Hiring on the Basis of Looks: Ethics and Discrimination
This paper examines the controversial practice of hiring employees on the basis of physical appearance, using Abercrombie & Fitch's well-publicized recruitment policies as a central case study. The paper explores whether appearance-based hiring constitutes a form of discrimination, why it has historically received less scrutiny than race- or gender-based discrimination, and how unconscious bias shapes employer decisions. Drawing on perspectives from business ethics scholars and social researchers, the paper concludes with practical recommendations for companies seeking to build a branded workforce image while avoiding legal liability and ethical criticism.
- Introduction: The Abercrombie & Fitch Controversy: A&F hiring scandal and the core question raised
- Is Appearance-Based Hiring Unfair or Discriminatory?: Debating fairness and legitimacy of looks-based hiring
- Why Lookism Gets Less Attention Than Other Discrimination: Social stigma keeps appearance discrimination underreported
- Employer Bias and the Psychology of Hiring: Unconscious bias and clonal hiring tendencies
- Legal and Ethical Dimensions of Hiring for Looks: Legal risk and ethical critique of appearance-based policies
- Recommendations for Ethical Hiring Practices: Practical steps to avoid discrimination while building brand image
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a high-profile real-world case (Abercrombie & Fitch) to ground an abstract ethical question in concrete, recognizable events.
- Balances multiple perspectives — critics, defenders, legal analysts, and social commentators — giving the argument nuance rather than one-sided advocacy.
- Moves logically from problem identification through ethical analysis to actionable policy recommendations, giving the paper a clear practical orientation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied ethics reasoning: it does not simply declare a practice wrong but instead weighs competing considerations (employer freedom, public perception, legal risk, candidate qualifications) before arriving at a measured conclusion. The use of direct quotations from named scholars (Hatfield, Carroll, Rockman) to support each analytical step is a strong model of evidence-based argumentation in business ethics writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into two main movements. The first (problem identification) introduces the A&F case, defines the issue, surveys expert opinion on fairness and legality, and analyzes why appearance discrimination is underreported. The second (recommendations) pivots to practical guidance: how a company can legally and ethically shape its workforce image by linking hiring criteria to demonstrable job requirements — such as energy level and age bracket — rather than naked judgments about attractiveness.
Introduction: The Abercrombie & Fitch Controversy
Abercrombie & Fitch came under attack when it was found that many young, good-looking people were being offered jobs on the basis of their physical appearance. When the issue came to light, other complaints also surfaced: people from Filipino and African-American backgrounds reported having been rejected by the company because of their race. This gave rise to significant public outcry, and Abercrombie & Fitch acknowledged that it had been company policy to offer jobs to attractive people in order to improve sales.
Hiring practices have often come under fire due to discriminatory policies. However, while sex-, gender-, and race-based policies frequently lead to discrimination charges, people have yet to become sufficiently aware of hiring practices that focus too heavily on external appearance. This raises a fundamental question: is hiring on the basis of looks unfair, illegal, or even discriminatory?
It is easy to see that employing someone purely on the basis of looks is a form of discrimination against otherwise average-looking people. The question cannot have a simple yes-or-no answer, however, due to the variety of complexities involved. When Abercrombie & Fitch came under attack for hiring practices that appeared to exclude average-looking people, it triggered a broader debate regarding discrimination based on physical appearance.
As one account illustrates: "According to an attractive young woman, a student at [University], the same thing happens to her every time she goes shopping at Abercrombie and Fitch. On at least three occasions, store managers have approached her and offered her a job… Elizabeth looks like she belongs in an A&F catalog." (Carroll, p. 937)
References
Hatfield, Elaine. (1986). Mirror, Mirror: The Importance of Looks in Everyday Life (SUNY Series in Sexual Behavior). State University of New York Press.
Carroll, Archie B. (2008). Business and Society: Ethics and Stakeholder Management. South-Western College Publishing, 7th edition.
Rockman, Milton. (1982). Know how to interview for a job. Wisconsin State Journal.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.