the police force needs people who are emotionally stable and people-oriented, and who are not drawn to the position because of the power it grants them over others (Schweizer). It is clear from the foregoing that the police force needs a change in culture and, concurrently, an ability to attract a different kind of candidate if it is to achieve the institutionalization of more professional job and management skills.
The culture of authoritarianism, coupled with the fact that college education was not a prerequisite for police officers, finally led to a situation where police management practices related to street crime suppression, brutality, corruption, and discrimination came increasingly under public scrutiny. As Thibault et al. (1995) note: "Amid the race riots and social protests of the 1960s, the President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice called for all police officers to possess college degrees." (p. 263). Emerging from the recognition that higher education had an important role to play in police management, criminal justice educational programs were developed, and by 1990 over 1,000 academic criminal justice programs existed in colleges and universities (Morn, 1995, p. 180).
At first, the historic connection of criminal justice with police science appeared to be too vocational, and it was found that many aspects of criminal justice could fit into traditional academic disciplines. For example, police management could be covered under public administration programs. The adoption of a liberal arts model led to only a few programs remaining committed to the practical aspects of law enforcement. As a result, the field grew so scholarly that many students and practitioners found it irrelevant, as evidenced by a 1988 Police Executive Research Forum (PERF) survey, which reported that only 48.8% of police agencies preferred a criminal justice degree when hiring college graduates (Morn, 1995, p. 180).
The debate on the need to hire college-educated police officers is ongoing. There is some data suggesting that educated officers have a lower incidence of brutality complaints. Opponents to higher education requirements counter such data with statistics indicating that higher education is linked to lower tenure. As of now, the minimum standards applied in police recruitment largely focus on excluding convicted felons, people convicted of crimes of domestic violence, and those with substance abuse histories. For the remainder, recruitment of the right candidates depends on psychological and emotional screening tests (Schweizer).
The ongoing debate also reflects the tension between academic criminology and practical law enforcement. While scholars advocate for college degrees as a way to professionalize the force, many police administrators remain skeptical of the direct applicability of classroom instruction to street-level policing. Nevertheless, the evidence from jurisdictions that have raised educational requirements suggests meaningful improvements in officer conduct and community relations.
"How educated officers reform police culture and training"
"Education's role in shaping police codes of ethics"
"Research, planning, and resource management benefits"
Though there are opponents to the need for college-educated police officers on the grounds that there is a wide gap between classroom theory and street reality, it is evident that education can bring many important benefits: a more positive image of the police as protectors of justice and peace, improved relations with the communities served, problem-solving skills drawing on human relations and behavioral management techniques, and an organizational structure that optimizes available resources. The continued development and refinement of criminal justice education programs remains an important investment in the professionalization of policing and the quality of public safety.
You’re 58% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.