Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,080 words

Famine, Politics, and Aid in Africa: de Waal and Galvan

~6 min read 7 sections Social Issues · Hunger
Abstract

This paper examines the causes of famine and underdevelopment in Africa through the works of Alex de Waal and Dennis C. Galvan. Drawing on de Waal's concept of the "anti-famine political contract," the paper argues that authoritarian regimes undermine famine prevention by removing accountability mechanisms that democracies provide. It further explores Galvan's account of the Serer people of Senegal, whose indigenous land-use systems were disrupted by French colonial economic models. Together, these perspectives suggest that both colonial powers and contemporary NGOs have at times worsened African economic conditions by imposing external frameworks that ignore local realities and governance structures.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Famine as a Political and Economic Reality: Overview of famine scholarship and NGO critique
  • De Waal's Anti-Famine Political Contract: De Waal's political contract theory explained
  • Democracy, Authoritarianism, and Famine Prevention: How regime type shapes famine accountability
  • Galvan and Indigenous Economic Development in Senegal: Serer land systems and local economic success
  • Colonial Economic Models and Their Lasting Damage: French economic imposition disrupted Senegalese systems
  • NGOs, Misconceptions, and Parallels to Colonialism: NGO failures compared to colonial economic harm
  • Conclusion: Local Solutions and the Limits of External Intervention: Argument for locally adapted over external solutions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It synthesizes two distinct scholarly works — de Waal's political analysis and Galvan's village-level case study — into a coherent comparative argument about external intervention in Africa.
  • The paper draws a thought-provoking parallel between colonial economic imposition and contemporary NGO practices, grounding an abstract critique in concrete historical examples.
  • It uses specific regional cases (Ethiopia, Somalia, Senegal) to anchor broader theoretical claims, giving the argument empirical texture without overextending its evidence.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates comparative source synthesis: rather than summarizing each book separately, it weaves their arguments together around a shared theme — the harm caused by imposing external frameworks on African societies. This technique allows the student to build a unified analytical thread across two different scholarly works and disciplinary perspectives.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a framing introduction, then develops de Waal's political contract theory, including its democratic versus authoritarian implications. It transitions to Galvan's village-level economic history in Senegal, uses it to critique colonial economic transplantation, and closes by drawing a direct analogy between colonial powers and NGOs. The conclusion reinforces the argument for locally adapted solutions over externally imposed interventions.

Essay 1,080 words

Introduction: Famine as a Political and Economic Reality

Famines and famine situations have been, and continue to be, cruel realities in Africa. Scholars such as Alex de Waal and Dennis C. Galvan have attempted both to identify the causes of famines and poor economic development in Africa and to suggest constructive paths forward — in terms of both prevention and response. In the process, difficult realities have emerged, many with political consequences. Among the most striking is the finding that many NGOs that claim to help people in Africa during times of need are, in practice, directing money and dedication elsewhere.

In his book Famine Crimes: Politics and the Disaster Relief Industry in Africa, Alex de Waal argues that international humanitarian assistance has often amplified African problems rather than resolved them. This is not a blanket condemnation — de Waal himself never denies the genuine help some NGOs provide — but he contends that a persistent misunderstanding of African realities frequently creates the conditions for counterproductive action.

De Waal's Anti-Famine Political Contract

A central contribution of de Waal's analysis is his concept of the "political contract," or "anti-famine contract," that may be concluded between a people and their rulers. He connects famine directly to the nature of the political regime in place at a given time. The famines in Ethiopia and Somalia, for example, are not isolated catastrophes but reflections of the political regimes those countries had implemented.

The central problem with such a contract is that it is far more likely to be concluded — and honored — under democratic regimes than under authoritarian ones (de Waal, 2000). The logic is straightforward: authoritarian regimes act and react on the basis of unchecked power. They therefore have no meaningful obligation, beyond a purely moral one, to enter into or to respect contracts with the people they govern.

5 Sections Hidden · 655 words
Democracy, Authoritarianism, and Famine Prevention140 words
In a democracy, by contrast, the powers of rulers are constrained by a constitution and by legislative and judicial institutions. This means that democratic leaders are subject to removal, and that…
Galvan and Indigenous Economic Development in Senegal160 words
Dennis C. Galvan's book The State Must Be Our Master of Fire offers…
Colonial Economic Models and Their Lasting Damage130 words
The Western-style economy introduced by the French encountered several serious problems. Most fundamentally, it was not a sustainable model in the Senegalese…
NGOs, Misconceptions, and Parallels to Colonialism150 words
To be fair, the original purposes are quite different. For colonial powers, exploitation was the defining rationale for colonization. In…
Conclusion: Local Solutions and the Limits of External Intervention75 words
Local and village-level economic developments may often appear primitive and irrelevant to those belonging to Western civilization. On the other hand, it must be recognized that they are…

Bibliography

de Waal, Alex. Famine Crimes: Politics and the Disaster Relief Industry in Africa. Oxford, 1997.

Galvan, Dennis C. The State Must Be Our Master of Fire. June 2004.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Anti-Famine Contract Political Accountability Authoritarian Regimes NGO Critique Colonial Economic Legacy Indigenous Land Systems Local Governance Famine Prevention Humanitarian Aid Senegal Serer
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Famine, Politics, and Aid in Africa: de Waal and Galvan. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/famine-politics-aid-africa-de-waal-galvan-64447

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.