This paper examines Frank Pacetta's book Don't Fire Them, Fire Them Up, which chronicles the turnaround of a struggling Xerox sales office in Cleveland, Ohio during the 1990s. The paper identifies key leadership principles Pacetta employs — including building trust, fostering loyalty, generating enthusiasm, and promoting mentorship — and evaluates their applicability in both military and non-military organizational settings. It also compares Pacetta's management style with leadership practices observed in the author's own workplace, highlighting the value of recognition, teambuilding, and a winning culture.
The paper demonstrates applied literary analysis of a nonfiction management text, moving beyond summary to evaluate how Pacetta's principles function across different contexts — military, corporate, and personal. This technique of cross-contextual application is a hallmark of strong analytical writing at the undergraduate level.
The paper opens with an overview of the book and its setting, then surveys the leadership principles Pacetta advocates. It transitions to a focused analysis of the book's military language and tone, examines how those ideas transfer to civilian organizations, and concludes with a first-person reflection comparing Pacetta's methods to the author's own workplace. A brief concluding recommendation closes the paper.
Frank Pacetta's Don't Fire Them, Fire Them Up is a glimpse into the successful turnaround of a struggling Xerox sales office in Cleveland, Ohio during the 1990s. The author employs several fundamental principles of management and leadership, along with his own unique contributions, to "fire up" his employees and build a successful organization. The ideas themselves are familiar, but the way Pacetta implements them is not.
The book reads somewhat like a sports team's pre-game motivational speech and partly like a military field manual. Pacetta uses this voice effectively to appeal to a wide audience of managers — particularly those who relate to competitive, results-driven messaging drawn from familiar contexts at home and in the workplace. He also provides bulleted checklists and concise chapter summaries at the back of the book, making the advice accessible to readers who need quick, practical guidance. As readers move through the book, they develop a deeper understanding of Pacetta's methods, why they worked, and how to apply them to their own business or personal situations.
The leadership principles Pacetta uses throughout the book are ones that most leaders encounter over the course of their careers. He introduces several of them in the book's Introduction, including building trust, creating loyalty, and generating enthusiasm, excitement, and teamwork (Pacetta 14). Beyond these, he offers a host of additional ideas that blend together to portray a dynamic leader who genuinely enjoys leading — one who embraces both the highs and the lows of the role.
Pacetta is not afraid to share his failures in Cleveland alongside his successes, because he believes that taking risks is an essential component of good management. He is also a strong advocate for mentorship, arguing that few people can rise to the top without guidance from others. He writes, "Mentors are absolutely essential. Find one. Find a dozen. Use them as role models and sounding boards. No matter how talented you are, it is essential to have backup, support, and a second opinion" (Pacetta 42). His willingness to seek help and advice is itself a leadership lesson: good leaders are not too proud to ask for input.
Leadership, in Pacetta's view, is ultimately about winning — but winning through common sense. He emphasizes that leaders must enjoy the challenge, and that this enjoyment is contagious within an organization.
One of the most distinctive features of Pacetta's writing is his consistent use of military language and analogies. He calls his team "troops," refers to managers as "commanders," quotes General George Patton, and frames the overarching goal of business and sales as winning a campaign. One representative passage captures this military theme clearly: "The same competent combat commander, the one who is willing to beat a strategic retreat, knows he'll soon have his back to the wall if he can't demand and enforce a minimum level of performance, like keeping weapons clean to avoid misfires" (Pacetta 30).
This military-style leadership framework makes the book directly applicable to military contexts, as it speaks to military leaders and their teams in language they recognize. The parallels are not merely rhetorical — Pacetta's emphasis on discipline, clear objectives, unit cohesion, and performance standards mirrors the organizational values that military institutions formally codify.
Pacetta's ideas are equally applicable in non-military settings, appealing to the universal human desire for teamwork and shared purpose. The framework also resonates strongly with anyone who has served in the military and carried those organizational instincts into civilian professional life.
Pacetta, Frank, with Roger Gittines. Don't Fire Them, Fire Them Up. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1994.
You’re 56% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.