Margaret Fuller's Feminist Arguments for Women's Rights
This paper examines the life and feminist thought of Margaret Fuller, a nineteenth-century intellectual and writer whose advocacy helped shape the early American women's rights movement. Drawing on her landmark book Woman in the Nineteenth Century, her popular "Conversations" lecture series, and her journalistic work, the paper outlines Fuller's central arguments: that women deserved recognition as independent citizens, that revolution meant freedom for both the laboring class and women, and that intellectual development — free from rigid gender roles — was essential for social progress. The paper also traces Fuller's early education, religious views, and the lasting influence of her ideas on organized feminism.
- Early Life and Intellectual Formation: Fuller's upbringing, education, and intellectual pressures
- Fuller's Arguments for Women's Equal Status: Key feminist claims in Woman in the Nineteenth Century
- The 'Conversations' Lecture Series and Organized Feminism: Fuller's Boston lectures and their impact on feminism
- Gender Roles, Education, and Basic Rights: Fuller's rejection of gender stereotypes and property rights
- Conclusion: Fuller's vision of mutual human development
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper draws on multiple source types — a primary text, a major newspaper essay, a denominational biography, and a Gale literary database entry — giving its claims a well-rounded evidentiary base.
- It moves logically from biographical context to Fuller's specific arguments, allowing readers to understand how her upbringing shaped her advocacy.
- Frequent direct quotation from Fuller's own writing grounds abstract claims about her feminist philosophy in her actual language.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of synthesis across secondary sources: rather than summarizing each source separately, the writer layers them to reinforce a single argument about Fuller's feminist contributions. For example, the Gale biography and the UUA entry both affirm Woman in the Nineteenth Century as a landmark text, and the paper uses that convergence to strengthen its claim rather than repeating the same point twice.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a biographical introduction establishing Fuller's intellectual origins, then moves into a sustained thematic section on her major feminist arguments — equal citizenship, revolutionary freedom, and intellectual development for women. A focused passage addresses gender stereotypes, property rights, and suffrage before the conclusion restates Fuller's core belief in mutual human development. The structure is argument-driven rather than chronological, which suits the paper's analytical purpose.
Early Life and Intellectual Formation
Margaret Fuller was born in Boston and pushed hard from a young age by a father who, when she was just four years old, recognized her high level of intelligence and sought to instill in her a thirst for knowledge. Her father, Timothy Fuller, a Unitarian rationalist, treated her "not as a plaything, but as a living mind," she explained (Gornick, 2012, p. 2). While it is true that she later wrote at length about how much she appreciated being encouraged by her intellectually demanding father to study literature and philosophy and to learn languages even before her teens, she reportedly suffered "lifelong migraines, permanent insomnia and impaired eyesight" as a result of the intensity of the pedagogic pressure he placed on her (Gornick, p. 2).
She also carried a constant worry that "her intellectual output was insufficient" (Gornick, p. 2). This was deeply ironic, because she was such an intellectual powerhouse and so inclined to voice her formidable opinions that some of America's greatest literary figures — Nathaniel Hawthorne, for example — could barely stand to be in the same room with her.
Fuller's Arguments for Women's Equal Status
In her book Woman in the Nineteenth Century, Fuller contributed to the emerging feminist movement by arguing that "a good world could only be achieved" when women were fully recognized "as citizens in their own right" (Gornick, p. 3). Fairness in the world, Fuller asserted, could only come through the "intellectual and spiritual elevation of each and every human being," and this achievement for women could only be manifested through "a wealth of literary, philosophical and historical references" (Gornick, p. 3). Horace Greeley, publisher of the New York Tribune, responded to her book by calling it:
"The loftiest and most commanding assertion yet made of the right of Woman to be regarded and treated as an independent, rational being entitled to an equal voice in framing and modifying the laws she is required to obey" (Gornick, pp. 3–4).
A biography of Fuller published by the Unitarian Universalist Association reports that Woman in the Nineteenth Century was "her major gift to the times," a "manifesto for the women's rights movement" (UUA, 2002, p. 4). In the book, Fuller depicted the "oppression of the female sex through history and advocated equal status for women" (UUA, p. 4). Fuller, who was raised a Unitarian, attended the Unitarian church headed by antislavery activist Rev. Edward B. Hall, and in 1842 she adapted her Christian faith to "her own needs" (UUA, p. 4). She justified her faith by writing that Christianity should include "the deep consciousness of a Moses with the holy love and purity of Jesus," while adding that the "blue sky" preached to her "better than any brother" (UUA, p. 4).
While in Italy in 1848, Fuller — who was sending essays back to New York for Greeley's publication — became "an ardent supporter" of the Italian revolution. She advocated that "revolution meant freedom and human rights for the laboring class and for women" (UUA, p. 5). This constitutes the second major argument examined in this paper.
Conclusion
On myriad occasions — through many columns, letters, and books — Fuller insisted that the "development of one [male] cannot be effected without that of the other [woman]" (Fuller, p. 1). Moreover, her "highest wish" was that the truth of fairness between the genders "should be distinctly and rationally apprehended" (Fuller, p. 1). These convictions, expressed across a remarkable body of work, established Fuller as one of the most important and far-sighted voices of the early American feminist movement.
Works Cited
Fuller, Margaret. Woman in the 19th Century. North Chelmsford, MA: Courier Dover Publications, 1999.
Gale Biography in Context. "(Sarah) Margaret Fuller / Feminist Writers." Retrieved November 29, 2012, from http://0-ic.galegroup.com. 1996.
Gornick, Vivian. "A Double Inheritance: On Margaret Fuller." The Nation. Retrieved November 29, 2012, from http://www.thenation.com. 2012.
Unitarian Universalist Association. "Margaret Fuller." Retrieved November 29, 2012, from 2002.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.