Aesthetic Life in Kierkegaard's Either/Or: Desire and Fulfillment
This paper examines Kierkegaard's aesthetic life view as presented in Either/Or, analyzing its norms, limitations, and relationship to the ethical and religious life views. Drawing on Aristotle's concept of "right desire," the paper traces how the pseudonymous author A constructs an aesthetics of pleasure centered on moderation and imagination, using the figure of Don Giovanni as a cautionary example of aesthetic excess. The paper argues that the aesthetic life, taken alone, is insufficient to fulfill human existential meaning — it requires the boundaries of ethics and, ultimately, the transcendent object of religious love to provide genuine happiness. Kierkegaard's implicit turn toward the religious life view is identified as the necessary resolution to the either/or dilemma.
- Introduction: Right Desire and the Aesthetic Framework: Aristotle, Plato, and Kierkegaard's framing of desire
- The Norms and Limitations of the Aesthetic Life: Don Giovanni illustrates aesthetic excess and failure
- The Alternative: Ethics, Religion, and the Art of Forgetting: Pain, forgetting, love, and the religious answer
- Finding the 'Right Desire': Prayer, religion, and transcendent aesthetic fulfillment
- Conclusion: Infinite desire requires an infinite object for fulfillment
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper sustains a single, clearly stated thesis throughout — that the aesthetic life cannot fulfill itself without ethical and religious support — and returns to it consistently in each section.
- It uses Don Giovanni as a concrete, recurring literary example to ground abstract philosophical claims about desire, moderation, and self-destruction, making the argument accessible and vivid.
- The integration of multiple thinkers — Aristotle, Plato, Kierkegaard, Dante, and Schiller — demonstrates broad philosophical awareness without losing focus on the central text.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper employs close reading of primary source quotations to build its argument incrementally. Rather than simply summarizing Kierkegaard's positions, it unpacks specific passages — on forgetting, love, prayer, and desire — and interprets them within a coherent philosophical framework. This technique of embedding direct citations and then immediately analyzing their implications is a strong model for philosophical essay writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a theoretical frame drawn from Aristotle and Plato before introducing Kierkegaard's Either/Or. The second section analyzes the aesthetic life's norms and uses Don Giovanni to show their limits. The third section introduces the alternative — the religious dimension — through discussions of suffering, forgetting, and love. The fourth section brings all threads together around the concept of "right desire" and the institutional religious life. The conclusion restates the thesis concisely, tying finite and infinite desire to their appropriate objects.
Introduction: Right Desire and the Aesthetic Framework
The crux of the aesthetic life — as well as the ethical life — depends upon the definition of norms and, as Aristotle implied, the cultivation of "right desire." This sense of "right desire" underlies the norm — whether constitutive, prescriptive, imperative, or otherwise — and establishes a kind of philosophical goal toward which mankind may strive. By sifting through one's numerous and sometimes contradictory desires for the "right desire," one is compelled to rely upon intellect and reason to discern an object or end — the philosophical goal that, like the light from on high in Plato's Allegory of the Cave, compels the philosopher to climb upward. In Kierkegaard's Either/Or, this light is examined from a number of perspectives, each making an assertion concerning "right desire," yet each offering differing opinions on what exactly that desire should be — whether aesthetic (as the pseudonymous A argues) or ethical (as the pseudonymous Judge argues), imaginary or practical. Within this framework, Kierkegaard explores life through lived experience and the meaning of life through the use of reason.
This paper explains the meaning and aim of life from within Kierkegaard's aesthetic life view and shows what it is to live the good or happy life according to its prescribed norms. It also examines whether, on its own terms, such a life view has the resources to realize its existential meaning and aim. The central claim is that it does not — that the aesthetic life relies upon the ethical life view to maintain any kind of equilibrium, to keep oneself from becoming like Mozart's Don Giovanni. In other words, the aesthetic view needs "right desire" — as Aristotle stated — but cannot fulfill it on its own, unless that desire comes from God Himself, as Kierkegaard implies, hinting at man's ultimate religious nature and purpose.
Reference List
Kierkegaard, S. (1987). Either/Or. Princeton University Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.