The Manager's Basic Responsibility: Beyond Focusing People
This paper critically evaluates the claim that a manager's most basic responsibility is to focus people toward the performance of work activities in order to achieve desired outcomes. Drawing on Daft's four functions of management, Mintzberg's managerial roles, and Luthans's observational study, the paper argues that directing employees represents only one component of a much broader managerial role. It further contends that other organizational resources — particularly financial, technological, and physical — may demand equal or greater managerial attention. The paper also demonstrates that no single responsibility applies universally to all managers, and concludes that an excessive focus on directing and controlling employees can paradoxically reduce managerial effectiveness.
- Introduction: Questions whether directing people is the core managerial duty
- Management Functions and the Scope of Managerial Roles: Reviews Daft, Mintzberg, and Luthans on managerial roles
- The Importance of Non-Human Resources: Argues financial and other resources may outrank human resources
- Variation in Managerial Responsibilities Across Roles: Shows managerial priorities differ by organisation and position
- The Risk of Over-Focusing on Employee Direction: Over-managing employees can reduce overall managerial effectiveness
- Conclusion: Synthesises why no single responsibility defines all managers
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper systematically addresses its central claim from multiple angles — definitional, comparative, contextual, and practical — giving the argument a well-rounded structure.
- It uses concrete illustrative examples (e.g., the CEO financial mismanagement scenario, the technology development organisation) to ground abstract theoretical points in recognizable situations.
- It draws on multiple credible, well-known scholarly sources (Daft, Mintzberg, Luthans, Bruch & Ghoshal, Furedi) and triangulates their findings rather than relying on a single authority.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective counter-argument development: it begins by acknowledging a degree of truth in the claim under scrutiny before systematically dismantling it through evidence and reasoning. This concessive structure — "this is partly true, but..." — is a hallmark of strong analytical writing and shows intellectual honesty rather than simple refutation.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction that frames the debate and signals the paper's position. It then moves through four argumentative sections: (1) establishing that the claim describes only one of several managerial functions; (2) arguing that non-human resources may be equally or more critical; (3) showing that managerial priorities vary by role and organisation type; and (4) presenting the counterintuitive risk that over-emphasising employee focus can undermine effectiveness. A brief conclusion synthesises all four strands.
Introduction
It has been said that the manager's most basic responsibility is to focus people toward performance of work activities to achieve desired outcomes. Is this a true statement? Certainly, it describes part of the manager's role, and that part is a significant one. However, focusing people toward the performance of work activities is only one component of the manager's role and may not be the most crucial. A manager may have other responsibilities that are more basic and more essential. At the same time, this narrow description of the manager's role may actually undermine the manager's ability to perform their job effectively. These issues are considered in turn below.
References
Bruch, H & Ghoshal, S 2002, 'Beware the busy manager', Harvard Business Review, vol. 80, no. 2, pp. 62–69.
Daft, R 1997, Management, The Dryden Press, Sydney.
Furedi, F 2005, 'Treat employees like adults', Harvard Business Review, vol. 83, no. 5, pp. 22–23.
Luthans, F 1988, 'Successful vs. effective real managers', Academy of Management Executive, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 127–132.
Mintzberg, N 1975, 'The manager's job: Folklore and fact', Harvard Business Review, vol. 53, no. 4, pp. 49–61.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.