This paper provides a close exegetical reading of Luke 4:1-13, the passage in which Jesus is tempted three times by the devil following His baptism and desert retreat. Drawing on scholars including Joseph Fitzmyer, John Nolland, Alfred Plummer, and Fulton Sheen, the paper examines each temptation as both a clarification of Christ's redemptive mission and a model for how Christians are to confront their own trials. The paper also considers the distinctive features of Luke's Gospel — its Gentile audience, its emphasis on prayer and sacrifice, and its foreshadowing of the Cross — before offering a practical application of the passage for contemporary Christian life.
According to John Hayes and Carl Holladay, exegesis is an exercise in "leading" — which is to say that a scriptural exegesis acts as a kind of interpretation, helping people to understand more fully the Word of God (1). This paper provides an exegesis of Luke 4:1-13, in which Jesus is tempted three times by the devil, and it will also show how each temptation helps to clarify for Christians the exact mission of Christ (Fitzmyer 509).
Luke was a Gentile by birth and by profession a doctor. According to tradition he was also an artist and is still revered by many today as a patron of both doctors and artists. An early companion of St. Paul, Luke can be said to have been influenced by the Apostle. Indeed, Luke's writings are filled with a similar zealousness found in Paul's letters. What makes Luke's Gospel unique among the other Gospel narratives is that it emphasizes the sacrificial nature of Christ, beginning as it does with the chronicle of Zachary the priest. Moreover, Luke's Gospel appears to be dedicated to the Gentile converts, with whom he could share some common ground. This Gospel may also especially appeal to modern readers, who live in a neo-pagan era where the gods of gold and celebrity are worshipped. We should not fail to appreciate the characteristics of Luke, which are spiritually satisfying because they concentrate on the spiritual aspects of Jesus. More than any other Gospel, the Gospel of Luke shows Christ "as an example of prayer" (Frey 144), and it is the episode of Christ's temptation in this last of the Synoptic Gospels that we now examine.
Joseph Fitzmyer notes that the three scenes of Jesus' temptation, though they differ in order from the other Synoptic Gospels, "have a common subject in that they correct a false understanding of Jesus' mission as Son" (509). The scenes of Jesus' temptation in Luke help clarify the exact mission of Christ, but each of the temptations also serves as an example of the kind of temptation every person can be expected to face at some point in life — in modern times no less than in ancient. Such is the reason they are recorded by Luke, according to Fulton Sheen, who describes each temptation as a "short cut from the cross" to kingship. "Good men," as Sheen states, "are not tempted in the same way as evil men, and the Son of God, Who became man, was not tempted in the same way as even a good man" (63). As Luke's narrative begins, Jesus is being "led by the Spirit" (Luke 4:1), which is to say he was participating in a retreat in the desert. Going into the desert was often a part of retreating from the world and getting in touch with the spirit. Those who did so removed themselves from the company of others to grow in solitary communion with God. Jesus does this after his baptism, to show that the soul's entry into communion with God must be accompanied by submission through prayer and fasting. Following this example, Jesus is tempted by Satan — a situation that we can all expect to face when we attempt to draw near to God.
According to Sheen, Satan tempts Jesus by "pretending to help Him find an answer to the question: How could He best fulfill His high destiny among men? Satan had a satanic suggestion, namely to bypass the moral problem of guilt and its need of expiation, and to concentrate purely on worldly factors" (63). Jesus was tempted to be like so many social institutions whose primary concern is the economic endowment of man — through which the belly is so often satisfied. But Jesus was not primarily on Earth to satisfy the belly. His retreat following His baptism showed the purpose of His life: to prepare for His death. Such is why He allowed His first temptation: "If you are the Son of God, command that this stone become a loaf of bread" (Luke 4:3).
As Sheen observes, Satan "was appealing to Our Lord to stop acting as a man, and in the name of man, and to use his supernatural powers to give His human nature ease, comfort, and immunity from trial" (64). However, Jesus' life was one of trial, not of comfort, and his answer to Satan is perfectly recollected: "Not by bread alone shall man live, but by every word of God" (Luke 4:4). Undaunted, Satan attempts another tactic to divert Jesus from His destination — the Cross. "To thee will I give all this power and their glory… if thou wilt worship before me" (Luke 4:6-7). Jesus delivers the reproof that man shall worship and serve God alone, despite whatever honors one may be offered by the world. As Sheen asks, "Why could He not choose a much quicker way of establishing His kingdom, by striking up a treaty, which would give Him all He desired, namely the world, but without the Cross?" (68). The answer, Sheen states, is in Jesus' absolute refusal of any compromise — a striking claim. By stating exactly whom man should worship, without exception, Jesus clears the path to the Cross.
But He permits one final temptation. Satan virtually commands Jesus to prove His divinity by hurling Himself from the ramparts — for the angels would not dare allow harm to come to Him Who Is. Satan, essentially, tells God to do the unreasonable to prove Himself: show your power by annihilating yourself. Jesus decides rather to prove that faith "must never contradict reason" (Sheen 67). Jesus' response is the essence of medieval scholasticism upon which doctors like Thomas Aquinas would build their theology.
"Source origins and Luke's language choices for Gentiles"
"Contemporary relevance of the temptation narrative"
Luke 4:1-13 offers a glimpse into the writings of the evangelist who accompanied St. Paul on his journeys, soaking up his spiritual insights and imbuing his own work with a prayerful vision of Jesus. The temptation scenes of Luke 4 show Jesus as a strict and straightforward force of opposition to the devil — referred to by Matthew as Satan. Satan tempts Jesus, as Fulton Sheen suggests, away from the Cross: first, by appealing to Jesus as a humanitarian ("Turn the stone into bread"); second, as a politically minded man of the world ("All this shall be yours if only you worship me"); third, as a man of pride whose faith goes against reason ("Throw yourself down and God will save you"). To each temptation Jesus responds by ignoring the devil's urgings and restating God's law — quoting divine scripture in each case. In this sense, Luke appropriately provides a Gospel narrative for the Gentiles, hoping to encourage them in their own time of trials.
You’re 62% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.