This paper traces the evolution of United States fiscal policy from the pre-Depression era of minimal government intervention through the rise of Keynesian economic thought, the transformative tax changes spurred by World War II, and the political pressures of the mid-twentieth century. It examines how shifting economic structures, labor movements, and ideological changes shaped tax policy, culminating in the landmark Tax Reform Act of 1986. The paper concludes by reflecting on the contemporary trend toward market-driven fiscal logic and reduced federal intervention in the private economy.
The paper effectively uses historical periodization as an analytical tool. Rather than simply listing tax changes, it explains the economic and political forces driving each shift, showing how structural changes in capitalism and democratic pressure from labor movements translated into new fiscal priorities. This cause-and-effect framing strengthens the overall argument.
The paper is organized chronologically and thematically: it opens with pre-Depression minimal governance, introduces Keynesian theory, examines the WWII tax transformation, discusses postwar political economy, critiques mid-century tax expenditures, highlights the Tax Reform Act of 1986 as a turning point, and closes with a brief reflection on current fiscal trends. Each section builds on the last, creating a cohesive narrative arc.
Before the United States entered the Great Depression, the government's approach to the economy was laissez-faire — meaning it did not intervene in business affairs. Taxes were typically paid only by the wealthiest individuals and companies, and were therefore often referred to as class or mass taxes under an "Ability to Pay" arrangement (Waltman 1985).
British economist John Maynard Keynes — widely regarded as the father of Keynesian economics — believed the best way to encourage fiscal stability for the nation was to leverage government spending to promote consumption and investment. He believed that government could influence macroeconomic productivity levels by increasing or decreasing tax levels and public spending. This in turn would decrease inflation, increase employment, and keep the overall value of money stable.
The logic of Keynesian economics became widely accepted. Economists increasingly came to believe that government could and should effectively manage the capitalist economy (Dyson 2010).
The economy evolved considerably between World War I and World War II. World War II, in particular, led to dramatic changes in ideas about taxation. The costs of fighting the war were enormous, and it was clear that no one would be able to avoid massive increases in their personal tax burden. At the same time, more people were moving away from agriculture and into industry. More incomes were being paid in cash by employers via weekly paychecks. A new political economy had opened up and ushered in new ideas about taxation (Weber and Wildavsky 1986).
Unions and new working- and middle-class political parties were stirred into action. Their representatives increasingly demanded that taxes be used as instruments to correct the unfair distribution of income and wealth produced by capitalism. New fiscal policies emerged in response to the changing structure of capitalism and the political demands placed upon policymakers.
There were newer sources of revenue, which meant new levels of government involvement in the economy. This ultimately shaped what policymakers and interest group activists understood to be both possible and desirable. Eventually, it was determined necessary for government to take a more active role in regulating unemployment, business cycles, inflation, and the cost of money (Waltman 1985). Tax policies were aimed at being more efficient, universal, and fair, although they were not always successful in accomplishing these goals (Weber and Wildavsky 1986).
You’re 51% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.