This paper takes the form of a formal letter addressed to the Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario (RNAO), arguing that the province's nursing shortage poses a serious threat to both patient health and nurse well-being. The letter reviews evidence of unsustainable nurse-to-patient ratios, excessive overtime costs, and the ongoing exodus of Ontario-trained nurses to the United States. It evaluates the limited success of prior government interventions and proposes a comprehensive retention strategy, including guaranteed employment for new graduates, sign-on bonuses, and expanded education funding, to prevent the crisis from deepening further.
October 13, 2012
To the Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario (RNAO):
The nursing shortage in Ontario has the potential to have a catastrophic impact on both the health of patients and the health of nurses. Nurses as a whole are committed to providing excellent care and upholding the standards of their profession. However, when they are operating in facilities that are chronically understaffed, achieving this goal can seem impossible. Nurses are forced to oversee unsustainably high patient loads and to work long hours, effectively doing the work of two people in one body. Despite this reality, almost 90 per cent (89%) of patients in Ontario rated their nursing care as excellent or good — a figure that reflects the high personal cost nurses pay to deliver that care (MacKinnon 2001).
As nurses retire and age out of the profession without being replaced by new recruits, the shortage will grow even more critical. While nursing shortages are common in the United States as well, Canada faces a particular challenge. Health experts warn that Canada could face a repeat of the 1990s, when health-care cuts by the provinces drove as many as 27,000 nurses to the United States alone to look for work (Spencer 2010). The United States has proven particularly attractive because of the incentives offered to nurses, such as sign-on bonuses and subsidized higher education (Spencer 2010).
Ontario has the second-worst nurse-to-patient ratios in Canada and spends close to $134 million a year on overtime hours, along with approximately $50.5 million in directly related sick time (MacKinnon 2001). This creates a vicious cycle: the more nurses are forced to overwork and care for more patients than they can reasonably manage, the more nurses decide to leave the profession. Even though Ontario patients have praised nursing care overall, there have still been patient complaints about understaffing, which can lead to more frequent hospital readmissions because patients are not appropriately monitored. Almost one-third of patients reported that their call buttons were not answered promptly (MacKinnon 2001). Patient satisfaction with nurses' efforts should not make nursing organizations complacent about the ongoing shortage.
"Funding initiatives fall short of solving retention"
"Bonuses, job guarantees, and education funding proposed"
I am a nursing student who hopes to remain in Ontario. However, in the face of better job offers elsewhere, I may have no choice but to leave. Unless systematic action is taken to invest in the future of the nursing profession, Ontario will continue to struggle to provide high-quality patient care, and conditions for nurses will continue to worsen. The time for incremental measures has passed; what is needed now is a coordinated, province-wide commitment to recruiting and retaining the nurses that Ontario — and its patients — depend on.
You’re 54% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.