Marriage Expectations in Lahiri's "A Temporary Matter"
This essay analyzes Jhumpa Lahiri's short story "A Temporary Matter" through the lens of the nightly game Shoba and Shukumar play during a power outage. By examining the passages surrounding the game, the paper argues that each spouse approaches the activity with fundamentally different intentions: Shoba uses it as a vehicle to gradually disclose her plan to leave, while Shukumar sees it as a chance to rebuild emotional intimacy. The essay further contends that these divergent expectations reflect deeper personality differences—Shukumar's emotional, creative nature versus Shoba's reserved, calculating disposition—that ultimately make the marriage unsalvageable.
- Introduction: The Game as a Lens on a Failing Marriage: Nightly game exposes the couple's marital troubles
- Shoba's Motive: Using the Game to Exit the Marriage: Shoba uses the game to announce her departure
- Shukumar's Motive: Seeking Closeness Through the Game: Shukumar hopes the game will rebuild intimacy
- Deeper Personality Differences Between the Couple: Contrasting personalities drive incompatible expectations
- Conclusion: Incompatible Expectations and a Sundered Marriage: Divergent expectations make the marriage unsalvageable
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay uses a single recurring motif—the nightly game—as the analytical thread that ties all its claims together, keeping the argument focused throughout.
- Each body paragraph integrates a direct textual quotation and then provides specific interpretation, demonstrating evidence-based literary analysis rather than mere plot summary.
- The contrast structure (Shoba's motives versus Shukumar's motives) is clearly established early and consistently maintained, making the comparative argument easy to follow.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper exemplifies close reading: it selects brief but revealing passages and unpacks their implications layer by layer, connecting surface-level action (playing a game in the dark) to deeper thematic claims about personality, expectation, and marital failure. This technique shows how a focused textual moment can carry an entire interpretive argument.
Structure breakdown
The essay follows a classic five-paragraph structure: an introduction that presents the central claim, two body paragraphs that contrast the two characters' motivations through quotation and analysis, a third body paragraph that traces those motivations to underlying personality differences, and a conclusion that synthesizes all three points into a unified thesis about incompatible expectations.
Introduction: The Game as a Lens on a Failing Marriage
The focal point of Jhumpa Lahiri's short story "A Temporary Matter" is a game that a married couple plays each night during a period when their home has no electricity. The object of the game is to tell one another something that each had not previously known. To the reader, the game appears to be a diversion — a way to keep the couple, which is experiencing significant marital difficulties, from having to endure awkward silences. However, during the course of this game, the pair uncovers many of the intricacies that can complicate, and perhaps even end, a marriage. A closer look at the game and the facts revealed by each character — Shoba and Shukumar — indicates that the two held fundamentally different expectations of one another, which ultimately results in their marriage coming apart.
Shoba's Motive: Using the Game to Exit the Marriage
It is quite clear from a thorough examination of the text that Shoba's motive in playing this game with her husband is to separate from him. She is the one who suggests the game in the first place. Moreover, on the final night they are together, she tells him that she has found an apartment and is moving out. Her participation in the game is therefore her way of slowly revealing things he did not know — including, ultimately, the fact that she is leaving him. The following passage, in which Shukumar reacts to this disclosure, confirms her intention:
"It sickened Shukumar, knowing that she had spent these past evenings preparing for a life without him. He was relieved and yet he was sickened. This was what she had been trying to tell him for the past four evenings. This was the point of her game" (Lahiri).
This passage reveals that Shoba's aim was to gradually introduce the painful information that she was abandoning their marriage. Yet the very method she chose — a seemingly innocuous game rather than a direct conversation or an honest attempt to resolve their differences — demonstrates that her perception and expectations of the marriage were profoundly different from her husband's.
Shukumar's Motive: Seeking Closeness Through the Game
Shukumar, for his part, participates in the game simply because his wife asked him to. Once he begins, however, his intentions diverge sharply from hers. Whereas Shoba is using the game to ease her way out of the marriage, Shukumar sees it as an opportunity to achieve the opposite: to grow closer to his wife and to bridge the emotional distance between them. Although he is initially relieved merely to have something to say to her, he gradually comes to treasure the intimacy — both physical and emotional — that the candlelit evenings produce. The following passage, in which the couple engages in passionate sex after one of their nightly exchanges, supports this reading:
"As he made love to her he wondered what he would say to her the next night, and what she would say, the thought of it exciting him" (Lahiri).
The game has had a profound effect on Shukumar. It has drawn him emotionally and physically closer to his wife. Part of this response stems from his ignorance of her true intentions, but it also reflects his different conception of the marriage itself. Despite their problems, Shukumar is unwilling to abandon the commitment he made to Shoba. This fundamental difference in outlook — his desire to stay versus her plan to leave — demonstrates just how far apart the two spouses truly are in their expectations of the relationship.
Conclusion: Incompatible Expectations and a Sundered Marriage
In summary, an analysis of the passages surrounding the game that Shukumar and Shoba play in Lahiri's tale reveals that they are two very different people with incompatible expectations about their marriage. Shoba's expectation for the game was to gradually prepare her husband for the news that she was leaving him. Shukumar's expectation was to narrow the emotional divide between them and renew their bond. These divergent expectations are, in turn, expressions of deeper differences in personality and outlook. With contrasts this pronounced, it would be difficult for any two people to sustain a marriage.
Works Cited
Lahiri, Jhumpa. "A Temporary Matter." The New Yorker, 1999.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.