This paper examines the concept of emerging adulthood as a developmental period and analyzes how its experience differs across cultural contexts. Drawing on Arnett's theory of emerging adulthood and Erikson's psychosocial development framework, the paper identifies five defining features of this life stage: identity exploration, instability, self-focus, feeling in-between, and possibilities. The analysis reveals that emerging adulthood is primarily a phenomenon of industrialized societies and may be shortened or absent in cultures with different values around marriage, parenthood, and family obligations. The paper explores how young people from ethnic minority groups face unique pressures balancing cultural expectations, bicultural identity development, and the autonomy characteristic of emerging adulthood in Western contexts.
Emerging adulthood is a distinct life stage occurring between adolescence and adulthood, characterized by demographic change, subjective experience, and identity exploration. As Arnett describes it, "30 is the new 20"—a period in which individuals explore various alternatives before settling into stable commitments, rather than immediately assuming traditional adult roles. This transitional phase is defined by high levels of personal freedom and minimal social responsibility. The experience reflects young people's need to explore independent roles and identities before committing to long-term partnerships, careers, or parenthood.
However, emerging adulthood is not a universal phenomenon. It exists primarily in post-industrial societies that allow a gradual transition from adolescence to adulthood. The presence and duration of this life stage depend heavily on cultural context, varying significantly across different cultural and ethnic groups. The experience of emerging adulthood does vary as a result of differing cultural contexts, which causes young people to deal with pressures depending on their ethnicity.
A person's cultural context encompasses the physical and psychological environments that surround and shape them. Understanding emerging adulthood requires grounding it in established developmental theory. According to Erikson's stages of psychosocial development, Arnett (2002) identifies new stages in the psychosocial development of young people. Arnett builds on Erikson's research and expands the theory of identity formation, recognizing that identity formation is crucial during the period between adolescence and young adulthood. This stage reflects significant changes in social processes taking place in Western culture.
Emerging adulthood should be understood as a characteristic of culture rather than of individual countries. Within highly industrialized countries, members of minority cultures may experience shortened periods of emerging adulthood. Cultural beliefs prohibiting premarital sex and emphasizing the desirability of large families create considerable social pressure to marry early and begin having children. Schlegel and Barry (1991) concluded that while adolescence exists as a universal life stage, the period between adolescence and adulthood was present in only 20 percent of the cultures they studied. In these cultures, adulthood was signified by marriage by age 20, soon followed by parenthood.
Arnett describes five features that define emerging adulthood. The first is the age of identity exploration, in which emerging adults continuously explore different options to discover who they are and what they want to become. This characteristic occurs primarily in the areas of romantic relationships and careers (Arnett, 2004, p. 8-9).
The second feature is the age of instability. During this period, emerging adults encounter hardship as their life plans encounter reality. Young adults often experience career changes, relationship transitions, and residential moves (Arnett, 2004, p. 10-11).
The third feature is the self-focused age. Emerging adults delay adult responsibilities such as marriage and parenthood to enjoy their freedom without parental constraints. They focus on their own personal needs and goals (Arnett, 2004, p. 12-13).
Fourth is the age of feeling in-between. Emerging adults experience themselves as neither adolescent nor adult. They are in transition between the restrictions of adolescence and the full responsibilities of adulthood (Arnett, 2004, p. 12-13).
Finally, the age of possibilities reflects emerging adults' confidence that they will achieve better lives than their parents and will find lasting romantic partnerships (Arnett, 2004, p. 12-13).
Emerging adulthood takes different forms across cultures, and young people from ethnic groups often face unique challenges. They are expected to assume the role of full adulthood—including marriage and parenthood—earlier than their peers in dominant cultural groups. These challenges include navigating their relationship to their ethnic group and the larger society while constructing a coherent sense of identity. Young people must address the complexity of being bicultural.
According to Erikson, identity development occurs within the context of finding one's social role within their environment. The person's needs, interests, and social environment together shape identity development. Erikson also believed that identity is composed of beliefs, emotions, and desires. For emerging adults to find their self-identity, a major component involves balancing cultural expectations, goals, and values with personal aspirations. Furthermore, emerging adults are reflecting on their own beliefs and restructuring their worldviews, processes influenced by experiences in university and work contexts. While exploring different experiences, they simultaneously face feelings of frustration and instability as they move closer to or away from their own and their families' expectations.
Young people in minority groups must navigate conflicting images of their ethnic group in the broader culture while finding a satisfactory identity. Many young people living at home are expected to show respect to their parents and respond to the needs of family members. Therefore, young people from ethnic backgrounds face high expectations from their parents regarding education, work, and individual achievement. At the same time, they are also expected to be independent and assertive—values emphasized in the dominant culture. The differences in cultural values experienced by ethnic minorities can create significant pressure and stress.
Experimentation and self-focusing are two key characteristics of emerging adulthood, though they manifest differently across cultures. Individuals focusing on themselves experience new situations and make independent decisions, even regarding small life choices. In industrialized societies, these two characteristics are related to each other. However, in minority cultures, the situation changes significantly.
The primary reason for this change is that in minority cultures, there is always someone to consult when making decisions throughout every period of life. For instance, adolescents in these contexts do not necessarily need to focus on themselves, because there is always somebody available to give advice and make decisions on their behalf. Additionally, adolescents receive support from others even for simple decisions. This community and cultural support restricts experimentation by emerging adults because dependency and protection are values supported by the community.
The American Psychological Association recognizes that these cultural differences in autonomy and decision-making authority represent fundamental variations in how development unfolds. In collectivist cultures, identity exploration may take forms quite different from the individualistic exploration emphasized in Arnett's Western framework. The balance between personal autonomy and family obligation remains a central tension for many emerging adults from ethnic minority backgrounds navigating multiple cultural expectations.
Emerging adulthood is a cultural theory and is shaped by how emerging adulthood is experienced. In many cultures, these beliefs include the desirability of striving for self-sufficiency before taking on adult responsibilities of love and work. However, the form and duration of this life stage vary significantly across cultural contexts, with minority cultures within industrialized societies and non-Western cultures often compressing or reformulating the emerging adulthood period based on different values regarding family, marriage, and individual autonomy. Young people from ethnic minority backgrounds face distinctive pressures as they navigate conflicting cultural expectations and work to develop coherent identities across multiple cultural contexts.
You’re 98% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.