Leadership Profiles of Senior Nurse Executives: A Critical Review
This paper reviews E.A. Hemman's study "Leadership Profiles of Senior Nurse Executives," published in the Canadian Journal of Nursing Leadership (2000). It examines the demographic and educational backgrounds of senior nurse executives in acute care hospitals, the rationale for applying stratified systems theory as a leadership framework, and the practical implications for healthcare management and nursing education. The paper also critiques Hemman's analysis, identifying a notable gap in the discussion of fiduciary responsibilities facing clinically trained nursing executives. The review concludes that Hemman's findings offer a valuable foundation for future leadership development programs, particularly as healthcare systems continue shifting toward clinically experienced administrators.
- Introduction: Leadership Change in Healthcare: Context for shift toward clinically experienced administrators
- Background and Profile of Senior Nurse Executives: Demographics and education of profiled nurse executives
- Stratified Systems Theory as a Leadership Framework: Three-tier leadership framework and research questions
- Healthcare Application of the Research: Applying findings to rural and urban care settings
- Critique of Hemman's Analysis: Gap in addressing fiduciary and financial leadership training
- Conclusions and Implications for Nursing Leadership: Recommendations for future study and nurse executive development
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly separates descriptive summary from critical analysis, first explaining Hemman's findings before identifying a substantive gap — the absence of fiduciary preparation — that adds original analytical value.
- It grounds its critique in the real-world context of healthcare reform, connecting demographic and educational data about nurse executives to broader system pressures, which strengthens the relevance of the argument.
- The conclusion is constructive, recommending how future research could address identified weaknesses rather than simply dismissing the original study.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates the critical book/article review format: summarizing a source's purpose, methodology, and findings, then evaluating its strengths and omissions using domain knowledge. The writer effectively uses direct quotation from the source to anchor claims, then steps back to assess what the research does and does not accomplish.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with the healthcare context driving leadership change, moves into the study's scope and nurse executive demographics, explains the stratified systems theory framework and its research questions, applies findings to real healthcare settings, delivers a focused critique centered on financial training gaps, and closes with a forward-looking recommendation for replicating and extending the study.
Introduction: Leadership Change in Healthcare
In a changing healthcare environment, the need for a corresponding change in leadership is evident. Communities are increasingly becoming aware of the holistic health needs of their citizens and are growing more knowledgeable about what those needs are and how to meet them. For these and other reasons, they have placed a significant burden on the healthcare system to focus more closely on primary care and communication.
To meet the demands of this change, healthcare agencies have moved away from traditional non-practitioner management positions and toward clinically experienced administrators. This paper describes the findings of researcher E.A. Hemman in Leadership Profiles of Senior Nurse Executives, examines the nurses' backgrounds and the study's rationale, considers its healthcare application, and offers a critique of the author's understanding, rationale, and conclusions.
Naturally, the role of the clinically experienced administrator falls heavily on master's-level nursing professionals. According to Hemman and others, it has become increasingly important to profile the individuals who are filling these new roles in order to understand their strengths and potential weaknesses — and, in doing so, to render the system more globally effective in managing holistic care, whether by changing educational curricula or reformulating management procedures through consensus building.
Background and Profile of Senior Nurse Executives
The leadership stratification framework used by Hemman is stratified systems theory, which describes three hierarchical functional domains: strategic, organizational, and production. Each of the three management levels is further analyzed through four general categories: decision making, information giving and seeking, influencing people, and building relationships. These categories generated the following research questions:
The nurses profiled were those occupying the highest-ranking executive position in each healthcare facility studied. As Hemman (2000) defines it: "In this study, a senior nurse executive is the registered nurse occupying the highest executive position in an acute care hospital. He or she is ultimately responsible for nursing activities throughout the organization and, in the organizational chart, these executives are responsible to the hospital administrator or chief executive officer as part of the executive-level, decision-making management team."
Nurse executives in these positions are predominantly female, typically over the age of 46, and married. Ethnicity was underrepresented in the studies Hemman reviewed, but available data placed the percentage of white nurses at approximately 70%, Black nurses at 3%, with other ethnicities comprising the remainder. Educationally, nurses in most of these positions were expected to hold an MSN or higher degree. The average length of time in a current position was approximately five years, though Hemman is quick to note that this is likely a reflection of the rapidly changing system rather than individual nurses' employment habits.
Stratified Systems Theory as a Leadership Framework
Hemman's rationale for conducting this research review was to fill a gap in the profile information on senior nurse executives with respect to stratified systems theory. As Hemman (2000) states, "The main implication of this study lies in the development of future leaders and managers." Profiling these professionals after some of the major changes in the healthcare system have occurred is, for Hemman and other healthcare professionals, important for understanding the needs of the executive system going forward, assessing the effectiveness of changes already made, and potentially identifying the need to revise current educational curricula for both new nurses and continuing education programs.
Hemman (2000) elaborates: "Leadership profiles can be incorporated in leadership education and training programs or any curriculum designed to prepare nursing leaders for executive level positions… leaders can use them to analyze their leadership patterns and also the profiles of their immediate supervisors."
Stratified systems theory is currently recognized as one of the most informative gauges for assessing the effectiveness of a leadership style at the positions being profiled. As Hemman (2000) notes, "These leader behaviors were developed by Yukl (1997) and consisted of a comprehensive classification of effective leader and manager behavior." The hierarchical nature of this framework is intended to help future executives understand the transitional nature of their roles. Each hierarchical stage of executive development requires that a progressively higher percentage of time be spent focused on the concerns of the higher leadership strata.
References
Hemman, E.A. (Jan./Feb. 2000). Leadership profiles of senior nurse executives. Canadian Journal of Nursing Leadership, 13(1).
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.