This paper examines the case for reforming traditional education in response to the demands of a global, knowledge-based economy. Drawing on foundational theorists including Piaget, Dewey, Bruner, and Rogers, it traces the development of constructivist and experiential learning approaches that position students as active participants rather than passive recipients of knowledge. The paper further explores learning styles theory and Gardner's multiple intelligences framework as tools for personalizing instruction. It concludes with an international comparison of educational performance — particularly between the United States and Japan — to identify instructional practices associated with higher student achievement in mathematics, and considers what these findings mean for curriculum design and classroom practice.
It is now understood that the traditional form of education needs to change. First, students will face a completely different environment when they enter a fast-paced and global world. Second, a growing body of research recognizes that children learn very differently, and the teacher-lecture approach does not provide the best education for everyone. Third, in today's environment, knowledge is the main product for sale. To develop this product, students need a high-quality, specialized learning situation. Increasingly, schools will have to offer well-rounded education to successfully prepare the next generation of students to meet a wide variety of experiences and face many different challenges.
The Industrial Age required more workers than thinkers, so in most respects school was designed for learning the basics needed to get by (Reigeluth, 1994). Those who had a desire to learn and continue their studies went on to the next level of education, while everyone else entered the workforce. As the world became more complex with the creation of an information-based society, the ability to think, acquire knowledge, and adjust to changing situations became increasingly critical for larger numbers of workers.
Educators now recognize that the basics are no longer enough. Employers are demanding much more complex skills, even from high school graduates. Moreover, in an increasingly global economy that is becoming competitively flat, if the education of one country is not providing the necessary skill base, companies will simply hire graduates from another country or relocate their operations elsewhere.
Highly skilled workers are therefore crucial for a country's continued economic advancement. Not only must individuals be technologically competent, they must also have strong analytical abilities, interpersonal skills, and a creative entrepreneurial spirit. Today's organizations are looking for employees who can reason, problem-solve, multi-task, communicate effectively with diverse populations, and foster teamwork. Their people must be innovative and capable of working independently. For continued success in traditional fields such as computing and healthcare, as well as emerging industries such as nanotechnology and biotechnology, people are needed who can think outside the box and develop entirely new approaches to old problems.
In addition, the labor market is shifting quickly away from lifetime employment toward less permanent opportunities. Workers in this century need to be adaptable and flexible. Education and training is no longer solely about acquiring the skills and knowledge necessary to establish a foundation in one's career — it is required for continuous improvement over one's lifetime in order to keep pace with evolving work demands.
Over the last century, a number of different theories have been developed to explain how children learn. Many of these theoretical approaches have proven valid since they were first proposed. However, the way they are applied must be adapted to meet the changing needs of students and society. Jean Piaget (1936), a Swiss biologist and psychologist, is known for a model of birth-through-adulthood development and learning based on the concept that a growing person builds cognitive structures — or mental schemas and networks — for comprehending and relating to experiences within the environment. According to Piaget, a child's cognitive structure becomes increasingly sophisticated as it develops, growing from a few innate responses such as crying to highly complex mental activities.
Piaget (1936) describes a number of principles for expanding cognitive ability. As children develop, they experience their environment using the mental schemas they have established thus far. When they encounter a repeated experience, its results are assimilated into their cognitive structure so that they can maintain mental balance. When they encounter a new experience, they temporarily lose mental equilibrium and must adjust their cognitive structure to cope with the new situation. In this way, children build increasingly complex and adaptive cognitive structures. Several lessons can be drawn from Piaget's model for modern education: teachers must develop curricula that are developmentally appropriate and that enhance students' level of cognitive growth, and educators must stress the essential role that both established and new experiences play in students' continued learning.
Much of Piaget's theoretical framework is grounded in the work of John Dewey (1910) and the philosophy of constructivism — the idea that people understand only what they have created or constructed. Today, constructivism can be seen as establishing an interdisciplinary approach, since it encompasses a diverse set of educational, sociological, psychological, and philosophical theories. It should not be viewed as negating other teaching approaches, but rather as one that can be incorporated into existing learning environments as a means of enhancing the student's involvement in the process rather than leaving the teacher as the sole authority.
