Psychoanalysis and Grief in Faulkner's As I Lay Dying
This essay examines William Faulkner's 1930 novel As I Lay Dying through a psychoanalytic lens, analyzing how the Bundren family's journey to bury matriarch Addie reveals the complexity of human grief, self-interest, and psychological defense mechanisms. The paper explores how each family member's divergent motivations and responses to bereavement expose broader truths about the human psyche. It also discusses Faulkner's narrative techniques — particularly stream-of-consciousness and multiple perspectives — and how these formal choices deepen the novel's psychological portrait of mourning, identity, and familial breakdown.
- Introduction: Modernism and the Human Psyche: Novel framed as psychoanalytic modernist text
- Selfishness and Ulterior Motives Among the Bundrens: Each family member harbors selfish reasons for journey
- Divergent Grief Responses Across Family Members: Cash's stability contrasts with family's existential crisis
- Grief, Identity, and Psychological Instability: Darl's identity crisis and descent into insanity
- Blame, Tragedy, and Family Cohesion: Disasters and blame-trading test family unity
- Stream-of-Consciousness and Narrative Technique: Multiple narrators and symbolic language reveal psychology
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper consistently grounds its psychological claims in direct textual evidence, quoting characters' monologues (such as Darl's existential soliloquy and Dewey Dell's "loud thinking") to support its interpretations.
- It maintains a clear analytical throughline — that self-centeredness shapes each character's response to grief — which unifies what could otherwise be a scattered character-by-character survey.
- The essay balances attention to narrative form (stream-of-consciousness, multiple perspectives, symbolic language) with thematic content, showing how technique reinforces meaning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates psychoanalytic literary criticism — applying concepts such as defense mechanisms, ego identity, and mourning dynamics to fictional characters. Rather than simply summarizing plot, the writer interprets characters' behaviors as symptoms of deeper psychological states, a hallmark of this critical approach.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a theoretical framing of the novel as a psychoanalytic text, then moves through the characters systematically — contrasting stable grief responses (Cash) with unstable ones (Darl) — before widening to group dynamics, blame-trading, and family cohesion. It closes with an analysis of Faulkner's narrative technique. This funnel-then-widen structure effectively moves from individual psychology to collective behavior to authorial craft.
Introduction: Modernism and the Human Psyche
William Faulkner's 1930 novel As I Lay Dying is a landmark of modernist literature that incorporates a deeply psychological dimension. As a psychoanalytic novel, it displays the intricacy of the human psyche by attempting to unravel what lies within human minds. The novel presents an emotionally, psychologically, and physically distressing journey undertaken by a family marked by selfishness and divergent desires. It offers a critical inquiry into the psychoanalysis of human minds and their responses to tribulation, and its richness in human emotion echoes a self-centeredness that produces wide divergence in human behavior.
Group dynamics are vividly and richly drawn throughout the novel, which covers multiple psychological complexities across its characters. The story is narrated from multiple perspectives and addresses several dimensions of human experience, including characters' psychological development, mechanisms of defense, and the dynamics of mourning. The novel incorporates the inevitability of anguish and grief to define the values of human existence. Its central situation — the expedition of the fictional Bundren family through a fictitious Yoknapatawpha County as they transport their deceased wife and mother, Addie, to her hometown of Jefferson — becomes a vehicle for exploring incongruities in response to bereavement and the full spectrum of human emotion.
Selfishness and Ulterior Motives Among the Bundrens
Self-centeredness and insensitivity are paradoxes that feature throughout the plot. The family begins deliberating about the mother's death, coffin, and burial while she is still on her deathbed and while they are not yet certain of her passing. Superficially, the family is remorseful and intends to accord Addie her wished-for burial, but a deeper reading reveals ulterior motives that energize each member's desire to travel to Jefferson. As the Bundrens share the burden of grief, they are largely drawn toward the personal opportunities that arise from Addie's death and the journey it necessitates.
The eldest son, Cash, constructs a coffin for his dying mother just outside her window — she lies "with her head propped up so she could watch Cash building the coffin." While Cash argues that his mother derives more value from observing the coffin's construction than from his company at her side, his motive is in part driven by a materialistic desire to demonstrate his carpentry skills. His later impulse to rescue the drowning coffin from the river is similarly motivated by wanting to recover his work tools stored inside it. Ostensibly, the family journeys to Jefferson to honor Addie's burial wish, but each member carries concealed, self-interested intentions alongside that duty.
The family members display divergent obsessions that symbolize the individualism characteristic of modern society. Although Addie's husband, Anse, insists on taking his deceased wife to Jefferson because it was her wish, he simultaneously admits his desire to procure a new set of teeth. The family's only daughter, Dewey Dell, is driven by the need to obtain an abortion, while the youngest child, Vardaman, is consumed by an obsession with getting a toy train. Dewey Dell's self-absorption is made explicit in her interior monologue: "I heard that my mother is dead. I wish I had time to let her die." By contrast, Darl embarks on the journey to ensure the mother receives a proper burial while simultaneously observing and tracking the family's behavior. Jewel — Addie's son by the local minister Mr. Whitfield, not by Anse — wishes primarily to be apart from his family. Even Addie herself, introduced posthumously in a striking narrative choice, reveals a selfish wish to spend eternity as far from the Bundrens as possible, as revenge for the depression she suffered after Darl's birth. Faulkner's decision to introduce Addie's perspective after her death is a deliberately puzzling device used to sustain the reader's interest.
Divergent Grief Responses Across Family Members
The novel demonstrates that responses to psychological pain vary widely across individuals. Each family member counters grief in a different way. Cash responds to the loss by absorbing himself in work. His reaction to his mother's illness and death demonstrates the behavior of a well-adjusted person possessing maturity and understanding. This stability is arguably rooted in the loving, secure relationship Cash and Addie shared — one in which Cash did not define himself through his mother but through his craft. Cash sees life in a constructive light. While other family members are drawn into existential questioning because of their more fraught relationships with Addie, Cash concentrates on labor, revealing the strength of his psychological foundation.
The contrasting reactions of the Bundren siblings illustrate how the quality of one's bond with the deceased shapes the experience of grief. Characters whose relationships with Addie were ambivalent or deprived — particularly Darl — experience the most severe psychological disruption, while Cash's relative equanimity points to the stabilizing effect of secure attachment. Faulkner thus uses the divergent grief responses not merely for dramatic variety but to make a sustained argument about the relationship between human bonds and psychological resilience.
References
Faulkner, William. As I Lay Dying: The Corrected Text. New York: Modern Library, 2000. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.