This paper reviews a 1997 article from the Journal of Popular Film & Television that examines the "mountain man" archetype across American popular media from the early 1970s to the mid-1990s. The review summarizes the author's central argument that the mountain man figure embodies contradictory roles — hero, villain, pariah, and scapegoat — within the American cultural psyche. Drawing on Carl Jung's concept of the "shadow," the article connects mountain man representations in film, television, and other media to the Vietnam War, masculinity in crisis, and fears of government and women. The review evaluates the article's strengths and weaknesses, noting both its broad knowledge of American media and its definitional inconsistencies and thematic gaps.
This paper demonstrates the technique of definition-based critique: it identifies the author's stated definition of the "mountain man" as a fur trapper of the nineteenth-century trans-Mississippi West and then systematically tests whether the article's own examples meet that definition. This approach yields a focused and evidence-supported weakness argument, showing how a narrow or inconsistently applied definition can undermine an otherwise broad and ambitious thesis.
The paper opens with a concise summary of the article's thesis and supporting evidence, including its theoretical framework (Jungian shadow theory) and cultural scope (60 films, 20 documentaries, and more). It then identifies two key strengths — illustrative examples and media breadth — before presenting three distinct weaknesses: definitional inconsistency, incomplete thematic follow-through, and the author's tendency to digress from media analysis into historical commentary. The conclusion synthesizes the critique succinctly.
The article "Mountain Man and American Anguish," published in the Journal of Popular Film & Television (Winter 1997), examines how the "mountain man" figure in American popular culture media represents several conflicting aspects of what the author calls "the extreme West" in the American psyche — including the roles of hero, villain, pariah, and scapegoat. To support this argument, the author references a remarkably wide range of popular cultural representations, including 60 films, 20 documentaries, filmstrips, beer commercials, radio programs, music, paintings, drawings, sculptures, and books.
The author also draws on Carl Jung's theory of the "shadow" — described as "the thing a person has no wish to be" — as a theoretical framework for understanding the mountain man as a pariah onto whom Americans project their darker characteristics. Although the author briefly addresses the mountain man as pariah and savior in 1950s television, the article concentrates primarily on representations from the early 1970s to the mid-1990s.
The author defines the mountain man as "the fur trapper and/or trader of the United States of America's nineteenth-century trans-Mississippi West." Within American popular media, this figure is portrayed in a range of contradictory ways — as frontier hero, dangerous outcast, romantic adventurer, and social scapegoat. The article traces how these shifting portrayals reflect broader tensions in American cultural identity, particularly around themes of individualism, freedom, and violence.
To illustrate these representations, the author discusses mountain men depicted in numerous television shows, miniseries, and films, including The Oregon Trail, The Life and Times of Grizzly Adams, The Macahans, How the West Was Won, Centennial, Hagan, Dream West, Manhunt for Claude Dallas, The Abduction of Kari Swenson, Gunsmoke: Return to Dodge, Cry in the Wild: The Taking of Peggy Ann, Blood River, Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman, and Buffalo Girls.
A central theoretical pillar of the article is Jung's concept of the shadow — the repressed, undesirable aspects of the self that are projected outward onto others. The author applies this framework to argue that the mountain man functions as a cultural shadow figure in American media: a repository for qualities that mainstream American society wishes to disown, including violence, lawlessness, and social deviance. In this reading, the mountain man is not merely a historical figure but a psychological archetype through which collective anxieties are expressed and managed.
This Jungian lens gives the article its most distinctive analytical contribution, framing popular media representations as symptoms of deeper cultural and psychological conflicts rather than simple entertainment products.
According to the author, the renewed prominence of the mountain man figure in American media during the early 1970s emerged largely in response to the Vietnam War and the social upheaval of that era. The mountain man became a vehicle for exploring additional themes, including: the Vietnam combat soldier; the repression of the war's psychological effects; men as victims of war, government, and women; fear and hatred of women; and the loss of individual liberties.
These themes, the author argues, mapped onto the mountain man archetype in ways that resonated with audiences grappling with national trauma, disillusionment with government authority, and shifting gender dynamics in the post-Vietnam decades through the mid-1990s.
You’re 53% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.