High-Stakes Testing and Its Negative Effects on Learning
This essay argues that high-stakes testing, as mandated by the No Child Left Behind Act, has a negative effect on student learning. The paper presents three central arguments: first, that high-stakes testing incentivizes teachers to teach to the test rather than fostering genuine competency; second, that students come to view passing the test as the ultimate goal of education, generating harmful stress and increased dropout risk; and third, that students with learning disabilities are systematically disadvantaged because schools fail to provide the accommodations and appropriate curriculum they need to succeed on standardized assessments.
- Introduction: High-Stakes Testing and the No Child Left Behind Act: Overview of high-stakes testing and thesis statement
- Teaching to the Test Instead of Teaching for Competency: Teachers incentivized to prioritize test content over real skills
- Students' Misplaced Focus on Test Performance: Testing stress causes students to lose sight of learning
- Disadvantages for Students with Learning Disabilities: Learning-disabled students harmed by inadequate testing accommodations
- Conclusion: Rethinking High-Stakes Assessment: Summary of harms and call for further research
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay presents a clear three-part argumentative structure, previewing each argument in the introduction and developing each in its own dedicated section, making the logic easy to follow.
- Each argument is grounded in cited research, including peer-reviewed sources and policy analyses, lending credibility to the claims beyond personal opinion.
- The paper addresses counterarguments briefly before refuting them, demonstrating awareness of the opposing perspective without dwelling on it.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates classical argumentative essay structure: a thesis is stated in the introduction, supported by three distinct and progressively broadening arguments (teacher behavior, student psychology, and systemic inequity), and restated in the conclusion with a call for further research. This scaffolded approach ensures each point builds logically on the last.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with context about educational assessment and the role of the No Child Left Behind Act, then states its thesis and previews its three arguments. Each body section addresses one argument in turn, with supporting citations. The conclusion synthesizes all three arguments and closes with a cautionary policy recommendation, noting that further research is needed before high-stakes testing can be deemed safe or beneficial.
Introduction: High-Stakes Testing and the No Child Left Behind Act
Most teachers and administrators agree that it is important to measure student learning within schools. Performing tests, obtaining results, and analyzing those results can help schools make decisions about curriculum, faculty, and environment, among other variables. Obtaining test results can help schools better serve their students, producing more capable learners. But what is the best way to obtain these results?
The No Child Left Behind Act mandates high-stakes testing as the primary assessment method through which student learning is evaluated. High-stakes testing has even been called the "backbone" of No Child Left Behind (Nichols, n.d., para. 4). High-stakes tests can be defined as assessments used to make influential decisions about students' lives, such as whether they will advance to the next grade or graduate. Beckette and Brown argue that most teachers do not support high-stakes testing (cited in "Pros and Cons," 2006, para. 3). In fact, there are many arguments against high-stakes testing, though some argue that carefully designed high-stakes testing can be beneficial in shaping "school curriculum and reform" ("Pros and Cons," 2006, para. 5).
This essay argues that high-stakes testing has a negative effect on student learning. This argument is developed through three claims: first, that high-stakes testing encourages teachers to teach to the test rather than teaching the skills students need to obtain genuine competency in a field; second, that high-stakes testing encourages students to view the test — rather than learning itself — as the ultimate goal of education; and third, that high-stakes testing disadvantages students with learning disabilities.
References
Amrein, A. L., & Berliner, D. C. (2002, March 28). High-stakes testing, uncertainty, and student learning. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 10(18). Retrieved February 22, 2009, from
Appropriate use of high-stakes testing in our nation's schools. (2001, May). Retrieved February 22, 2009, from the American Psychological Association.
Cortiella, C. (2004, June). Implications of high-stakes testing for students with learning disabilities. Retrieved February 22, 2009, from Great Schools. http://www.greatschools.net/cgi-bin/showarticle/2846
Heubert, J. P. (2002). High-stakes testing: Opportunities and risks for students of color, English-language learners, and students with disabilities. Wakefield, MA: National Center on Accessing the General Curriculum. Retrieved February 22, 2008, from
Nichols, S. (n.d.). Motivation for high-stakes testing. Retrieved February 22, 2009, from
Pros and cons of NCLB: What research says. (2006). Retrieved February 22, 2009, from the Educational Research Newsletter.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.