The constructivist approach places the emphasis on the learner rather than the teacher. Students need to experience their environment and, as a result, gain an understanding of its characteristics and qualities. They develop their own conceptualizations and discover personalized solutions to problems, which allows them to become more autonomous and independent. In the constructivist classroom, knowledge gained is influenced by the environment and the learners' beliefs and attitudes. Students are given the responsibility of identifying, solving, and evaluating problems, in addition to determining methods for applying experience gained to future situations. Teachers encourage learners to build on previously acquired knowledge and to construct new knowledge. Piaget's constructivist approach is grounded in his perspective on the psychological development of children and the essential element of discovery: "To understand is to discover, or reconstruct by rediscovery, and such conditions must be complied with if in the future individuals are to be formed who are capable of production and creativity and not simply repetition" (Piaget, 1973).
Another important educator, Rogers (1969), emphasizes what he calls experiential learning, which is closely related to constructivism. He distinguishes between cognitive or rote learning and experiential learning, which involves personal involvement, learner initiation and self-evaluation, and pervasive effects on the learner. Rogers contrasts this experiential approach with the traditional classroom, in which students are merely passive vessels receiving information from the teacher and the textbook. This perspective aligns with Dewey (1910), who believed that knowledge is gained only through experiences integrated into a social context — such as a classroom — where students participate in transforming materials and, as a result, form a learning community and build knowledge together. Rote memorization is not the optimal path to learning; instead, education should take place in a directed-learning situation where structured activities are combined with theory. The key point is that students must be engaged in meaningful activities that encourage them to apply the concepts they are attempting to learn.
Another theorist associated with constructivism is Bruner (1973), who views learning as a social process in which students construct new concepts founded on current knowledge. Learners select information, construct hypotheses, and make decisions with the goal of integrating new situations into their existing mental constructs. Cognitive structures provide meaning and order to experiences and give learners the opportunity to go beyond the established limitations of the information supplied. Bruner believes that learner independence — furthered through the encouragement of discovery of new principles — is the basis for effective education. In addition, he argues that curriculum needs to be organized spirally so that students can build upon information they have already acquired.
Bruner (1973) stresses three key principles: readiness, meaning that instruction should be appropriate to the experiences that make the student willing and able to learn; spiral organization, meaning that teaching must be structured so that it is readily understood by students; and going beyond the information provided, meaning that instruction should be designed to facilitate extrapolation. By providing opportunities for independent thinking, constructivism allows students to take responsibility for their own learning — constructing questions and working to answer them. Going beyond basic factual information, students are encouraged to identify links between ideas and to theorize, explain, and defend their positions.
The constructivist approach can be incorporated successfully into the curriculum through learning guides tailored to students' prior knowledge, with an emphasis on hands-on problem solving. In their instruction, teachers stress making connections between learned facts and promoting new levels of student understanding. Instructors customize their strategies to learner responses and support students in their analysis, interpretation, and prediction of information. They rely considerably on open-ended questions and encourage widespread interaction among students. Learners are assessed as part of the educational process and play a larger role in determining their own progress, rather than being evaluated solely through grades and standardized testing.
The theories described above represent an alternative to the traditional teacher-lecture method, giving students greater involvement in their own learning process. One important element is that, as they grow older, students become more aware of the ways they best acquire information. It is now recognized that individuals learn in different ways — they perceive and process information through various means. The learning styles theory suggests that the way children acquire information has more to do with whether the educational experience aligns with their specific style of learning than with their intelligence.
The foundation of the learning styles methodology lies in the classification of psychological types. Research demonstrates that, due to hereditary factors, upbringing, and present circumstantial demands, different students have an inclination to perceive and process information differently. These different ways of learning include: (1) concrete or abstract perceivers — concrete perceivers acquire information through direct experience of doing, sensing, and feeling, while abstract perceivers accept new ideas through analyzing, observing, and thinking; and (2) active or reflective processors — active processors understand a new experience by immediately applying new information, while reflective processors analyze an experience by reflecting on it. Traditional schooling favors abstract perceiving and reflective processing, and other kinds of learning are not as well rewarded or reflected in curriculum, instruction, and assessment.
The classroom setting can also have a significant effect on the amount of learning that takes place. People differ in their environmental preferences, and the following common factors should be considered when creating optimal learning conditions (Moore, 1992):
"How individual learning preferences and environment shape outcomes"
"Seven intelligences and their implications for balanced curriculum"
"TIMSS data comparing U.S. and Japanese classroom approaches"
"Conclusions on individualized, culturally aware education reform"
You’re 41% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 4 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.