This essay examines the lives and writings of two remarkable medieval English mystics, Julian of Norwich and Margery Kempe, focusing on the central role that pain plays in their visionary experiences of God. Drawing on The Shewings of Julian of Norwich and The Book of Margery Kempe, the paper explores how both women — shaped by their middle-class backgrounds — transcended the patriarchal constraints of medieval society through spiritual devotion. The essay argues that their theologies are simultaneously humanist and feminist, linking personal suffering to divine revelation in ways that parallel Christ's own martyrdom, and that their written testimonies represent a remarkable assertion of female spiritual authority.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
The paper models comparative close reading: it selects specific passages from two primary texts and uses them to support a unifying thesis about pain, revelation, and gender. Rather than summarizing each work in turn, the author weaves evidence from both texts together around thematic claims — a technique central to literary and religious studies essays at the undergraduate level.
The essay opens with an introduction establishing both figures and its central thesis — that pain triggers visionary experience. It then provides social and biographical context, noting how class enabled both women to pursue spiritual lives. Subsequent paragraphs develop the pain-as-revelation theme with textual evidence, before moving to their shared theology of sin and forgiveness. The essay then addresses childbirth and patriarchy as specifically female dimensions of suffering. A brief conclusion ties the women's experiences back to the story of Christ, completing the thematic arc.
Both Margery Kempe and her mentor Julian of Norwich illuminate the roles that women have played in Christian history. Although the Roman Catholic Church has officially canonized neither of them, the Anglican Church recognizes and honors both. Margery Kempe and Julian of Norwich both wrote extensively, and their writings have survived as testimony to the hardships women endured given their low social status, and to how religion helped women attain personal power and peace. Moreover, their writings reveal a mature theology that can be considered both humanist and feminist.
Margery Kempe and Julian of Norwich also share the experience of hallucinations related to near-death episodes. These experiences linked the two women and anchored them to Christ. Kempe eventually came to visit Julian of Norwich, and the two shared a visionary love of God that permeates their writing. A common theme in their work is that pain can trigger visionary experiences of God, and that those visionary experiences bring one closer to the truth and to the divine.
Both Julian of Norwich and Margery Kempe led extraordinary lives for medieval English women, in part because they both came from middle-class rather than poor families. Class plays a significant role in how these two women perceived and responded to their spiritual experiences. It is likely that a poor woman experiencing spiritual visions precipitated by pain would not have had the opportunity to express herself in writing.
In The Book of Margery Kempe, the author writes her autobiography in the third person, referring to herself as "she." This technique creates more of a narrative distance and draws the reader into her story. Among Kempe's primary motifs are childbearing and motherhood, which she endured fourteen times before vowing to leave behind the mundane life of a medieval wife. Kempe claims that her husband loved her, but that she felt a spiritual calling precipitated by great physical and psychological pain. She declares herself forever a servant of Christ and lives her life honestly devoted to spiritual practice.
Before embarking on her ambitious religious pilgrimages, Margery Kempe engaged in entrepreneurial activities, which reveal how women negotiated power within their personal lives at a time when they were systematically denied access to social, economic, and political power. Brewing was an activity open to women in medieval England, which is one reason Kempe became a brewer. She claims her beer was known to be excellent, but that a setback with the yeast culture led to low worker morale. The business ultimately failed, and Margery blamed herself and her own sins.
The psychological pain from this failure caused Kempe to devote herself more deeply to spiritual practice. Likewise, Julian of Norwich drove herself toward deep spiritual revelations after tiring of the dissatisfactions of daily life. It is impossible to say whether patriarchal social structures were a definitive or conscious cause of these two women withdrawing from their respective social circles to be closer to God. It is, however, reasonable to assume that their relatively privileged backgrounds did facilitate their transition from mundane to purely spiritual life. Both women had the opportunity to choose their destinies in ways that poor women were most likely prohibited from doing, whether due to economic necessity, social constraint, or both.
Kempe's entrepreneurial activities demonstrate that her financial position was strong enough to allow her to pursue activities independent of her husband, and her later worldly travels further confirm that she viewed herself as a strong, empowered woman capable of fending for herself. Julian of Norwich's life is more shrouded in mystery than Kempe's, because unlike her counterpart, Julian did not pen a fully autobiographical text. Her Shewings of Julian of Norwich details her spiritual visions without providing much personal information.
Pain is a cornerstone of both Julian of Norwich's and Margery Kempe's visionary experiences. The type of pain they describe is mystical in nature, leading to a profound connection with God. A curious blending of pleasure and pain permeates their writings. Julian of Norwich describes the "paynes of Christ and His cruelle dying" (lines 17–18). She also refers to revelations received through Christ suggesting that the greatest pain of all is to see "thy love suffir" (lines 661–662).
Julian of Norwich and Margery Kempe both relate to Christ as the archetypal martyr, in part because women's role in medieval society was itself martyr-like. For example, when her brewing business fails, Margery Kempe blames herself and chastises herself for her sins, even though the failure was not her fault. The role of women in medieval society was subordinate, which is precisely why the stories of Kempe and Julian of Norwich are so remarkable. The pain they felt as part of a subordinate caste of human beings was commensurate with the pain that Christ felt on the cross — this is the central implication of their spiritual legacy.
Pain plays a major role in the visionary experience, often triggering intense revelations of the kind that Julian of Norwich and Margery Kempe detail in their writings. Julian of Norwich's The Shewings of Julian of Norwich conveys the intensity of her visions, which are ecstatic in nature. Her love of God is translated into a love of humanity, offering an uplifting message that pain can and will be transcended through spiritual experience. Margery Kempe's The Book of Margery Kempe is more autobiographical in style but equally illustrates the close connection between pain and spiritual revelation. Because the story of Christ is itself a story of pain and suffering, the lives of these two women closely resemble the life of Christ.
You’re 74% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.