This paper examines the rise and fall of the Roman Empire through the lens of surplus extraction and elite exploitation. Beginning with Rome's legendary founding and its early organization around tribal clans and Etruscan influence, the paper traces Rome's expansion into the Mediterranean world's dominant power. It then analyzes the multiple factors contributing to Rome's decline, including military overspending, economic inequality, political corruption, unclear succession rules, and the disruptive influence of religious conflict. Drawing on historians Harold Perkin and Edward Gibbon, the paper argues that greed and exploitation by the ruling elite ultimately blinded Rome's leaders to the needs of their citizens and the dangers posed by external enemies.
According to historians, the key to the establishment, survival, and fall of historical societies is their use of resources and surplus income (Perkin 2002). Except for the most primitive, no society "would be able to afford the protection, law and order, administration, defense, spiritual advice, personal services, cultural production" and other essentials without "the extraction, by the elite, of products surplus to immediate requirements, such as food, arms, luxuries and other goods and services produced by farmers" (Perkin 2002). Moreover, before conquerors such as the Romans were able to take over a society, it had to already be organized; and to make it worth the effort of the conquerors, the society also had to have reached a sufficient level of material production (Perkin 2002).
The fall of early empires was due to the fact that elites were greedy and took more than their share of income and resources, resulting in internal malaise, depression, rebellion, and possible conquest by external forces (Perkin 2002). In an article from History Today, Harold Perkin explains that "surplus extraction, without which civilization and decent human life are impossible, can too easily slip into exploitation and so lead to self-destruction" (Perkin 2002). This observation certainly applies to the rise and fall of the Roman Empire.
Like the Greeks, the early Romans were awed by fire and believed in Vesta, the goddess of fire. They maintained a sacred temple of fire tended by four women known as the Vestal Virgins. The greatest legend among Romans begins with one of these Vestal Virgins giving birth to twin boys, Romulus and Remus, fathered by the god Mars. Romulus killed Remus and became Rome's first king, populating his city with people gathered from other lands. After a long reign, he vanished into a thunderstorm and became a god, reappearing to declare that Rome would be the capital of the world and that all others would be helpless against Roman arms. This legend dates the founding of Rome at 735 BCE; however, there is evidence that Rome was already a collection of villages as early as 1000 BCE.
Romans were organized around tribal clans. In 600 BCE, Etruscan chieftains conquered Rome, from whom the Romans learned to grow grapes and olives, adopted an alphabet, and acquired military organization. The leading Roman patrician families then took power and ruled as members of the Senate, making Rome a republic. Later, representatives from Greece and other states appealed to the Roman Senate for help in settling local disputes, giving Rome a new role that would eventually lead it to become the world's greatest empire.
By the fourth century A.D., the Roman Empire extended entirely around the basin of the Mediterranean Sea, encompassing modern Turkey, Israel, Egypt, and North Africa. The Empire also included Iberia — today's Spain and Portugal — Gaul (modern France), and the area of modern England, with the northern borders reaching the Rhine and Danube Rivers. The Romans had "brought stability, prosperity, and order to the civilized West," and excellent roads connected the far reaches of the empire with the capital at Rome, greatly improving communications and trade (Dorrington).
Emperors held absolute authority, which worked well under capable rulers but caused great harm under incompetent ones. Furthermore, the rules for succession to the throne were never clearly established, resulting in debilitating civil wars as common citizens grew increasingly dissatisfied with corruption and the unequal distribution of wealth and labor (Dorrington).
As wealthy Romans invested abroad, loaned money at high interest rates, and created slave plantations, Roman financial operations grew larger than those of the Greeks and Near Easterners. Rome was soon spending eighty percent of its budget on its military. Fraud increased as luxury items were imported from the East; yet because slaves performed most of the labor, free men were left poor and unemployed. Family feuds and violence were frequent, there were no medical professionals to speak of, and life expectancy hovered around forty years.
This deepening social inequality — with elites accumulating vast wealth while the general population suffered — reflects precisely the pattern of surplus extraction that historians identify as the engine of imperial collapse. The Roman state's failure to address these internal contradictions would prove fatal as external pressures mounted.
"Political, religious, and military causes of Rome's fall"
"Key emperors and Rome's concluding legacy"
You’re 65% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.