Friendship Categories in Judith Viorst's Essay Analyzed
This paper analyzes Judith Viorst's essay "Friends, Good Friends, and Such Good Friends," in which Viorst redefines friendship among women by replacing her earlier assumption of unqualified, uniform friendship with a structured taxonomy of eight categories. The paper examines how Viorst organizes these categories — convenience, special-interest, historical, crossroads, cross-generational, part-of-a-couple, men who are friends, and medium/pretty good/very good friends — into two broader groupings based on either affinity or similarity in characteristics. It also evaluates Viorst's informal, reader-friendly writing style and her balanced treatment of each category, concluding that the essay functions as both an entertaining and informative exploration of women's friendships.
- Introduction: Viorst's evolving view of women's friendship
- Overview of Viorst's Eight Friendship Categories: All eight categories named and listed
- Affinity-Based vs. Characteristic-Based Friendships: Two meta-groupings organizing the eight categories
- Writing Style and Tone: Informal tone and reader-friendly voice analyzed
- Evaluation of the Essay's Structure and Argument: Balanced structure, overlapping categories, overall assessment
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper identifies a clear organizing principle in Viorst's essay — affinity versus similarity in characteristics — and uses it to group the eight categories into a coherent framework, demonstrating analytical synthesis.
- The analysis addresses both content (the friendship categories) and craft (Viorst's tone and word choice), giving the response a well-rounded evaluative scope.
- The acknowledgment that categories may overlap in real life shows critical nuance and avoids oversimplification of the source text.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates categorical analysis: it takes Viorst's eight discrete categories and regroups them under two higher-level organizing principles, showing the reader a pattern the original essay implies but does not state explicitly. This move — reading a text to surface an underlying structure — is a foundational literary analysis skill.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief introduction to Viorst's essay and her shift in thinking about friendship. It then enumerates all eight categories before proposing the affinity/similarity binary as a meta-framework. A short section addresses Viorst's writing style and its effect on the reader, and the paper closes with an evaluative conclusion that acknowledges both the essay's strengths and the inherent overlap among categories.
Introduction
"Friends, Good Friends, and Such Good Friends" by Judith Viorst is an essay that attempts to redefine the concept of friendship as experienced among women. Viorst's discussion of the topic stems from her earlier assumption that unqualified friendship exists between people — particularly women. She previously believed that "a friend is a friend all the way," a notion that changed over time as social interaction and lived experience taught her that friendships can have varying degrees, characteristics, and levels of intimacy. As her essay illustrates, Viorst categorizes friendships among women into various levels of intimacy, self-disclosure, and relational characteristics.
Overview of Viorst's Eight Friendship Categories
Viorst identifies eight categories that reflect the criteria she uses — level of intimacy, degree of self-disclosure, and the defining characteristics of each friendship or relationship. These categories are: convenience friends, special-interest friends, historical friends, crossroads friends, cross-generational friends, part-of-a-couple friends, men who are friends, and medium/pretty good/very good friends. Together, they form a taxonomy that moves beyond the idea of a single, uniform type of friendship, offering instead a nuanced picture of how women relate to the people in their lives.
Affinity-Based vs. Characteristic-Based Friendships
Viorst's eight categories can be grouped into two broader types based on either (a) the affinity of an individual with a friend, or (b) similarities in characteristics between individuals. Convenience friends, historical friends, cross-generational friends, and part-of-a-couple friends fall under the affinity-based grouping — these are friendships shaped by one's relationship to another person, making the formation of social bonds somewhat inevitable rather than entirely chosen.
Similarities in characteristics, on the other hand, place greater emphasis on the individual's freedom of choice in selecting and establishing relationships. Special-interest friends, crossroads friends, men who are friends, and medium/pretty good/very good friends belong to this second grouping. In these cases, shared interests, values, or life circumstances draw people together by personal choice rather than circumstance.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.