This paper examines the famous 1945 photograph of Marines raising the American flag on Mount Suribachi during the Battle of Iwo Jima, drawing on James Bradley and Ron Powers' Flags of Our Fathers. It explores the brutal conditions the Marines faced against entrenched Japanese forces, the personal backgrounds and emotional struggles of the six men in the photograph, and the gap between the image's triumphant symbolism and the ongoing carnage it concealed. The paper also analyzes how media misrepresentation shaped public perception and burdened the survivors, who viewed the flag-raising not as a moment of glory but as one harrowing episode in a month-long ordeal.
Anyone who has ever seen the photograph of Marines raising an American flag on the island of Iwo Jima in 1945 recognizes that a tremendous struggle must have preceded that moment — but many people do not know the details surrounding it. The photograph does not reveal what it took for the men to reach the point where they could plant that flag. It does not reveal that this was the first time an American flag had been planted on Japanese soil, marking a significant benchmark in the end of the Pacific theater war. It does not reveal the full weight of what these men endured to get there.
The Japanese soldiers the Americans faced were the most seasoned, most experienced, and most determined in the Japanese army, and every one of them would literally fight to the end, choosing death over surrender. There were only 22,000 of them, but they were extremely well entrenched in a network of fortified and reinforced caves. Although the island had been bombarded before the first men landed, those bombs had had little effect because the caves sheltering the Japanese were so well reinforced.
The fight for Iwo Jima would be won yard by yard, and often through hand-to-hand combat. It was vital that American forces capture the island, and equally vital to the Japanese that they prevent that capture. As the author of Flags of Our Fathers writes, "somehow valor overcame terror" (p. 273). The carnage was terrible: by the end of the first day, fewer than 16% of the medical corpsmen had survived, and this handful of men had to do the best they could to help tremendous numbers of casualties, many with severe injuries.
The Marines landed on Iwo Jima on February 19. The author draws a pointed comparison to D-Day in Europe, where the fighting on the beach was over within 24 hours. On Iwo Jima, the fighting went on for days.
The seven men associated with raising the second flag at Iwo Jima were Ira Hayes, Franklin Sousley, John Bradley, Harlon Block, Mike Strank, "Doc" John Bradley, and Rene Gagnon. Each of these men endured hardships and horror to reach that powerful moment. They — and many others — had to crawl over bodies and body parts to advance. The first description of Harlon Block in the account is of a man in shock, stunned by what he had witnessed and possibly experiencing flashbacks of horrors seen on other islands. The men in the photograph represent all the agony, struggle, and hard-won progress of every soldier who contributed to getting American forces to that point, that day, on Iwo Jima. Men below the mountain cheered and shouted, believing the battle was over.
The actual flag shown in the famous photo had been saved from a ship sinking during the Pearl Harbor attack and was much larger than the first flag used on the summit. The photographer of the famous picture was Joe Rosenthal, who came upon the scene as men were raising the second, larger flag.
"Visual meaning of photo versus ongoing battle reality"
"Press embellishment distorted soldiers' stories and public view"
"Survivors struggled with violence, fame, and the hero label"
You’re 39% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.