Missionary Conquest: Critical Analysis of Cultural Genocide
This paper offers a critical analysis of George Tinker's Missionary Conquest: The Gospel and Native American Cultural Genocide, examining his central thesis that Christian missionaries were active partners in the cultural genocide of Native American peoples. The paper evaluates Tinker's methodology — including his use of the missionaries' own writings to support his argument — while also identifying two significant weaknesses: the tension created by Tinker's own identity as a Christian pastor, and the broader problem of reconstructive criticism, namely the difficulty of judging historical actors by contemporary moral standards. The four missionaries Tinker profiles — John Eliot, Junipero Serra, Pierre-Jean De Smet, and Henry Benjamin Whipple — are examined in turn, with attention to how Tinker's analysis both succeeds and falls short.
- Introduction: Religion in the Service of Evil: Overview of Tinker's argument and reviewer's two objections
- Tinker's Thesis and Methodology: Genocide claim, four missionaries, and supporting evidence
- John Eliot and the Praying Towns: Eliot's civilize-before-convert doctrine and cultural destruction
- Serra, De Smet, and the Civilizing Mission: Spanish and Western missionaries imposing Euro-American culture
- Whipple and the Problem of Intention: Whipple's Anglo arrogance and Tinker's logical inconsistency
- Reconstructive Criticism and Its Limits: Judging historical actors by present-day moral standards
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper engages critically rather than merely summarizing — it identifies specific logical contradictions in Tinker's argument, such as his repeated acknowledgment of missionaries' "good intentions" while simultaneously condemning them as genocidal partners.
- It uses a consistent analytical lens throughout: the tension between Tinker's Christian identity and his critique of missionary Christianity, applied to each of the four missionaries in sequence.
- The conclusion raises a genuinely interesting meta-point — that Tinker's own position as a Native American Christian pastor may be itself a product of the missionary legacy he critiques, lending the paper a reflective and nuanced ending.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates critical book review methodology at a strong undergraduate level. Rather than accepting the author's framework uncritically, the writer isolates two structural weaknesses — authorial positionality and the limits of anachronistic moral judgment — and tests them against each chapter's evidence. This technique, sometimes called immanent critique, holds an argument to its own stated standards.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a framing introduction that previews both Tinker's thesis and the reviewer's two main objections. It then works chapter by chapter through the four missionaries Tinker profiles, applying the same critical questions to each. The conclusion synthesizes the reviewer's assessment: Tinker largely succeeds in his historical goal but is hampered by unresolved tensions in his own position. References consist of a single primary source (Tinker, 1993), appropriate for a focused book review.
Introduction: Religion in the Service of Evil
It is often said that there is nothing so dangerous as a convert or a missionary. Although many take this idea as a kind of tongue-in-cheek characterization of the excesses of those "blinded by faith," there remains a sinister truth in the statement. George Tinker's book, Missionary Conquest: The Gospel and Native American Cultural Genocide, clearly illustrates the dark side of missionary work and the damage that can, and has been, done to Native American cultures and peoples as a result of the inherent coupling of colonialism, ethnocentrism, and religion — what Tinker calls "religion in the service of evil."
However, although Tinker does a remarkable job of pointing out the unfortunate Anglo-centrism of the missionaries he discusses, as well as the horrible price Native Americans would pay as a result of their efforts, he does not acknowledge the difficulty his own position as a Christian pastor creates for the effectiveness of his argument. Nor does he reconcile the reader's doubt concerning the common problem with reconstructive thinking — namely, can one use the values of today to judge the values of history?
Bibliography
Tinker, George. Missionary Conquest. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1993.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.