This essay examines the ideological tensions embedded in Frank Darabont's 1999 film The Green Mile, focusing on how the character of John Coffey functions as a Christ-like, "Uncle Tom" savior figure whose supernatural suffering exists primarily to redeem white characters. Drawing comparisons to Darabont's earlier film The Shawshank Redemption (1994) and literary antecedents including Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin, the essay argues that The Green Mile's racial politics are obscured by its anti-death penalty message, its Depression-era Southern setting, and Coffey's deliberate narrative construction as inarticulate and one-dimensional. The paper also considers the film's commercial and critical reception and its debt to works such as Of Mice and Men.
The paper demonstrates ideological film criticism — reading a mainstream Hollywood text against the grain to expose how narrative choices (setting, characterization, focalization, and genre conventions) naturalize racially problematic assumptions. This technique requires the student to move beyond plot summary and ask whose story is being told and at whose expense.
The essay opens with a thesis that frames both films in contrast. It then methodically builds its case: the historical setting distances viewers from complicity; the white narrator silences the Black protagonist; Coffey's characterization echoes the Uncle Tom archetype; the supporting white characters further center whiteness; and a final section addresses the film's commercial reception and literary debts. The conclusion returns to the Christ/Uncle Tom parallel to restate the ideological stakes.
While both The Green Mile (1999) and The Shawshank Redemption (1994) share a prison setting and the same director, the two films' overarching ideological agendas stand in striking contrast. The Green Mile employs the Christ myth of a singular, suffering Black savior who exists to redeem white society. The Shawshank Redemption, by contrast, presents a morally ambiguous notion of salvation that all individuals must strive toward on their own terms, even as they work together to form a more viable prison community. The latter film offers a more complex and morally nuanced response to the stresses of a corrupt judicial system — one that cannot be fully healed, but can only be assuaged by individual rebellion and strivings for intellectual liberty in the midst of captivity and oppression.
The comfort that The Green Mile creates in the hearts of its viewers is partly a product of its setting in time and place. By situating the film in the deep, rural, Jim Crow-era South of 1935, the film creates a sense of historical distance and implies that America has changed a great deal since then. Merely by not being as vociferous a participant in racism as the most villainous characters in the drama, the viewer feels absolved — having "come a long way" — and is thus not perceived as complicit in the old system that convicts John Coffey. The movie is told as a series of flashbacks drawn from the memories of Paul Edgecomb, now an elderly man living in a retirement home, which further increases the sense of distance between the ideological past and the viewer's present.
The Green Mile's narrative focus is almost exclusively upon white characters, and the story is told in the voice of a white man. The compassionate white guards who control the fate of the central accused victim dominate both the frame and the focus of the tale. By virtue of the rigid segregation of Southern society, the film positions its focus on whites as historically inevitable — "that was the way things were back then." Whites speak for Blacks in the film, since the unjustly accused Black man, John Coffey, at the center of the drama is almost entirely inarticulate and illiterate. This allows Edgecomb to speak on his behalf rather than giving Coffey a voice to tell his own story or express his own longings — whatever those longings might be, since he speaks little of freedom and is, in terms of desire, presented as largely and comfortingly asexual.
Coffey is accused of killing and sexually violating two children, although he is portrayed as childlike himself. He lacks, for example, the intellectual presence of the Black man standing accused of raping a white woman in the 1962 drama To Kill a Mockingbird. Rather than being portrayed as an intellectual or morally complex character — like Morgan Freeman's character in The Shawshank Redemption — John Coffey is purely spiritual and Christ-like, gifted with faith healing rather than intelligence or developed character. He is so inarticulate that, upon first arriving at the prison, he can only say that his name is like the drink, only not "spelled the same," rather than speak of what he has been accused of or the freedom he has lost. Not only can Coffey barely read; he barely has a presence as a three-dimensional, speaking human being.
When the actor playing Coffey is on camera, his figure is physically imposing, but he has no memorable speaking moments beyond those tied to his supernatural gifts. The film's most famous scene, involving a mouse, focuses on the animal far more than on any complexity of emotion in Coffey himself — because there is no such complexity to the character, only metaphorical significance. Coffey is so childlike that he is even afraid to sleep without a night-light. The film's camera angles emphasize his physical size, while the audio mix makes his voice seem even quieter than the other characters' whispers.
The charge that a Black male character functions as an "Uncle Tom" saving figure for whites is not a trivial one. Yet Harriet Beecher Stowe's problematic anti-slavery classic and The Green Mile share a strikingly similar construction: a spiritually gifted yet intellectually diminished African American, unjustly captured and controlled by whites, who possesses greater spiritual gifts than his captors. John Coffey seems to exist in order to redeem his white accusers and captors, rather than for his own people or his own dignity. Whites clearly speak for Blacks, and a Black man saves whites — that is the essential dynamic of The Green Mile.
The backdating of the tale and its Southern location reinforce the parallels with anti-slavery narratives told through white eyes. The old Southern setting even implies, subtly, that unjust accusations of Black men do not occur today in the North, or at least not as frequently — as though the North were, in the tradition of Stowe, a purer domain of freedom rather than its own site of oppression. Just as Uncle Tom served as a Christ figure for Stowe — absent the discomforting Gospel preaching about the exaltation of the lowly — the mute, faith-healing Coffey functions as such a figure in The Green Mile, saving his white captors from the damnation of their own racism.
Edelstein, David. "The Green Mile." Film Review. Slate. 1999.
"The Green Mile." 1999. Directed by Frank Darabont. Business data available from the IMDb at http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120689/business.
"The Shawshank Redemption." 1994. Directed by Frank Darabont.
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom's Cabin. 1852.
"To Kill a Mockingbird." 1962. Directed by Robert Mulligan.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.